The AI workspace for legal professionals
Try it free for 14 days (10 questions/day during trial)
52.1999.207•Appeal struck off as moot; prior decision annulled
52.1999.207Other CourtOct 4, 1999Dismissed
Extracted by Omnilex
The appellant challenged a 21 July 1999 decision of the CV-LEPIC before the Ticino Administrative Court. In its response of 1 September 1999, the authority accepted the appeal. The court therefore held that the proceedings had become moot, struck the appeal from the docket, annulled the challenged decision, waived court fees and costs, and ordered the CV-LEPIC to pay CHF 250 in party compensation because the appellant had been forced to litigate to obtain the requested relief.
Administrative appeal becomes moot when the challenged authority fully adheres to the appellant's request in its response; the court then strikes the proceedings off the docket and annuls the contested decision. Where the appellant had to seize the court in order to obtain the desired relief, an award of party compensation is justified even if no court costs are levied (consid. implicit).
AIUTO RICERCA
Anteprima di stampa
Numero d'incarto: 52.1999.207
Data decisione, Autorità: 04.10.1999, TRAM
Incarto n. 52.99.00207
Lugano 4 ottobre 1999
In nome della Repubblica e Cantone del Ticino
Il presidente del Tribunale cantonale amministrativo
Lorenzo Anastasi
assistito dal segretario:
Leopoldo Crivelli
statuendo sul ricorso 27 luglio 1999 della
__________, patr. da: avv. __________,
contro
la decisione 21 luglio 1999 della Commissione di vigilanza per l'applicazione della legge sull'esercizio della professione di impresario costruttore (CV-LEPIC);
preso atto che con la risposta 1º settembre 1999, la CV-LEPIC, ha aderito al ricorso;
ritenuto che la ricorrente ha dovuto adire il Tribunale cantonale amministrativo per soddisfare la sua richiesta, per cui si giustifica la corresponsione di un'indennità per ripetibili;
considerato pertanto che il procedimento è divenuto privo d'oggetto;
decreta:
§. La decisione 21 luglio 1999 della CV-LEPIC è pertanto annullata.
La CV-LEPIC verserà alla ricorrente fr. 250.-- a titolo di ripetibili.
Il presidente del Tribunale cantonale amministrativo
Il segretario
Ultimo aggiornamento: 02.07.2026
| Informazioni legali | Requisiti minimi | Contatta il webmaster
Extracted by Omnilex
Whether the appeal remained live after the respondent authority accepted it.
The proceedings had become moot and the appeal had to be struck from the docket.
Because the CV-LEPIC adhered to the appeal in its response, the appellant's request was satisfied and no further judicial determination was necessary.
Whether the prior CV-LEPIC decision should be annulled.
The challenged 21 July 1999 decision was annulled.
Once the appeal had become moot through the authority's adherence, the prior decision could no longer stand.
Whether costs and compensation for legal expenses should be awarded.
No court fees or costs were charged, and the respondent authority had to pay CHF 250 in party compensation to the appellant.
The appellant had to bring the matter before the Administrative Court to obtain the requested relief, which justified an award of legal compensation.
Connect Omnilex to search the legal corpus from your AI assistant.