Denial of justice for failure to issue a formal decision

ATA/180/1998Cour de justice / Verwaltungskammer31.03.1998Granted

Von Omnilex extrahiert

Omnilex-Zusammenfassung

The insured person complained of a denial of justice in social insurance proceedings because the insurer had all necessary elements to decide but did not render a formal decision. The court upheld the appeal, holding that the failure to issue a decision constituted a denial of justice. The matter was therefore sent back in substance so that the insurer could decide formally.

Omnilex-Regeste

LAA art. 106; denial of justice where the insurer refrains from issuing a formal decision despite having sufficient elements to rule; an appeal is admissible and must be upheld when the administrative authority unlawfully leaves the claim pending instead of deciding it. The decisive criterion is not whether further investigation would be desirable, but whether the authority already disposes of the material necessary to render a decision (cf. consid. 1).

Gesamter Gesetzestext

Descripteurs

ASSURANCE SOCIALE; ACCIDENT; AA; DROIT D'OBTENIR UNE DECISION; PROCEDURE ADMINISTRATIVE; ASSU

Normes

LAA.106

Résumé

Recours pour déni de justice admis car l'assureur qui disposait des éléments pour statuer, n'a pas rendu de décision formelle.

Schlagwörter

social insuranceaccidentdenial of justiceformal decisionadministrative procedure

Von Omnilex extrahiert

Von Omnilex extrahierte Kernrechtsfragen

Kernrechtsfrage

Whether the insurer committed a denial of justice by failing to issue a formal decision despite having sufficient information to decide.

Extrahierter Entscheid

Yes. The appeal was upheld because the insurer should have issued a formal decision and did not do so.

Extrahierte Begründung

An authority may not leave a matter undecided when it already has the elements needed to rule; the absence of a formal decision constitutes a denial of justice.

Denial of justice for failure to issue a formal decisionKI-generiert