Question juridique clé
Whether the cantonal appeal procedure violated the right to a second level of jurisdiction
Solution extraite
No. A limited review of facts for arbitrariness is compatible with the guarantee of appeal; full factual review is not required.
Motifs extraits
The court held that neither Article 6 ECHR nor Article 32(3) of the Constitution requires a full re-examination of facts by the appellate court; review limited to law, with facts reviewed only for arbitrariness, is sufficient.