Question juridique clé
Whether the lease terminations were voidable as contrary to good faith because the landlord's personal-use motive was allegedly pretextual
Solution extraite
The terminations were not abusive; the landlord's wish to occupy the apartment personally was a legitimate and credible reason.
Motifs extraits
The relevant motive is assessed at the time of notice. The landlord's age, divorce, retirement, and housing situation made the stated intention plausible. The tenants did not prove that the personal-use ground was merely a pretext.