Key legal question
Whether the public law appeal is admissible in the absence of a legal entitlement to renewal of the residence permit.
Extracted holding
The appeal is inadmissible because Art. 44 AuG does not confer a right to a residence permit, and no other enforceable entitlement was shown.
Extracted reasoning
Under Art. 83 lit. c no. 2 BGG, public law appeals are excluded where no federal or international right to the permit exists. Art. 44 AuG is not an entitlement norm, and Art. 50 AuG does not help when no original entitlement under Art. 42 or 43 AuG existed.