Study grant denied despite monthly support from father

ATA/553/1997Cour de justice / Chambre administrative23 sept. 1997

Extrait par Omnilex

Résumé Omnilex

The decision concerns entitlement to a study grant under Art. 19 LEE. The student relied on the exception for cases of a total and durable rupture with the parents. The court held that this condition was not met because the student still received CHF 600 per month from his father abroad. Regular financial support was considered evidence that the family tie had not been broken in the required sense.

Regeste Omnilex

Art. 19 LEE; rupture totale et durable avec les parents: l’existence d’une aide financière régulière versée par un parent exclut en principe la reconnaissance d’une rupture totale et durable au sens de la disposition. Le critère suppose une séparation effective et persistante des relations familiales, non seulement un éloignement géographique ou des relations affaiblies. Des versements mensuels réguliers, même modestes, sont incompatibles avec une absence complète de lien parental (consid. non précisé).

Texte intégral

Descripteurs

BOURSE D'ETUDES; FAMILLE; MENAGE COMMUN; IP

Normes

LEE.19 al.3 litt.b

Résumé

N'est pas en rupture totale et durable avec ses parents, au sens de l'art. 19 LEE, l'étudiant qui reçoit de son père à l'étranger frs 600.- par mois.

Mots-clés

study grantfamily relationshipparental supporthouseholdrupture with parents

Extrait par Omnilex

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Omnilex

Question juridique clé

Whether the student was in a total and durable rupture with his parents within the meaning of Art. 19 LEE despite receiving monthly support from his father abroad.

Solution extraite

No. Monthly financial support from the father indicated that the family relationship was not totally and durably severed.

Motifs extraits

A total and durable rupture with parents is incompatible with ongoing regular support payments from a parent, even if the parent lives abroad.

Study grant denied despite monthly support from fatherGénéré par IA