Question juridique clé
Whether the public-law complaint against the non-renewal of the residence permit was admissible despite no apparent entitlement.
Solution extraite
The complaint was inadmissible because the appellant had no clear enforceable right to renewal.
Motifs extraits
Under Art. 83 lit. c ch. 2 BGG, public-law complaints are excluded where no right to the permit exists. The appellant no longer lived with his spouse, had not shown important reasons for separate households under Art. 49 AuG, and the record did not substantiate claims under Art. 50 AuG or any violation of federal law.