Question juridique clé
Whether the public-law appeal met the reasoning requirements of Art. 90 OJ
Solution extraite
No. The filing contained no reference to any legal norm and no serious constitutional argument, so it did not satisfy the statutory substantiation requirement.
Motifs extraits
In public-law appeals, the Federal Tribunal is not a court of appeal and does not review the case ex officio. The appellant must clearly and specifically explain which constitutional rights were violated and how. That requirement was plainly not met.