Question juridique clé
Whether the appeal against the distribution table decision was admissible despite not addressing the decisive reasons of the cantonal decision
Solution extraite
No. The appeal did not comply with the requirement to challenge the relevant and properly reasoned grounds of the contested decision.
Motifs extraits
The appellant mainly criticized the office's conduct and the facts, whereas the federal court is bound by the lower decision's factual findings and the appeal must meet the specific reasoning requirements of Art. 79(1) OJ.