rr-12-04.pdf

Preserve advance releases and the authoritative Internal Revenue Bulletin rendition; directory timestamps are file-publication metadata, not legal effective dates. HTML bulletins begin June 2003; earlier available issues require full PDF parsing.

This collection currently includes the publisher’s available advance-release directory. Historical bulletin renditions are discovered separately; an advance-release record alone does not certify the collection archive complete.

Part I

Section 401.—Qualified Pension, Profit-sharing, and Stock Bonus Plans
(Also, §§ 411, 415; 26 CFR 1.401(a)(31), 1.411(a)-4, 1.411(a)-4T, 1.411(c)-1,
1.415(b)-1.)

Rollover from qualified defined contribution plan to qualified defined
benefit plan to obtain additional annuity

Rev. Rul. 2012-4

ISSUES

(1) Does a qualified defined benefit pension plan that accepts a direct rollover
of an eligible rollover distribution from a qualified defined contribution plan
maintained by the same employer satisfy §§ 411 and 415 of the Internal
Revenue Code in a case in which the defined benefit plan provides an
annuity resulting from the direct rollover that is determined by converting
the amount directly rolled over into an actuarially equivalent immediate
annuity using the applicable interest rate and the applicable mortality table
under § 417(e)?

(2) How does the result vary if the defined benefit plan applies different
conversion factors for purposes of calculating the annuity resulting from
the amount directly rolled over?

FACTS

Plan A is a profit-sharing plan sponsored by Employer X that is qualified under
§ 401(a). Plan A satisfies the requirements under § 401(a)(11)(B)(iii) to be
exempted from the qualified joint and survivor annuity and qualified preretirement
survivor annuity rules of § 401(a)(11). Plan A does not provide for after-tax
employee contributions.

Plan B is a qualified defined benefit plan also sponsored by Employer X. Plan B
permits benefits to commence at any time after separation from service and
offers various optional forms of benefit. Plan B complies with all otherwise
applicable rules under § 401(a), including the rules of §§ 401(a)(11), 411(a)(11),
and 417 with respect to distributions and does not apply the rule of
§ 411(a)(11)(D) (i.e., does not disregard rollover contributions for purposes of
mandatory distributions of small amounts). As permitted under § 411(a)(3)(A),
Plan B provides that, except to the extent of the qualified preretirement survivor

2
annuity, the accrued benefit resulting from employer contributions is forfeited on
the death of the participant. Plan B provides that a participant can elect to
commence a distribution between 30 days and 180 days after the furnishing of
the QJSA explanation that is required pursuant to § 417(a)(3). Plan B does not
permit participants to elect a retroactive annuity starting date as provided under
§ 417(a)(7).

Plan B provides that it will accept a direct rollover from Plan A for any employee
or former employee of Employer X who separates from service after age 55 with
at least 10 years of service. Plan B will accept direct rollovers from Plan A with
respect to an employee or former employee only if the individual is electing or
has elected to commence receiving benefits from Plan B and the election
specifies a single annuity starting date for all of the employee’s or former
employee’s benefits under Plan B (including the additional benefit resulting from
the direct rollover, which is determined as described below).

Neither Plan A nor Plan B is a governmental plan, a nonelecting church plan, or
another plan to which § 411 does not apply under § 411(e)(1). Plan B does not
contain a qualified cost-of-living arrangement within the meaning of § 415(k)(2).

Participant P’s employment with Employer X terminates, and Participant P elects
a distribution from Participant P’s Plan A account balance that is made in the
form of a direct rollover to Plan B. Participant P elects to receive payment of the
benefit attributable to the rollover in the form of an annuity from Plan B. For the
entire plan year that includes the date of the rollover, Plan B’s adjusted funding
target attainment percentage under § 436(j)(2) is at least 60 percent. Participant
P is over age 55 and has at least 10 years of service with Employer X.

Plan B provides that if a participant in both Plan A and Plan B elects a direct
rollover from Plan A to Plan B and elects to use that direct rollover amount to
obtain an immediate straight life or other form of annuity from Plan B, then the
amount of that annuity is determined as the actuarial equivalent of the amount
rolled over from Plan A, where actuarial equivalence is determined using the
applicable interest rate and mortality table under § 417(e). A package of election
forms is used for the distribution from Plan A, the election of a direct rollover to
Plan B, and the election of an immediate annuity from Plan B. The package
provides for notarized spousal consent if the participant is married and elects a
distribution from Plan B that is not a qualified joint and survivor annuity, and is
accompanied by a disclosure that includes a statement that if Plan B terminates
with insufficient funds to cover its benefit liabilities, the benefit resulting from the
direct rollover will be subject to Title IV of the Employee Retirement Income
Security Act of 1974 (ERISA), Public Law 93-406, and a description of the

3
maximum benefit limitation and other relevant Title IV limitations on guaranteed
benefits.
1

Plan B provides that if a participant in both Plan A and Plan B elects a direct
rollover from Plan A to Plan B but the annuity starting date is after the time of the
direct rollover (which could occur under Plan B if the annuity starting date elected
by a participant is not more than 180 days after the date of the election notice
provided under Plan B), then the amount of the annuity is determined by crediting
the amount directly rolled over with interest at 120 percent of the Federal mid-
term rate under § 1274 until the annuity starting date and then converting the
resulting amount to an actuarially equivalent immediate annuity using the
applicable interest rate and the applicable mortality table under § 417(e) that
apply at that later annuity starting date.

If a participant under Plan B dies before the annuity starting date, a benefit equal
to any amount directly rolled over by the participant to Plan B from Plan A (plus
interest as described above) will be paid from Plan B to the participant’s
beneficiary, which is in addition to the death benefit under Plan B that would be
paid if no amount had been directly rolled over to Plan B. However, if such a
participant is married at the time of death and the participant did not waive (with
notarized spousal consent) the qualified preretirement survivor annuity payable in
accordance with §§ 401(a)(11) and 417, then the death benefit instead is a life
annuity to the surviving spouse that is actuarially equivalent to the amount
directly rolled over to Plan B from Plan A (plus interest as described above)
determined using the applicable interest rate and mortality table under § 417(e),
which is also in addition to the death benefit under Plan B that would be paid if no
amount had been directly rolled over to Plan B.

LAW

Section 401(a)(7) requires that a qualified plan satisfy the requirements of § 411.
Section 401(a)(16) requires that a qualified plan not provide for benefits or
contributions that exceed the limitations of § 415.

Section 401(a)(31) requires that a participant in a qualified plan be permitted to
elect to have a distribution made in the form of a direct rollover to another eligible
retirement plan if the distribution qualifies as an eligible rollover distribution.
Section 1.401(a)(31)-1, A-15, of the Income Tax Regulations provides that, for
purposes of applying the plan qualification requirements of § 401(a), a direct
rollover is a distribution and rollover of the eligible rollover distribution (rather

1
The Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation (PBGC) has informed the Service
that Title IV generally applies to benefits resulting from a rollover, and is
developing guidance on the Title IV treatment of such benefits, including
guarantee limitations under section 4022 of ERISA and asset allocation under
section 4044(a) of ERISA.

4
than a transfer of assets and liabilities). Section 1.401(a)(31)-1, A-13, provides
that a qualified plan is not required to accept rollovers or it can provide that it will
accept rollovers under limited circumstances.

Section 411(a)(1) requires that the accrued benefit derived from an employee’s
contributions be nonforfeitable. Section 1.411(a)-4T provides that adjustments in
benefits, such as adjustments in excess of reasonable actuarial assumptions,
can result in an impermissible forfeiture of participants’ rights. Section 1.411(a)-
4(b)(1)(ii) provides that the benefit derived from employee contributions is not
treated as forfeitable merely because, after commencement of annuity payments,
the participant dies without receiving payments equal in amount to the
nonforfeitable accrued benefit derived from mandatory contributions determined
at the time of commencement.

Section 411(c)(2) prescribes rules for the determination of the accrued benefit
derived from employee contributions. Under § 411(c)(2)(B), in the case of a
qualified defined benefit plan, the accrued benefit derived from the contributions
made by an employee is equal to the accumulated contributions expressed as an
annual benefit commencing at normal retirement age, using an interest rate
which would be used under the plan under § 417(e)(3) (as of the determination
date). Section 411(c)(2)(C) defines accumulated contributions as the mandatory
contributions made by the employee, increased by interest. With respect to
periods during plan years beginning on or after January 1, 1988, the interest is
determined using the rate of 120 percent of the Federal mid-term rate under
§ 1274 for the first month of each plan year for the period ending on the date the
determination is being made, and using the interest rate under § 417(e)(3) for the
period between the determination date and the normal retirement age. Under
§ 411(c)(2)(C) and § 1.411(c)-1(c)(4), mandatory contributions are defined as
amounts contributed to the plan by the employee which are required as a
condition of employment, as a condition of participation in the plan, or as a
condition of obtaining benefits (or additional benefits) under the plan attributable
to employer contributions.

Section 411(c)(3) requires that, if the accrued benefit derived from employee
contributions is to be determined with respect to a benefit other than an annual
benefit in the form of a single life annuity (without ancillary benefits) commencing
at normal retirement age, the accrued benefit derived from contributions made by
the employee must be the actuarial equivalent of the amount determined under
§ 411(c)(2).

Section 415(a)(1)(A) provides that, in the case of a qualified defined benefit plan,
the associated trust will not be a qualified trust if the plan provides benefits with
respect to a participant in excess of the limitations under § 415(b). Section
415(b)(1) prescribes limitations that are based on the annual benefit determined
under § 415(b)(2). Section 415(b)(2)(B) provides for adjustments, in accordance

5
with regulations, to the benefit determined under the plan if employees contribute
or make rollover contributions to the plan.

Section 1.415(b)-1(b)(1) prescribes rules for the determination of the annual
benefit for purposes of § 415(b). Under § 1.415(b)-1(b)(1)(ii), the annual benefit
does not include the annual benefit attributable to rollover contributions as
described in § 401(a)(31). Section 1.415(b)-1(b)(2) provides rules for the
determination of the annual benefit attributable to rollover contributions. Under
§ 1.415(b)-1(b)(2)(iii), the annual benefit attributable to rollover contributions is
determined by applying the factors applicable to mandatory employee
contributions as described in § 411(c)(2)(B) and (C) and the regulations
thereunder.

Section 401(a)(29) requires that a qualified defined benefit plan (other than a
multiemployer plan) satisfy the requirements of § 436. Section 436 sets forth a
series of limitations on the accrual and payment of benefits under an
underfunded plan. Section 436(b) places limitations on the payment of plant
shutdown benefits and other unpredictable contingent event benefits; § 436(c)
places limitations on plan amendments that increase liabilities for benefits;
§ 436(d) places limitations on the payment of accelerated benefit distributions;
and § 436(e) places limitations on benefit accruals. These limitations are applied
based on the plan's adjusted funding target attainment percentage (AFTAP) for
the plan year, as certified by the plan's enrolled actuary.

ANALYSIS

Under § 1.401(a)(31)-1, A-15, an amount directly rolled over from Plan A to Plan
B is treated as if it were distributed to Participant P from Plan A and then rolled
over into Plan B. Accordingly, this amount is treated as contributed by
Participant P to Plan B. Furthermore, the contribution is required as a condition
of receiving additional benefits under Plan B attributable to employer
contributions. For example, if the employee lives longer than the life expectancy
under the mortality table used to calculate the annuity and there are no offsetting
actuarial gains or the plan earns less than the interest rate used to calculate the
annuity, the employer would be required to make contributions to provide the
additional benefits. Thus, under § 1.411(c)-1(c)(4), the amounts directly rolled
over are treated as mandatory contributions for purposes of § 411(c) and the
accrued benefit derived from those amounts, determined under the rules of
§ 411(c), must be nonforfeitable.

The benefit resulting from the direct rollover that Plan B provides as an
immediate annuity is determined as the actuarial equivalent of the amount rolled
over from Plan A, where actuarial equivalence is determined using the applicable
interest rate and mortality table under § 417(e). Furthermore, in the event of a
delay between the rollover and the annuity starting date, interest on the rollover
contribution is accumulated in accordance with the requirements of

6
§ 411(c)(2)(C)(iii). Thus, Plan B satisfies the requirements of § 411(c)(2) with
respect to the rollover.

Prior to the annuity starting date under Plan B, the benefit resulting from the
amount directly rolled over is not forfeitable, even if the participant were to die
prior to the annuity starting date. If the participant were to die after the annuity
starting date, the benefit resulting from the amount directly rolled over is not
treated as being forfeited as a result of the cessation of the annuity, even if the
participant dies prior to having received an amount equal to the amount rolled
over to Plan B from Plan A plus interest as described above.

Accordingly, Plan B’s provisions relating to the benefit resulting from the amount
directly rolled over satisfy the requirement of § 411(a)(1) that the benefit derived
from an employee’s own contributions be nonforfeitable. In addition, the Plan B
benefit resulting from the amount directly rolled over is excluded from Participant
P’s annual benefit for purposes of § 415(b). This is because, under § 1.415(b)-
1(b), the annual benefit for purposes of § 415(b) excludes the benefit attributable
to rollover contributions, determined using the rules of § 411(c)(2)(B) and (C),
and the Plan B benefit resulting from the amount directly rolled over is
determined using the rules of § 411(c)(2)(B) and (C).

However, if Plan B were to use a less favorable actuarial basis (such as an
interest rate that is lower than the applicable interest rate under § 417(e)(3)(C) or
a mortality table with longer life expectancies than the applicable mortality table
under § 417(e)(3)(B)) to determine the amount of an annuity resulting from the
amount rolled over, Plan B would not satisfy the requirement under § 411(a)(1)
that the benefit derived from an employee’s own contributions be nonforfeitable.

By contrast, if Plan B were to use a more favorable actuarial basis (such as a
higher interest rate than the § 417(e)(3)(C) applicable interest rate or a mortality
table with shorter life expectancies than the applicable § 417(e)(3)(B) mortality
table) for purposes of calculating the annuity resulting from the rollover amount,
or otherwise provided for a larger annuity than the annuity derived from
employee contributions as determined under § 411(c), then the portion of the
Plan B benefit resulting from the amount directly rolled over that exceeds the
benefit derived from that rolled over amount under the rules of § 411(c)(2)(B) is
not treated as the benefit derived from the employee’s own contributions and
there are other considerations which must be taken into account. For example,
the liability for additional benefits under Plan B will likely be greater than the
assets transferred to the Plan (which means that the employer will become
responsible for additional funding costs). Similarly, the excess portion would be
included in the annual benefit for purposes of § 415(b). In addition, any benefit
that exceeds the actuarial equivalent of the amount directly rolled over
(determined using reasonable actuarial assumptions) would not be treated as
attributable to the rollover within the meaning of § 1.401(a)(4)-11(b)(1), and,

7
accordingly, would be taken into account in applying the nondiscriminatory
amount requirement of § 1.401(a)(4)-1(b)(2).

The election procedures under Plans A and B that are described in the facts of
this revenue ruling satisfy the requirements of §§ 401(a)(11), 411(a)(11), and
417.

If Plan B’s certified or presumed AFTAP were to drop below 60%, Plan B would
not be permitted to receive direct rollover contributions from Plan A because
such rollover contributions would give rise to additional benefit accruals that are
not permitted under § 436(e).

The analysis in this revenue ruling would be the same if Plan B allowed the
annuity resulting from the amount directly rolled over to have an annuity starting
date that differs from the annuity starting date for the remainder of the Plan B
benefits.

HOLDINGS

(1) Under the facts presented, a qualified defined benefit plan that accepts a
direct rollover of an employee’s or former employee’s benefit from a
qualified defined contribution plan maintained by the same employer does
not violate § 411 or 415 if the defined benefit plan provides an annuity
resulting from the direct rollover that is determined by converting the
amount directly rolled over into an actuarially equivalent immediate
annuity using the applicable interest rate and applicable mortality table
under § 417(e).

(2) If a defined benefit plan were to provide an annuity resulting from the
rollover amount that is determined using a less favorable actuarial basis
than required under the rules of § 411(c) (so that the annuity is smaller
than required under the rules of § 411(c)), then the plan would not satisfy
the requirements of § 411(a)(1).

(3) If a defined benefit plan were to provide an annuity resulting from the
rollover amount that is determined using a more favorable actuarial basis
than required under the rules of § 411(c) (so that the annuity is larger than
required under the rules of § 411(c)), then the portion of the benefit
resulting from the amount directly rolled over that exceeds the benefit
derived from that rolled over amount under the rules of § 411(c)(2)(B)
would be subject to the non-forfeiture rules applicable to benefits derived
from employer contributions and would be included in the annual benefit
for purposes of § 415(b).

PROSPECTIVE APPLICATION

8
Pursuant to the authority provided by § 7805(b)(8), the holdings of this revenue
ruling do not apply with respect to rollovers made before January 1, 2013.
However, plan sponsors are permitted to rely on the holdings of this ruling with
respect to rollovers made prior to that date.

DRAFTING INFORMATION

The principal author of this revenue ruling is Carolyn E. Zimmerman of the
Employee Plans, Tax Exempt and Government Entities Division. Ms.
Zimmerman may be reached by e-mail at RetirementPlanQuestions@irs.gov.