Nonprecedential Disposition

%KK*K%$"/K$K%($K-*K;K;K&&;K;K32;1
K
United States Court of Appeals
%(K*K,$*K(+*
%<K""$%)K60604 K
+#**K +"/K20<K2018GK
K +"/K30<K2018K
K
K
%(
K
K; K < K
K
K K; K < K
K
K K ; K ; K < K
K
K
%;K17H2567K
KKK <K
K <K
K K ;K
K <K
K ;K
K
&&"K (%#K *K $*K
**)K )*(*K %+(*K %(K *K
%(*($K )*(*K %K ""$%)<K
)*($K,)%$;K
K
%;K16KK2H1K
(")K;K %("<K;K
K
K
%$"K%-$K&"K+"*/K*%K*($)&%(*$K"K&%($%(&/<K18K;;;K
F2252>?>1?<K$K-)K)$*$K*%K15K/()CK#&()%$#$*;KK"$*K%K*K)$*$K
&$)K%$K$K$$#$*K+$(K18K;;;KF2252>?>1?<K-K&&")K*%K$/K&()%$K
-%K)KK%$,*%$KD+$(K*K"-)K%K$/K**K("*$K*%K(,*K).+"K+)<K
).+"K+)<K%(K+),K).+"K%$+*K$,%",$KK#$%(K%(K-(<K%(K*K&(%+*%$<K
KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK
G K *(K .#$$K *K ()K$K *K(%(<K-K ,K%$"+K **K %("K (+#$*K )K +$$))(/;K
K;K;K&&;K;K34>?>2?>?;K

-- 1 of 3 --

%;K17H2567K K2K
&%))))%$<K(&*<K#"$<K)"<K)*(+*%$<K)&#$*<K%(K*($)&%(**%$K%K"K&%(H
$%(&/<K%(K).K*(!$K%K"($E;K+)*%$K>?>1?K&(%,)K%(KK#$#+#K
*(#K%K15K/()K$KK#.#+#K%K40=K-*%+*K*K$$#$*K*K)**+*%(/K($K%(K
%-$K-%+"K,K$K5K*%K20K/();KK*(#K%K15K/()K)K-*$K%*K($)<K+*K/K
$$K*K$$#$*K&&""K*K)*(*K%+(*K$K*)K)(*%$;K>K +K
K$%*K)/K+$'+,%""/K**KK-%+"K,K#&%)KK15H/(K)$*$K-*%+*K("/H
$K%$K*K$$#$*K+$(K)+)*%$K>?>1?;?K
K
K)*(*K%+(*K%+$K**K$K1982K%-$KK$K%$,*K%K,%"*$K38K"";K
,;K**;KF11H5>?>3?K>1981?<K-K&(%*)K"-K*%+$K%KK";K -K*%+$K
*-$K#$%()K)K$%*K$%+K*%K""K%(K$K$$#$*K+$(K)+)*%$K>?>1?=K*K
).+"K%$+*K#+)*KKD+),EK>%(K"K-*K"K&%($%(&/K%(K).K*(!$K%K
"($?;KK)*(*K +K%$"+K**K*K$$#$*K$%$*"))K&&")<KH
+)K*K%$+*K**K"K*%K*K1982K%$,*%$K-) K+),;K$K($K*)K
%$"+)%$K*K +K("K%$K&%"K(%()K(*(K*$K*K)**K)**+*<K*K($K
&&()<K%(K*K*(#)K%K*K)**K%+(*C)K +#$*;K$K("/$K%$K(()*K(%()K*K +K
*%%!K%+$*K%K%+#$*)K**K*K+&(#K%+(*K"K)%+"K$%*KK%$)(;K
<K544K;;K13<K21I23K>2005?;K %(%,(<K*K%+(*K'+*KD"-EK
%$+*K-*KD+),EK%$+*K)&*KK)%$K%K*)K%+(*K( *$K**K'+*%$K
%(KK#*(""/K$*"K)**+*K$K$$;KK <K551K;3K718K
>7*K(;K2009?;K
K
$%(*+$*"/<K$%K%$K""K K*%K*K)*(*K +C)K**$*%$<K$K*K +K
")%KK$%*K#&"#$*K*K()*(*%$K#&%)K/K ;K$K*)K%+(*<K%-,(<K*K
&(%)+*%(K)K%$))K((%(;K+)K*K)**K%$,*%$K%+"K()*K%$K$%$H+),K
%$+*<K$K("K"-K#!)K*K&(%&(*/K%K(,)*K$$#$*)K&$K%$K*K
(#K%K%$,*%$K(*(K*$K-*K*K$$*K*+""/K<K)K
<K136K;K*;K2243K>2016?<K-K&*K*K%$))%$K$K(#$K%(K()$*$$;K
K
"*%+K*K%+(*K#+)*K$%*K$$K*K)$*$K+$(K)+)*%$K>?>1?<K*K(H
#$)K(K*%K%$)(K%-$C)K*+"K%$+*K-$K.()$K*)K)(*%$K*%K(*KK
)$*$<K-*$K*K($K%K5K*%K20K/()<K%(K*K%$+*K%K-K%-$K)*$)K%$H
,*;KK +K)K&(#**J$K('+(J*%K%$)(K*KD)*%(/K$K(*(H
)*)EK%K*K$$*;K18K;;;KF3553>?>1?;KK <K576K;3K400<K
403K:K$;2K>7*K(;K2009?;KD %K"#**%$K)""KK&"K%$K*K$%(#*%$K%$($$K
*K!(%+$<K(*(<K$K%$+*K%KK&()%$K%$,*K%K$K%$)K-KK
%+(*K%K*K$*K**)K#/K(,K$K%$)(K%(K*K&+(&%)K%K#&%)$K$K&H
&(%&(*K)$*$;EK18K;;;KF3661;K

-- 2 of 3 --

%;K17H2567K K3K
K*(+)*K**K-$K$*($KK$-K)$*$K*K)*(*K%+(*K-""K%((*K*K +H
#$*K*%K("*K**K%-$K)K$K%$,*K%K,%"*$K18K;;;KF2252>?>1?K$K
$%*<K)K*K +#$*K$%-K()<K18K;;;KF2252>1?>1?K@)AK$K>?>1?;K
K K K

-- 3 of 3 --