3 C 282/17•Compensation for diminished value requires proper withdrawal instructions
3 C 282/17Tribunale di primo grado13 mar 2018Diritto civileAccolto
Estratto da Omnilex
The Dülmen District Court ordered the defendant to pay the plaintiff €500 plus interest and €378.83 in extrajudicial legal costs plus interest. The court stated that a claim for compensation under § 357(7) BGB requires proper and error-free instructions on the right of withdrawal. The defendant was ordered to bear the costs of the proceedings. The judgment is provisionally enforceable, subject to the stated security provisions. The court granted leave to appeal.
§ 357 Abs. 7 BGB; a claim for compensation for diminished value following withdrawal requires the consumer to have received proper and error-free information about the right of withdrawal. The statutory compensation entitlement is therefore conditional on compliance with the applicable information obligations, including those set out in Art. 246a § 1 Abs. 2 Satz 1 Nr. 1 EGBGB. Where the withdrawal instructions are deficient, the statutory conditions for requiring the consumer to compensate for diminished value are not met.
Entscheidungsdatum: 2018-03-13
Aktenzeichen: 3 C 282/17
ECLI: ECLI:DE:AGCOE2:2018:0313.3C282.17.00
Dokumenttyp: Urteil
Spruchkörper: Einzelrichter
Normen: BGB § 357 Abs. 7; EGBGB Art 246a § 1 Abs. 2 Satz 1 Nr. 1
Der Wertersatzanspruch aus § 357 Abs. 7 BGB setzt eine ordnunsgemäße und fehlerfreie Widerrufsbelehrung voraus.
Der Beklagte wird verurteilt, an den Kläger 500,-- € nebst Zinsen in Höhe von 5 Prozentpunkten über dem jeweiligen Basiszinssatz seit dem 06.10.2017 und 378,83 € außergerichtliche Rechtsanwaltskosten nebst Zinsen in Höhe von 5 Prozentpunkten über dem jeweiligen Basiszinssatz seit dem 31.12.2017 zu zahlen.
Der Beklagte trägt die Kosten des Rechtsstreits.
Das Urteil ist vorläufig vollstreckbar.
Dem Beklagten wird nachgelassen, die Vollstreckung durch Sicherheitsleistung in Höhe von 110 % des aufgrund des Urteils vollstreckbaren Betrages abzuwenden, wenn nicht der Kläger zuvor Sicherheit in Höhe von 110 % des jeweils zu vollstreckenden Betrages leistet.
Die Berufung wird zugelassen.
Whether the defendant must pay the plaintiff €500 in compensation.
A claim for compensation under § 357(7) BGB requires proper and error-free instructions on the right of withdrawal.
The court stated that a claim for compensation under § 357(7) BGB depends on proper and error-free withdrawal instructions.
Whether the defendant must reimburse the plaintiff's extrajudicial legal costs.
The defendant must pay €378.83 in extrajudicial legal costs, with interest as ordered.
Allocation of the costs of the proceedings.
The defendant bears the costs of the proceedings.
Whether the judgment should be provisionally enforceable and the defendant permitted to avert enforcement by providing security.
The judgment is provisionally enforceable; the defendant may avert enforcement by providing security of 110% of the enforceable amount, unless the plaintiff first provides security of 110% of the amount to be enforced.
Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.