Question juridique clé
Whether the later psychiatric medical certificates constituted new decisive facts or evidence justifying revision of the 2005 judgment
Solution extraite
No. The new certificates did not show objectively deficient findings or establish that a decisive earlier incapacity during the insured period had been proven.
Motifs extraits
Revision requires new facts or evidence that were previously unknown despite diligence and that would likely lead to a different judgment. The new reports were either too vague, merely re-evaluated known facts, or conflicted with contemporaneous records and the claimant’s work performance.