Key legal question
Whether the federal appeal satisfied the requirements for relief and reasoning under Art. 42 LTF
Extracted holding
No. The appeal contained only cassatory conclusions and did not set out specific reasons or requested changes to the judgment.
Extracted reasoning
In an appeal in public law matters, the remedy is reformative; the appellant must seek substantive relief and explain briefly why the challenged decision is unlawful. A bare request for annulment is insufficient.