n-04-12.pdf

Preserve advance releases and the authoritative Internal Revenue Bulletin rendition; directory timestamps are file-publication metadata, not legal effective dates. HTML bulletins begin June 2003; earlier available issues require full PDF parsing.

This collection currently includes the publisher’s available advance-release directory. Historical bulletin renditions are discovered separately; an advance-release record alone does not certify the collection archive complete.

Part III - Administrative, Procedural, and Miscellaneous

Proposed Revenue Procedure Regarding Services that Qualify For the Student FICA
Exception

Notice 2004-12

I. Overview and Purpose

This notice contains a proposed revenue procedure providing a safe harbor that
certain institutions of higher education, and certain affiliated organizations can use in
applying the exception for services performed by a student provided under §
3121(b)(10) of the Internal Revenue Code (student FICA exception). A previous version
of this safe harbor was issued in Rev. Proc. 98-16, 1998-1 C.B. 403. However, the
Service has recently proposed amendments to the Employment Tax Regulations
interpreting § 3121(b)(10) in order to clarify specific issues that have arisen with
taxpayers and in litigation (see proposed regulations § 31.3121(b)(10)-2(c), (d), and (e)
published in the Federal Register on February 25, 2004 (69 Fed. Reg. 8604)). In order
to provide guidance that is consistent with the proposed regulations in all respects, the
Service is suspending Rev. Proc. 98-16 and proposing to replace it with the revenue
procedure contained in this notice.
The proposed revenue procedure updates the safe harbor of Rev. Proc. 98-16 in
several respects that align it with the proposed regulations. First, the proposed revenue

procedure adds a primary function requirement to the definition of an institution of
higher education. Section 3121(b)(10) applies only to services performed in the employ
of a school, college or university, or an affiliated § 509(a)(3) organization. Under the
proposed regulations and the new safe harbor, an organization can be a school, college
or university only if its primary function is to conduct educational activities. Thus, in
order to take advantage of the safe harbor in the revenue procedure, an institution must
satisfy not only the Department of Education’s regulations at 34 C.F.R. § 600.4 and
satisfy the accreditation requirements of 34 C.F.R. § 600.2, as was required in Rev.
Proc. 98-16, but also must have education and instruction as its primary function. The
primary function requirement may make the exception under § 3121(b)(10) unavailable
to certain institutions of higher education that are embedded within a larger organization
like a hospital or museum.
Second, the proposed revenue procedure does not permit an institution to apply
the student FICA exception to services performed by an employee who regularly works
40 or more hours per week. Under the existing regulations, services fall within the
student FICA exception only if they are performed incident to and for the purpose of
pursuing a course of study. The proposed regulations clarify that an individual who
regularly works forty or more hours per week has the status of a career employee, and,
accordingly, is not performing services incident to and for the purpose of pursuing a
course of study. The proposed revenue procedure follows the proposed regulations.
The student FICA exception generally, and the safe harbor provided by the proposed
revenue procedure specifically, are still available for services performed by an

2

employee who on occasion works 40 or more hours per week and otherwise meets the
requirements of the safe harbor.
Third, the proposed revenue procedure provides that an individual has career
employee status if the individual is a “professional employee.” The proposed
regulations provide that a professional employee for purposes of the student FICA
exception is an employee whose primary duty consists of the performance of services
requiring knowledge of an advanced type in a field of science or learning, whose work
requires the consistent exercise of discretion and judgment in its performance, and
whose work is predominantly intellectual and varied in character. The proposed
revenue procedure follows the proposed regulations.
Fourth, the proposed revenue procedure expands the terms of employment that
result in status as a career employee. Rev. Proc. 98-16 provided that an individual was
to be considered a career employee if the employee was eligible to participate in one of
several types of retirement plans, eligible for reduced tuition (with certain exceptions), or
otherwise classified by the institution of higher education as a career employee. The
proposed regulations adopt the same criteria for identifying individuals who have the
status of a career employee and adds to the list eligibility for a number of other benefits.
The proposed revenue procedure follows the proposed regulations, adding the
additional criteria that cause an individual to have career employee status and fall
outside the scope of the safe harbor. Employees considered as having the status of a
career employee per se cannot have the status of a student for purposes of the student
FICA exception.

3

Fifth, and finally, the proposed revenue procedure provides that an employee has
career employee status if the individual is required to be licensed under state or local
law in order to perform the services the individual provides to the school, college or
university. The proposed revenue procedure follows the proposed regulation.

II. Request for Comments
Comments are requested on the proposed revenue procedure. Comments may
be submitted on or before May 25, 2004, to Internal Revenue Service, PO Box 7604,
Washington, DC 20044, Attn: CC:PA:LPD:PR (Notice 2004-12), Room 5203.
Submissions may also be hand-delivered Monday through Friday between the hours of
8 a.m. and 4 p.m. to the Courier=s Desk at 1111 Constitution Avenue, NW., Washington,
DC 20224, Attn: CC:PA:LPD:PR (Notice 2004-12), Room 5203. Submissions may also
be sent electronically via the internet to the following email address:
Notice.comments@irscounsel.treas.gov
. Include the notice number (Notice 2004-12) in
the subject line.
III. Effect on Other Documents

Rev. Proc. 98-16 is suspended effective February 25, 2004.

IV. Effective Date

The Service intends to issue a final revenue procedure at the same time that the
proposed regulations under § 3121(b)(10) are finalized. Until a final version of the
proposed revenue procedure is issued, taxpayers may rely on the proposed revenue
procedure with respect to services performed on or after February 25, 2004 (the date

4

prop. Reg. § 31.3121(b)(10)-2(c) - (f) (69 FR 8604) was published in the Federal
Register).
V. Proposed Revenue Procedure
SECTION 1. PURPOSE
This revenue procedure sets forth generally applicable standards for determining
whether service in the employ of certain public or private nonprofit schools, colleges,
universities, or affiliated organizations described in § 509(a)(3) of the Internal Revenue
Code (the Code) performed by a student qualifies for the exception from Federal
Insurance Contributions Act (FICA) tax provided under § 3121(b)(10) of the Code
(Student FICA exception). These standards are intended to provide objective and
administrable guidelines for determining employment tax liability.
SECTION 2. SCOPE
.01 Institutions of higher education typically distinguish between career employees and
student employees. Sections 5 and 6 of this revenue procedure contain generally
applicable standards for determining whether or not services performed by employees
of certain institutions of higher education are eligible for the Student FICA exception.
.02 The standards contained in this revenue procedure do not apply to employees who
are postdoctoral students, postdoctoral fellows, medical residents, or medical interns
because the services performed by these employees cannot be assumed to be incident
to and for the purpose of pursuing a course of study. The employment activities of
these individuals overlaps with the activities comprising the course of study, and thus it
is not appropriate to apply the standards of this revenue procedure to these individuals.

5

.03 The standards contained in this revenue procedure may not constitute the exclusive
method for determining whether the Student FICA exception applies. If the standard for
qualifying for the exclusion described in section 6 of this revenue procedure (providing
generally that an employee enrolled at least half-time at an institution of higher
education has the status of student) is not met, whether or not service in the employ of
a school, college, university, or affiliated organization described in § 509(a)(3) of the
Code will qualify for the Student FICA exception will depend on consideration of all the
facts and circumstances.
SECTION 3. BACKGROUND
.01 Sections 3101 and 3111 of the Code impose social security and Medicare taxes
(FICA taxes) on employees and employers, respectively, equal to a percentage of the
wages received by an individual with respect to employment.
.02 Section 3121(a) of the Code defines "wages" for purposes of FICA taxes as all
remuneration for employment, with certain exceptions. Section 3121(b) of the Code
defines "employment" as services performed by an employee for an employer, with
certain exceptions.
.03 Section 3121(b)(10) of the Code excepts from the definition of employment services
performed in the employ of a school, college, or university (whether or not that
organization is exempt from income tax), or an affiliated organization described in §
509(a)(3) of the Code, if the services are performed by a student who is enrolled and
regularly attending classes at that school, college or university. Remuneration for
services excluded from the definition of employment under § 3121(b)(10) of the Code is

6

not subject to FICA taxes.
.04 Section 31.3121(b)(10)-2 of the Employment Tax Regulations provides that whether
an employee has the status of a student is determined on the basis of the employee's
relationship with the school, college, or university for which the services are being
performed. An employee who performs services in the employ of a school, college, or
university as an incident to and for the purpose of pursuing a course of study at the
school, college, or university has the status of a student in the performance of those
services. Services that are not incident to and for the purpose of pursuing a course of
study do not qualify for the exception. If the employee performs services as an incident
to and for the purpose of pursuing a course of study and, therefore, has the status of a
student, the amount of remuneration for services performed by the employee, the type
of services performed by the employee, and the place where the services are performed
are immaterial for purposes of the Student FICA exception.
.05 Section 218 of the Social Security Act (the Act), 42 U.S.C. section 418, allows states
to provide Social Security coverage for services performed by students for the public
school the student is attending under agreements established with the Social Security
Administration. If a state has exercised its option under § 218 of the Act to provide for
coverage of student services, § 3121(b)(10) of the Code provides that those services
will not qualify for the Student FICA exception.
SECTION 4. CERTAIN INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDUCATION
.01 The standards contained in this revenue procedure apply to “institutions of higher

7

education” meeting the requirements of § 31.3121(b)(10)-2(c) of the proposed
Employment Tax Regulations. For purposes of this revenue procedure, the term
"institution of higher education" includes any public or private nonprofit school, college,
university within the meaning of prop. Reg. § 31.3121(b)(10)-2(c), or affiliated
organization described in § 509(a)(3) of the Code, that meets the requirements set forth
in Department of Education regulations at 34 C.F.R. § 600.4, as amended from time to
time, and that is accredited or preaccredited by a nationally recognized accrediting
agency as defined in the Department of Education regulations at 34 C.F.R. § 600.2.
.02 Services for other institutions may also be eligible for the Student FICA exception.
Thus, for example, services performed by a student for a secondary school may be
eligible for the Student FICA exception. Whether or not services for other institutions,
such as secondary schools, qualify for the Student FICA exception is determined based
on the facts and circumstances of each case.
SECTION 5. STUDENT FICA EXCEPTION NOT AVAILABLE FOR EMPLOYEES
WITH CAREER EMPLOYEE STATUS
.01 Services performed by individuals with career employee status are not eligible for
the Student FICA exception under the standard in section 6 of this revenue procedure
because their services are not incident to and for the purpose of pursuing a course of
study. See prop. Reg. § 31.3121(b)(10)-2(d)(3)(ii).
.02 Career employee status. Services of an employee with career employee status are
not incident to and for the purpose of pursuing a course of study. An employee may be
considered to have career employee status based on the employee’s hours worked,

8

whether the employee is a “professional employee,” the employee’s terms of
employment, or whether the employee is licensed under state or local law to work in the
field in which the employee performs services. These standards are set forth in prop.
Reg. § 31.3121(b)(10)-2(d)(3)(ii). An employee has career employee status if the
employee is described in paragraph (1), (2), (3), or (4) of this section.
(1) Hours worked. An employee has the status of a career employee if the employee
regularly performs services 40 hours or more per week.
(2) Professional employee. An employee has the status of a career employee if the
employee is a professional employee. A professional employee is an employee--
(a) Whose primary duty consists of the performance of work requiring knowledge of an
advanced type in a field of science or learning customarily acquired by a prolonged
course of specialized intellectual instruction and study, as distinguished from a general
academic education, from an apprenticeship, and from training in the performance of
routine mental, manual, or physical processes.
(b) Whose work requires the consistent exercise of discretion and judgment in its
performance; and
(c) Whose work is predominantly intellectual and varied in character (as opposed to
routine mental, manual, mechanical, or physical work) and is of such character that the
output produced or the result accomplished cannot be standardized in relation to a
given period of time.
(3) Terms of employment. An employee’s terms of employment may indicate that the
employee has career employee status. An employee with career employee status

9

includes any employee who is--
(a) Eligible to receive vacation, sick leave, or paid holiday benefits;
(b) Eligible to participate in any retirement plan described in § 401(a) of the Code that is
established or maintained by the employer; or would be eligible to participate if age and
service requirements were met;
(c) Eligible to participate in an arrangement described in § 403(b) of the Code, or would
be eligible to participate if age and service requirements were met;
(d) Eligible to participate in a plan described under § 457(a), or would be eligible to
participate if age and service requirements were met;
(e) Eligible for reduced tuition (other than qualified tuition reduction under § 117(d)(5) of
the Code provided to a teaching or research assistant who is a graduate student)
because of the individual's employment relationship with the institution;
(f) Eligible to receive employee benefits described under § 79 (life insurance), 127
(qualified educational assistance), 129 (dependent care assistance programs), or 137
(adoption assistance); or
(g) Classified by the employer as a career employee.
(4) Licensure
. An employee is a career employee if the employee is required to be
licensed under state or local law to work in the field in which the employee performs
services.
.03 If an individual performs services in multiple job positions, the individual will be
deemed to have career employee status with respect to all of the positions if the
individual has career employee status in any one or more of the job positions.

10

SECTION 6. STANDARDS APPLICABLE TO UNDERGRADUATE AND GRADUATE
STUDENTS
.01 An individual who is a half-time undergraduate student or a half-time graduate or
professional student and who does not have the status of a career employee will qualify
for the Student FICA exception under this revenue procedure with respect to services
performed at or for an institution of higher education described in section 4 of this
revenue procedure in which they are enrolled or at affiliated organizations described in
§ 509(a)(3) of the Code. Services performed by a student for any other employer are
not covered by the standards of this revenue procedure.
.02 An individual is deemed to be a half-time undergraduate or half-time graduate or
professional student if the individual does not have the status of a career employee
status and is an undergraduate or graduate student who is in the last semester,
trimester, or quarter of a course of study requiring at least two semesters, trimesters, or
quarters to complete and is enrolled in the number of credit or unit hours needed to
complete the requirements for obtaining a degree, certificate, or other recognized
educational credential offered by that institution of higher education even if enrolled in
less than half the number required of full-time students.
.03 The determination of student status should be made at the end of the drop-add
period and may be adjusted thereafter at the institution of higher education’s option. The
determination of student status for payroll periods ending before the end of the drop-add
period may be based on the number of semester, trimester, or quarter hours being
taken at the end of the registration period for that semester, trimester, or quarter.

11

.04 If an individual is described in section 6.01 or 6.02 of this revenue procedure,
services performed by the individual are eligible for the Student FICA exception with
respect to all services performed during all payroll periods of a month or less that fall
wholly or partially within the academic term.
.05 The Student FICA exception does not apply to services performed by an individual
who is not enrolled in classes during school breaks of more than five weeks (including
summer breaks of more than five weeks), other than services described in section 6.04.
See Rev. Rul. 72-142, 1972-1 C.B. 317, and Rev. Rul. 74-109, 1974-1 C.B. 288.
However, the Student FICA exception applies to employment which continues during
normal school breaks of 5 weeks or less during which the individual is not eligible for the
Student FICA exception pursuant to section 6.01 of this revenue procedure provided
that the individual qualifies for the Student FICA exception pursuant to section 6.01 of
this revenue procedure on the last day of classes or examinations preceding the break
and is eligible to enroll in classes for the first academic period following the break.
.06 If the standards of this revenue procedure are met (and section 8 does not apply),
the amount of remuneration for services performed by the employee, the type of
services performed by the employee, and the place where the services are performed
are immaterial. If the services performed by a student otherwise described in section
6.01 or 6.02 are covered under an agreement pursuant to section 218 of the Act, the
Student FICA exception does not apply.
.07 For provisions relating to domestic service performed by a student in a local college
club, or local chapter of a college fraternity or sorority, see § 31.3121(b)(2)-1.

12

SECTION 7. DEFINITIONS
For purposes of the standard contained in section 6 of this revenue procedure, the
following definitions must be used. For purposes of the following definitions, the term
“institution of higher education” means an institution of higher education as defined in
section 4 of this revenue procedure.
.01 Undergraduate student. The term "undergraduate student" has the meaning
attributed to that term in the Department of Education regulations at 34 C.F.R. section
674.2.
.02 Half-time undergraduate student. The term "half-time undergraduate student" has
the meaning attributed to that term in the Department of Education regulations at 34
C.F.R. section 674.2.
.03 Graduate or professional student. The term "graduate or professional student"
means a student who--
(1) is enrolled at an institution of higher education for the purpose of obtaining a degree,
certificate, or other recognized educational credential above the baccalaureate level or
is enrolled in a program leading to a professional degree;
(2) has completed the equivalent of at least three years of full-time study at an institution
of higher education, either prior to entrance into the program or as part of the program
itself; and
(3) is not a postdoctoral student, postdoctoral fellow, medical resident, or medical
intern.
.04 Half-time graduate or professional student. The term "half-time graduate or

13

professional student" means an enrolled graduate or professional student, as defined in
section 7.03 of this revenue procedure, who is carrying at least a half-time academic
workload at an institution of higher education as determined by that institution according
to its own standards and practices.
SECTION 8. ANTI-ABUSE RULE
The standards in this revenue procedure must be applied in a reasonable manner,
consistent with the purpose of excluding from employment only services that are
performed as an incident to and for the purpose of pursuing a course of study at an
institution of higher education as defined in section 4 of this revenue procedure. If the
standards are inappropriately applied in a manner that conflicts with this underlying
purpose so as to manipulate or mischaracterize the nature of the relationship between
an employee and an institution of higher education, resulting in the improper avoidance
of payment of FICA taxes, then whether the Student FICA exception applies will be
determined on the basis of all the facts and circumstances, rather than on the basis of
the specific standards set forth in section 6 of this revenue procedure. For example, the
standards would be inappropriately applied through the manipulation of the relationship
between employees and the institution of higher education if a university claimed that
the Student FICA exception applied to research laboratory workers, who had been
career employees, but were converted to non-career status and required to enroll in a
certificate program granting six credit hours per semester for work experience in the
laboratory. As another example, if an individual who was not a student worked for a
university on a full-time basis for many years, in a job generally performed by non-

14

students (but nonetheless failed to meet the literal definition of career employee), and
then enrolled at the university for six credit hours of course work per semester while
continuing the full-time work in the same job, it may not be appropriate to apply the
standards of this revenue procedure to conclude that the individual's work has become
incident to and for the purpose of pursuing a course of study solely because the
individual enrolled for this course work. In both of these examples, whether the work is
performed incident to and for the purpose of pursuing a course of study must be
determined on the basis of all the relevant facts and circumstances.
SECTION 9. EFFECTIVE DATE
This revenue procedure is effective for services performed on or after February 25,
2004 (the date prop. Reg. § 31.3121(b)(10)-2(c) - (f) (69 FR 8604) was published in the
Federal Register).
The principal author of this notice is Stephen D. Suetterlein of the Office of
Associate Chief Counsel (Tax Exempt & Government Entities). However, other
personnel from the Service and Treasury Department participated in the development of
this notice. For further information regarding this notice contact Mr. Suetterlein at (202)
622-6040 (not a toll-free call).

15