Question juridique clé
Whether the 5-year expulsion under Art. 10 ANAG was lawful and proportionate
Solution extraite
Yes. The repeated convictions, long-term delinquency, and persistent financial irresponsibility justified expulsion, and a five-year ban was not excessive.
Motifs extraits
The applicant had accumulated serious and repeated offenses over many years, including property and sexual offenses, and showed no lasting compliance with the legal order. His debts, defaults, and welfare dependence also supported the expulsion ground under Art. 10(1)(b) ANAG. Given his age on entry, weak integration, and the family’s ability to follow him, the public interest prevailed.