The AI workspace for legal professionals
Try it free for 14 days (10 questions/day during trial)
ATA/78/1998•Inflatable tennis hall not permitted in green zone
ATA/78/1998Court of Justice / Administrative ChamberFeb 10, 1998Dismissed
Extracted by Omnilex
A tennis club applied to build an inflatable tennis hall in a green zone. The court held that, despite the zone's sports mention, such a hall is not compatible with the green zone because its size and nature go beyond light sports installations. It should be located in a sports zone instead. A derogation was also denied because the structure is not imposed by its destination. The application was therefore dismissed.
LALAT art. 24; compatibility of a construction with a green zone containing a sports designation and conditions for derogation. An inflatable tennis hall, by reason of its dimensions and character, is not a light sports installation admissible in a green zone. The mere presence of a sports mention does not transform the zoning into a sports zone. A derogation is excluded where the structure is not imposed by its destination and ought to be sited in a sports zone; the zoning purpose and the scale of the installation remain decisive.
Descripteurs
CONSTRUCTION ET INSTALLATION; ZONE DE VERDURE; COURT DE TENNIS; ESTHETIQUE; ZONE SPORTIVE; TPE
Normes
LALAT.24 al
Résumé
La construction d'une halle de tennis gonflable n'est pas conforme à la zone de verdure, même si cette dernière comprend une mention "sportive". Cette halle n'a pas, au vu de ses dimensions, un caractère d'installations sportives légères, lesquelles pourraient être autorisées dans cette zone. Cette halle devrait trouver place en zone sportive, ce qui n'est pas le cas. Une dérogation n'est pas possible (implantation de l'ouvrage non imposé par sa destination).
Extracted by Omnilex
Whether an inflatable tennis hall may be authorized in a green zone that includes a sports designation.
No. The planned hall is incompatible with the green zone, even if the zone also has a sports designation.
Given its dimensions and overall characteristics, the hall cannot be treated as a light sports installation that might be allowed in that zone.
Whether a derogation could be granted for the inflatable tennis hall.
No. A derogation is unavailable because the structure is not required by its destination and should instead be located in a sports zone.
The legal conditions for a derogation were not met, in particular because the building is not imposed by its purpose and is intended for a sports zone rather than the green zone.
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.