IN RE: 3M COMBAT ARMS EARPLUG PRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION

3:19-md-02885Flnd5 dic 2025

Apri la fonte

Testo completo

  	 	  

%($&$($) 	 	 	0B4%>  <3
('#+'(&+)


# *.# * * &%


78B>2D<4=C(4;0C4BC> 	 	 	!D364$ 0B4H(>364AB
4AC08=0B4B58;431H
4=8=64A0AA8B>=0E8B
&=470;5>5+60=30=;84=CB  	 	$068BCA0C4!D364>?4 0==>=


*78B A4?>AC 8B A4B?42C5D;;H BD1<8CC43 C> C74 >DAC ?DABD0=C C> C74 >A34A
0??>8=C8=6C74D=34AB86=430E83( 4A=3>=0B0)?4280;$0BC4AC>8=E4BC860C4
C748BBD4>5F74C74A24AC08=3>2D<4=CB58;438=C78B;8C860C8>=NB)4CC;4<4=C'A>6A0<
2>=BC8CDC44C7820;E8>;0C8>=B>A>C74A<8B2>=3D2C1H2;08<0=CB>A2>D=B4;>A1>C7C>
4=BDA4C748=C46A8CH>5C74'A>6A0<

-70C8B2;40AC>C78B)?4280;$0BC4A8BC70C4=8=64A0AA8B>=0E8BNB70=3;8=6
>58CB+60=30=2;08<B508;430CB4E4A0;;4E4;B !DBC0BF8C70=H;460;A4?A4B4=C0C8>=
>5 ?4AB>=B F7> 70E4 144= 8=9DA43 0=3 B44: 2><?4=B0C8>= C7A>D67 C74 2>DACB 0
;0FH4A 70B >1;860C8>=B C> C74 2;84=CB C74 >DAC C74 ;460; ?A>54BB8>= 0=3 C74
B4CC;4<4=C06A44<4=CF8C7C743454=30=C *74)?4280;$0BC4A58=3BC7458A<508;438=
402720C46>AH - #4F8B0AA8B>=F0B0CC74C>?>5C74?A>54BB8>=0;A4B?>=B818;8CH
<4270=8B<5>AC78B58A< BB4=8>A?0AC=4AF8C706A40C340;>5$#4G?4A84=24C>
8=5>A< 0=3 6D834 78< 74 B7>D;3 70E4 B4C C74 A>03<0? 0=3 >E4AB44= C74 58A<NB
<0=064<4=C5>A;8C860C8>=0=3C74B4CC;4<4=C?A>6A0< 0AA8B>=F0B<>A48=E>;E43
8=C74;8C860C8>=0B?42C>5C78B;8C860C8>=F8C714;;F4C74ABCA80;B1DC7030;<>BC=>30H
C>30H70=3;8=6>5C74B4CC;4<4=C?70B4>5C74;8C860C8>= >F4E4A85>=4F4A4C>
@D0=C85H C74 A4B?>=B818;8CH 5>A C74 508;DA4B 8= C74 A4?A4B4=C0C8>= >5 C74B4 +60=30=
Case 3:19-md-02885-MCR-HTC Document 4190 Filed 12/05/25 Page 1 of 37

 	
2;08<0=CB?0AC=4AB*0H;>A0AC;4C0=3-8;;80<A>BB1H50A20AAHC74740E84BC;>03
>5A4B?>=B818;8CH5>AC74508;DA4B>5C78B;0F58A<8=C74A4?A4B4=C0C8>=>58CB+60=30=
2;84=CB0=38CB3DCHC>C74>DAC *74D=34AB86=433>4B=>C58=3C70C0=H<4<14A>5
C74 4=8=64A 0AA8B>= 0E8B 58A< 8=C4=C8>=0;;H 2><<8CC43 5A0D3 >= C74 >DAC
C7A>D67C78BB4CC;4<4=C?A>6A0<  C8B2;40A7>F4E4AC70C0AC;4CC0=3A>BBF4A4
=>CB8<?;H=46;864=C8=C7470=3;8=6>5C74B42;08<B1DC8=BC403F4A42>=B28>DB;H
0=3A42:;4BB;H8=38554A4=CC>C74E0A84CH>528A2D<BC0=24B>5C74+60=30=B4CC;4<4=C
?A>6A0<0;;>F8=65A0D3C>>22DA0=34@D0;;H8=38554A4=CC>C748A3DC84B0B>55824AB>5
C74>DAC8=C78B$# 

DA8=6 C74 8=E4BC860C8>= >5 C78B <0CC4A C74 )?4280; $0BC4A A4E84F43 C74
A42>A3B8=C742DBC>3H>5A>F=A44AC74B4CC;4<4=C03<8=8BCA0C>A0=38=C742>DAB4
C74A4>5 A4E84F43 7D=3A43B >5 2;08<B 58;4B 0D38>6A0<B 0=3 >C74A BD??>AC8=6
3>2D<4=CB  =0338C8>= 74;338B2DBB8>=BF8C7?4AB>==4;0CA>F=A44AF7>F4A4
C7>A>D67;H8=E>;E438=C7403<8=8BCA0C8>=>5C744=8=64A0AA8B>=0E8B
2;08<B8=2;D38=6&AA0=A>F=!0:4->>3H$0CC0II0A3!'D83>=0=30E83
)<8C7  $0=H >5 C74 38B2DBB8>=B F8C7 A>F=A44A ?4AB>==4; F4A4 A4;0C43 C> <H
A4@D4BCB 5>A 0338C8>=0; 8=5>A<0C8>= 5>;;>F8=6 D? >= C74 A4?>ACB A>F=A44A
?A4?0A43  8B2DBB8>=B F4A4 0;B> 74;3 F8C7 AH0= H;BC>2: 0=3 7A8B )4464A
?;08=C855BN #403 >D=B4; >E4A C74 )4CC;4<4=C 'A>6A0<   />>< 8=C4AE84FB F4A4
2>=3D2C43F8C7- #4F8B0AA8B>=;4G(>B0;4B0H;>A0AA8B>=0=370=;H=A44
>50BF4;;0BA0507$DB>:4>5+60=300=3C74?4AB>=2>=B834ABC>14
C74 A454AA8=6 2>D=B4; >5 C74 E0BC 1D;: >5 C74+60=30= 20B4B  =C4AE84FB >50H;>A
0AC;4CC!40=84)740330=3-8;;80<A>BBF4A42>=3D2C438=?4AB>=0=3C0:4=F8C7
02>DACA4?>AC4A0=3CA0=B2A8?CBF4A4B42DA430=30A4?0AC>5C74??4=38GC>C78B
((0;>=6F8C7>C74A3>2D<4=CB28C43>AA454AA43C>74A48= *74CA0=B2A8?CB70E40
;464=30CC741468==8=6C70CC74CA0=B2A8?CB0A42>=5834=C80;?DABD0=CC>0?A>C42C8E4
>A34A *70CF0B0=4AA>A *74HF4A4=4E4A8=C4=343C>142>=5834=C80; *74)?4280;
$0BC4A0;B>A4030=3A4E84F43C74A>F=A44AD38C(4?>AC>5C74+60=30=2;08<B
0A4B?>=B8E43>2D<4=CC74A4C>0DC7>A431H0=3C74A>F=A44A=0;HB8B>5
4=8=64A0AA8B>=0E8B 	 	D38C(4?>AC(4B?>=B4 -78;4<8=8<0;4027>5
C74B4 3>2D<4=CB 70E4 B><4 ?4AB>=0; 834=C85H8=6 8=5>A<0C8>= 0BB>280C43 F8C7 C74
Case 3:19-md-02885-MCR-HTC Document 4190 Filed 12/05/25 Page 2 of 37

 	
0D38>6A0<B0=3C74>DAC;8:4;HF8;;B40;C7>B44G7818CB?4=38=6A4E84F $>A4>E4A
C74)?4280;$0BC4AA4030=3A4E84F430A4?>AC5A><>0BC0;'028582 =E4BC860C8>=B
0= >A60=8I0C8>= 78A43 1H #403 AH0=H;BC>2: >DC;8=8=6 8CB 8=E4BC860C8>= >5 C74
8BBD4B8=E>;E43F8C7+60=30=2;08<B0=3?0AC82D;0A;HA0507$DB>:4 *74)?4280;
$0BC4A A4E84F43 C74 $0BC4A )4CC;4<4=C 6A44<4=C 0=3 2>=BD;C43 F8C7 '7
D38>;>68BC 7A8BC>?74A )?0=:>E827 F7> B4AE4B 0B 0= 4G?4AC 2>=BD;C0=C C> C74
)4CC;4<4=C'A>6A0<  2>=3D2C43<0=H8=C4A=4CB40A274BA4;0C8E4C>A468BCA0C8>=>5
<43820; ?A>E834AB <43820; 2;8=82B 0=3 0CC>A=4H A468BCA0C8>=   A4E84F43 C74 + ) 
4?0AC<4=C>5)C0C4F41B8C45>A8=5>A<0C8>=01>DC+60=30  A4B40A2743C74A42>A3
8=C74$#5>A24AC08=8BBD4B  A4030=3A4E84F43C74#>20;(D;4B5>AC74%>AC74A=
8BCA82C>5;>A830C74(D;4B>5'A>54BB8>=0;>=3D2C>5*74;>A8300A0=3C74
;010<0(D;4B>5'A>54BB8>=0;>=3D2C 
B0=H>=4F7>7030=H8=E>;E4<4=C8=C74$$#:=>FBC78B$#
70B 4=9>H43 0 C7>A>D67;H A>1DBC <0=064<4=C 1H C74 >DAC F8C7 4558284=2H
45542C8E4=4BB0=3B?443 *7>D67=>C;>=68=3DA0C8>=3403;8=4BF4A4CA40C430B58A<
0=34=5>A243 =4GC4=B8E414;;F4C74A?A>24BBF0B?DABD432><?;4C430=35A><0
C8<4;8=4?4AB?42C8E4F0BC7414=458280AH>5CA80;30C4B40A;H=>C;0C4A >C7B834B>5
C74 	;8C860C8>= 	E86>A>DB;H 	A4?A4B4=C43 	?;08=C855B 	0=3 	3454=30=C  	)4CC;4<4=C
=46>C80C8>=B1460=40A;H1DC383=>CA4BD;C8=0B4CC;4<4=C5>A0=4GC4=343?4A8>3 
><?A><8B8=6 C>>: 0 102: B40C C> 03E>202H  >F4E4A >=24 $0BC4A )4CC;4<4=C
6A44<4=CBF4A4B86=430=4GCA4<4;HA>1DBCB4CC;4<4=C03<8=8BCA0C8>=F0BB4CD?
0=3 <0=0643 F8C7 C74 :8=3 >5 BD?4AE8B8>= C74 4=C8A4 ;8C860C8>= ?A>24BB 4=9>H43 
8E4=<>A4C70=0@D0AC4A>50<8;;8>=?4AB>=B0??;8430=34=C4A43C70C?A>6A0<C74
B4CC;4<4=C03<8=8BCA0C8>=8B2><?;820C43 *><0:4C74?A>24BB0BC7>A>D672;40A
0=3<0=06401;45>A0;;2>D=B4;F8C72;84=CB8=C74?A>6A0<C74>DAC4BC01;8B7430
)4CC;4<4=C3<8=8BCA0C>A0=0;;>20C8>=)?4280;$0BC4A0=30;;C7430C0?A>24BB8=6
=424BB0AH5>ABD270=8=34?C7?A>24BB '0AC>5C70C30C0?A>24BB8=68=2;D3430<40=B
5>A 2>D=B4; 0=3 ?;08=C855B 8=38E83D0;;H C> D?;>03 0=3 0224BB 58;4B 2>=C08=8=6 C74
BD??>AC8=63>2D<4=C0C8>=5>A4027?;08=C8558=C74?A>6A0< )44<8=6;H2>D=C;4BB
KC>F=70;;<44C8=6BLF4A474;3?A8<0A8;H>=/>><B>C70C0=H>=4C70C=44343C>
;40A=C742;08<B?A>24BB8=62>D;33>B> >D=C;4BB3868C0;=>C824BB4CC;4<4=C0=3
0;;>20C8>=<4C7>3>;>6H5A4@D4=C;H0B:43@D4BC8>=B0=30=BF4ABF4A40E08;01;4B>
4E4AH>=42>D;3C7>A>D67;H;40A=C74B4CC;4<4=C?A>24BBC>A4?A4B4=CC742;84=CB=>F
2;08<0=CB0=3C740<>D=C>5<>=4HC>F7827C74HF4A44=C8C;438=C78B;8C860C8>= 
Case 3:19-md-02885-MCR-HTC Document 4190 Filed 12/05/25 Page 3 of 37
 	
%> >1942C8E4 >1B4AE4A >A ?0AC828?0=C 8= C74 B4CC;4<4=C ?A>24BB 2>D;3 ;468C8<0C4;H
0BB4ACC70CC748=5>A<0C8>=5;>F5A><C74B4CC;4<4=C?A>6A0<C>C742;08<0=CB0=3
2>D=B4;F0B5;0F438=0=HB86=85820=CF0H 
*7438B2DBB8>=BF7827;43C>C78B8=E4BC860C8>=>5C74+60=30=2;08<B58;431H
 1460= F8C7 =D<4A>DB 4<08;B 5A>< +60=30= 2;08<0=CB A4?A4B4=C43 1H
4=8=64AA0AA8B>=0E8B0=36>E4A=<4=C0;064=284B2><?;08=8=601>DC
;02: >5 ?0H<4=C 0=3 38B2A8<8=0C8>= 0608=BC =>=+ )  28C8I4=B  -78;4 ?DA?>AC43;H
B4=C1H38554A4=C?4AB>=BC744<08;B2>=C08=43C744G02CB0<4;0=6D064 &=24C74
=D<14A>52;08<BC70C@D0;858435>A''?>8=CB1420<4B8I401;40=3:=>F8=6C74
)4CC;4<4=C 'A>6A0<NB 0DC><0C43 A4E84F BHBC4< C>>: C74 2;08<B 0C 5024 E0;D4
A>F=A44A D=34AC>>: 0 70=3B>= A4E84F -8C7 C70C A4E84F 24AC08= 8AA46D;0A8C84B
20<4 C> ;867C F8C7 C74 2;08<B *74 A>F=A44AD38C (4?>AC 4=8=64A 0AA8B>=
0E8B F0B ?A4?0A43 1H A>F=A44A 0=3 ?A>E8343 C> C74 >DAC 0=3 30C43 $0H 
 &5C74 	?;08=C855BA4?A4B4=CB8=C74$) B4CC;4<4=C?A>6A0<
BD27 B4CC;4<4=C 2;08<0=CB 0A4 +60=30= =0C8>=0;B  &5 C74  +60=30= ?;08=C855B
A4?A4B4=C431H4;42C43'' 4;42C43'' *74?;08=C855B5A><+60=30
F>A:43 5>A 2>=CA02C>AB C70C ?A>E8343 B42DA8CH 6D0A3B 5>A 24AC08= 4<10BB84B 0=3
<8;8C0AH10B4B8=$833;40BCF0AI>=4B?A8<0A8;H A0@0=35670=8BC0=F74A4C74
+=8C43)C0C4B502437>BC8;8C84B *74+60=30=?;08=C855B2;08<C74HF4A48BBD43$
><10C A<B 0A?;D6B BD554A43 8=9DAH 0=3 F4A4 4=C8C;43 C> 0 ?>AC8>= >5 C74
B4CC;4<4=C *74''2;08<0=CBF4A44=C8C;43C> 	8=C74B4CC;4<4=C?A>6A0<0=3
C7>B40F0A3BF4A4?083 *74HF4A4=>CA4@D8A43C>BD1<8CC74CH?4>5BD??>AC8=6
3>2D<4=CBC70C''A468BCA0=CB0A4A4@D8A43C>BD1<8C  C8BC74A45>A4D=:=>F=85
C748BBD4BF782770E4144=A08B438=C74''20B4BF>D;370E42><4C>C745>A48=
C74''20B4B *74A45>A4C74>=;H2;08<BD=34A8=E4BC860C8>=8=E>;E4''2;08<B 

H E8ACD4 &gt;5 C74 0DC&gt;&lt;0C43 2;08&lt; 0=3 A4E84F ?A&gt;24BB ?A8&gt;A C&gt; 0 70=3B&gt;=



A4E84F703+60=30=2;84=CBF7>0??40A43C>@D0;85H5>A''A468BCA0C8>=
?0H<4=CBF78271460=>= 	 	F74=A>F=A44A0CC4<?C43C>?0HCF>+60=30=
2;08<0=CB E80  >C7 ?0H<4=CB F4A4 D=BD224BB5D;  A>F=A44A C74= 8BBD43
5>DA 2;08<0=C ?0H<4=CB 38A42C;H C>  >= 	 	  &=  	 	 A>F=A44A
1460=8BBD8=68=C4A=0C8>=0;F8A4BC>+60=30=2;08<0=CB *74C>C0;0<>D=C>5BD27
?0H<4=CB 	A4=34A430=4C0<>D=C>5  05C4AC74><<>=
Case 3:19-md-02885-MCR-HTC Document 4190 Filed 12/05/25 Page 4 of 37

 	
4=458CD=37>;3102:F0BC0:4=>DC )8=248B0=8=;4364A8=658A<8CF0B
:=>F=C70CC74 0CC>A=4HB544F0B 	*74H0BB4BB43C78B0<>D=C>=<>BC
1DC =>C 0;; +60=30= 2;08<0=CNB '' (468BCA0C8>= '0H<4=CB  A40:8=6 3>F= C74
0<>D=C?0835>A''A468BCA0C8>=544BC>C74+60=30=2;84=CB  	F>D;3
14C74=4C5>AC742;08<0=CB 	C>5>A544B0=3 C>C74><<>=
4=458CD=3 *74E0;D45>ANB544B8=2;D34BC748=C4A=0C8>=0;10=:544BF7827
0A4C>14?0835A><0CC>A=4H544B 420DB4>5C748AA46D;0A8C84BC70CF4A438B2>E4A43
8= C74 >=6>8=6 70=3B>= A4E84F >5 C74 2;08<B A468BCA0C8>= 544 ?0H<4=CB F4A4
BDB?4=343 >=?A8; 	 	 7>F4E4A F8A4 CA0=B54AB C> +60=30= 2;08<0=CB C70C
F4A4 8=8C80C43 145>A4 C70C 30C4 2>=C8=D43 C> 1>D=24 102: C> C74 )4CC;4<4=C
3<8=8BCA0C>A D=C8; $0H 	 	  ;A403H ?083 2;08<0=C B70A4B 0C C70C ?>8=C
0<>D=C43C>C> 2;08<0=CB *70C;45CD=?0835>A0C>C0;>5  	
'083C>0CC70C?>8=C8=C8<4F4A4544B8=C740<>D=C>5 	 	*A0=B54AA43
C>C74><<>=4=458CD=3BC8;;74;38=C74022>D=CF0B  	 	
85CHB8G+60=30=''2;08<0=CBF4A40F0A343?>8=CBA0=68=65A>< 	
C> 	 	%>C824BF4A4B4=CC> 	>5C742;08<0=CB1468==8=6>=$0A27 	 	 
>F4E4A0B8<8;0A7>;3F0B?;0243>=C74B40F0A3B>=?A8; 	 	0=3=>=4
70E4144=?083 
 	A>F=A44A34C4A<8=43C70C 	>5NB+60=30=2;08<0=CB8=C74
''?A>6A0<7030D38>6A0<BD?;>03433DA8=6C74424<14A 	A024'4A8>3
=>C145>A4C74!D;H  	'')D??;4<4=C0C8>=403;8=4 
 	NB58ABC2>=C02CF8C7+60=30=2;84=CB>22DAA438=>A0A>D=3D6DBC 	
F74=0A>=0AC;0=0=;010<0;0FH4AA454AA435>DA>A58E42;84=CBC> *7>B4
2;84=CBF4A4A468BC4A438=C74C8<45A0<414CF44=D6DBC0=3C744=3>5 	 
A0507$DB>:4F7>834=C8584378<B4;50B0?A02C828=6;0FH4A8="0<?0;0
+60=30F7>0;B>B4AE430B&>5=>=6>E4A=<4=C0;=>=?A>58C:=>F=0B>;;H=4
0A42>=C02C43-8;;80<A>BB0?0AC=4A0C4=8=64A0AA8B>=0E8B48C74A;0C4
>A40A;H 	4C>;3A>BBC70C7470306A>D?>52;84=CB74703A4?A4B4=C43
5>AH40AB0=3F0B8=?>BB4BB8>=>50;;C748AA42>A3B *74B40338C8>=0;+60=30=BF4A4
A468BC4A438=>A0A>D=3!D;H 	*7A>D67>DCC743>2D<4=CBA4E84F433DA8=6C78B
8=E4BC860C8>=C74)?4280;$0BC4A=>C43C70CC78B64=C;4<0=8BA454AA43C>0B$DB>:4
A050CA050C$DB>:40=31H>C74A=0<4B +;C8<0C4;H?A>E83430?7>C>2>?H
>5 C74 64=C;4<0=NB ?0BB?>AC >1C08=43 3DA8=6 C78B 8=E4BC860C8>= F7827 B7>FB 78B
Case 3:19-md-02885-MCR-HTC Document 4190 Filed 12/05/25 Page 5 of 37
 	
68E4==0<4C>14A0507"08C0;40=378BBDA=0<4C>14$DB>:4  C8B2DBC><0AH8=
FA8CC4=;0=6D0648=+60=30C>A454AC>0?4AB>=F8C778B;0BC=0<4?A8=C4358ABC >A
?DA?>B4B>5C78B((C74D=34AB86=43F8;;A454AC>78<1H78B68E4==0<458ABC0B
B?4;;43>=C74?0BB?>AC0=3C>;3C><41H$A $DB>:4 &5=>C4;8:4<>BC>5C74
2>D=CA84B0A>D=3C74F>A;3+60=30;8BCBC7430H58ABCC74=C74<>=C70=3;0BCC74
H40A *74>558280;;0=6D064>5+60=308B=6;8B7 
*74A>F=A44AD38C4BC01;8B74BC70CC74?A>24BB8=6>5+60=30=2;08<0=CB
5>AA>F=A44ABC0ACBF8C7C74502CC70C=>=4>5C74+60=30==0C8>=0;BF>A:8=65>A
0 2>=CA02C>A >5 C74 +=8C43 )C0C4B 5>A B42DA8CH A>;4B 8= 0 54F F0AC>A= ;>20C8>=B 8=
24AC08=2>D=CA84B7030=H&()0D38>6A0<B *>BD??>ACC748A2;08<BC74H2>D;3
>=;H?A>E8340D38>6A0<B5A><<43820;?A>E834ABC74H?A>2DA43C74<B4;E4B DA8=6
C78B ;8C860C8>= 0=3 B4CC;4<4=C ?A>6A0< C74 ?A4E0;4=C 0BBD<?C8>= F0B C70C C74B4
+60=30= 2>=CA02C>AB F>D;3 >=;H 70E4 >=4 0D38>6A0< 0 ?>BC 8=9DAH 0D38>6A0< 
>F4E4A 8C 1420<4 2;40A 5A>< <H 2>=E4AB0C8>=B F8C7 $A  $DB>:4 C70C BD27 0=
0BBD<?C8>= F0B 8=022DA0C4 22>A38=6 C> $DB>:4 C74 2><?0=84B C70C 2>=CA02C43
F8C7C744?0AC<4=C>5454=B4C>?A>E834B42DA8CH?4AB>==4;0C10B4B0=34<10BB84B
8=F0AI>=4B703C74+60=30=28C8I4=BC70CF4A4?>C4=C80;;H4;8681;45>A78A45>AC74B4
?>B8C8>=B D=34A6> 0 E4AH C7>A>D67 ?A434?;>H<4=C <43820; 4E0;D0C8>= *74 B0<4
F0BCAD4D?>=A4CDA=5A><34?;>H<4=C *74A45>A48C8B<>A4C70=;8:4;HC70C8=C74
A42>A3B>5C7>B4<43820;4E0;D0C8>=BF>D;370E4144=8=C74A42>A3B>5C7478A8=6
2>=CA02C>AB0=3C74<43820;?A>E834ABA4=34A8=6BD27B4AE824B >=B4@D4=C;HF70C
1420<4C>14:=>F=0BA454A4=240=38=9DAH0D38>6A0<BB7>D;370E4144=0CC08=01;4
5>AC74+60=30=?;08=C855B 
&=%>E4<14A 	A>F=A44A8BBD43=>C824B34=H8=60  	''
(468BCA0C8>= '0H<4=C C>  	  +60=30= 2;08<0=CB 3D4 C> C74 ;02: >5 0=
0D38>6A0<  A>F=A44A 8BBD43;4AC %>  	 	 4G?;08=8=6 C74 A4@D8A4<4=CB C>
A4248E4 0 '' A468BCA0C8>= ?0H<4=C 0B 5>;;>FB K'DABD0=C C> C74 ;;>20C8>=
$4C7>3>;>6H 0 2;08<0=C <DBC BD??;H 48C74A 0 (454A4=24D38>6A0< >A 0= =9DAH
D38>6A0<C>@D0;85H5>AC74''(468BCA0C8>='0H<4=C  502;08<0=C3>4B=>C70E4
0=H 0D38>6A0<B 48C74A 5A>< &() 30C0 >A C7A>D67 C74 '' BD??;4<4=C0C8>=
?A>24BB C74 2;08<0=C 8B =>C 4;8681;4 C> A4248E4 C74   	 (468BCA0C8>= '0H<4=C 
4=8432;08<0=CBF8;;=>CA4248E40=H5DCDA4''%>C824B0=3C74''2;08<F8;;14
2;>B43  420DB4 C74 !D;H 	 	 '' )D??;4<4=C0C8>= 3403;8=4 70B ?0BB43 =>
=4F3>2D<4=CB>A8=5>A<0C8>=8=2;D38=60D38>6A0<B<0H14BD1<8CC43=>F L
Case 3:19-md-02885-MCR-HTC Document 4190 Filed 12/05/25 Page 6 of 37
 	
)8GCHB8G>5C74+60=30=2;08<0=CBBD1<8CC430D38>6A0<A4?>ACB1HC74
!D;H  	''3403;8=4F8C75>ACHCF>BD1<8CC8=6>=40D38>6A0<0=3CF4=CH
5>DA?A>E838=6CF>022>A38=6C>C74A>F=A44AD38C(4?>AC >=B4@D4=C;H>=
%>E4<14A  	A>F=A44AB4=C=>C824B6A0=C8=6''A468BCA0C8>=?0H<4=CB
C> C7>B4 B8GCHB8G 2;08<0=CB  ;08<8=6 C70C C74H 383 =>C :=>F C74 A4@D8A4<4=C C>
BD1<8C0=0D38>6A0<B7>F8=6740A8=6;>BB34B?8C4=>C824B0=3C>F=70;;<44C8=6B
38B2DBB8=6 C74 A4@D8A4<4=C  1460= ?DB78=6 102: F8C7 A>F=A44A 5>A C74
34=80;>5C74 	2;08<0=CBA4@D4BC5>A0A468BCA0C8>=?0H<4=C  =502C?A8>AC>148=6
03E8B430608=C70C0=0D38>6A0<F0BA4@D8A434E4=5>A0A468BCA0C8>=?0H<4=C*0H;>A
0AC;4CC0B:43A>F=A44A850=H>=44;B47035>D=3C74B0<4K;>>?7>;4L74703 
0AC;4CC03E8B4378B?0AC=4ABC70C74703586DA43>DC0F0HC>64C0C7>DB0=33>;;0AB
5>AC74''2;84=CB=>C0F0A343?>8=CBB>C74H2>D;364C05440=370E4C748A4G?4=B4B
?083 *7458A<NB?4AB8BC4=248=8CB?>B8C8>=C>64C74AF8C79DBC054F2><?;08=CB5A><
>C74A ?A8<0AH 2>D=B4; 20DB43 &AA0= A>F= >5 A>F=A44A C> A4E84F C74 <0CC4A
F8C70;;>20C8>=)?4280;$0BC4A0AA4CB>=0=3C74>DAC )?4280;$0BC4A0AA4CB>=
4G?;08=43 C70C 740A8=6 ;>BB F0B BC8;; 0 ?A4A4@D8B8C4 C> 148=6 ?083 C74 A468BCA0C8>=
?0H<4=C 8B4G02CCDA=>5?7A0B4F0BC70CC74A468BCA0C8>=?0H<4=CF0B=>CB8<?;H
0 KB86=8=6 1>=DB L *74 2;08<0=CB F7> 508;43 C> C8<4;H D?;>03 >=4 >A <>A4
0D38>6A0<B508;43C>?A>E4740A8=6;>BB !D364(>364AB5>D=3C74)?4280;$0BC4ANB
3428B8>= C> 14 2>AA42C ?0AC82D;0A;H B8=24 C74 ?A>6A0< F0B 0 B4CC;4<4=C ?A>6A0<
<40=CC>2><?4=B0C402CD0;740A8=6;>BB 
*74>DAC0??A>E430338C8>=0;C8<4C>BD1<8C0D38>6A0<B2>=B8BC4=CF8C7C74
2A8C4A80>?4==>C>=;HC>C7458A<1DC0;;58A<B C74A41H0;;>F8=60C4=30H
KA024'4A8>3L5A><424<14A 	C7A>D67<83=867C424<14A 	 	5>A
''2;08<0=CBC>BD1<8C0D38>6A0<B?A>E8343C74HF4A48=C748A?>BB4BB8>=1HC74
?A4E8>DB3403;8=4>5!D;H  	 *740D38>6A0<B2>D;348C74A148=?>BB4BB8>=>5
C742;84=C>A2>D=B4;1DCC74H2>D;3=>C6>>DC0=3>1C08=0=4F=>A0?A4E8>DB;H=>C
?>BB4BB43 0D38>6A0< C> B0C8B5H C74 4;86818;8CH 2A8C4A80  &= 424<14A 
A>F=A44A740A35A><>=4>5C742;84=CBF7>BC0C4303E8B43C70C0=H
0D38>6A0<BBD1<8CC433DA8=6C74A024'4A8>3703C>148=NB?>BB4BB8>=0B>5
!D;H  &AA0=A>F=4<08;43C><0:4BDA4C74HD=34ABC>>3C740D38>6A0<B
2>D;348C74A148=C7458A<NB?>BB4BB8>=0B>5C70C30C4>A8=C742;84=CNB?>BB4BB8>= 
 	*01;4>5C74A>F=A44AD38C?064B4CB>DCC7458E44<?;>H44B
F7> D?;>0343 0D38>6A0<B 3DA8=6 C74 A024 '4A8>3  *74H 8=2;D34 F8C7 0
Case 3:19-md-02885-MCR-HTC Document 4190 Filed 12/05/25 Page 7 of 37
 	
?0A4=C74C820;=D<14A>50D38>6A0<BD?;>0343*0H;>A0AA8B>= 70=;H=A44
  ;4G (>B0;4B   *0H;>A 0AC;4CC   !40=84 );4033  	 0=3 )0<
70=24 C4;;8=6BC0C8BC828=*01;4A4E40;BC70C0C>C0;>5 	0D38>6A0<BF4A4
D?;>0343 3DA8=6 C74 58ABC 30H >5 C74 A024 '4A8>3 424<14A    3DA8=6 C74
B42>=3 	3DA8=6C74C78A3 3DA8=6C745>DAC7=>=43DA8=6C74585C7 	3DA8=6
C74B8GC70=3 3DA8=6C74B4E4=C730H>5C74C4=30H6A024?4A8>3 DA8=6C74
4867C7 30H C74 B0<4 30H &AA0= A>F= 2;0A85843 5>A  C70C C74 8=?>BB4BB8>=
A4@D8A4<4=C>5C742A8C4A80?4A<8CC43C7>B40D38>6A0<B8=?>BB4BB8>=>5C742;08<0=C
0BF4;;0B2>D=B4; 0D38>6A0<BF4A4D?;>0343F8C70=>C74A>=C74=8=C7
30H0=30=>C74A >=C74;0BC30H>5C74A024'4A8>3 *0H;>A0AC;4CC03E8B43C74
D=34AB86=43C70C74E>;D=C0A8;H2DC>55C>C746A40C4BC4GC4=C?>BB81;40D38>6A0<B
148=6B4=C0=3D?;>034305C4AC74=8=C730H1420DB474=44343C8<4C>64C0A4?>AC
5A>< A>F=A44A 0B C> F7827 2;84=CB 703 C748A A468BCA0C8>= ?0H<4=C 34=843 0=3
F7827383=>C70E40=H0D38>6A0<BD?;>0343 A0507$DB>:4C>;3<4C74+60=30=B
8=2;D38=678<F4A4C>;30CB><4?>8=CC>BC>?B4=38=60D38>6A0<BC>4E4=
C7>D67C74H703<0=H<>A4C>B4=3  =78BF>A3BKC74A49DBCF0B=NC4=>D67C8<4 L
*74B4=D<14ABA4E40;C70C?A8>AC>C7401>E4<4=C8>=432;0A85820C8>=68E4=C>
  0D38>6A0<B F4A4 D?;>0343  >;;>F8=6 C70C 4<08;  0D38>6A0<B F4A4
D?;>0343 

)?40:8=6F8C7C74BC055?4AB&gt;=BF7&gt;383C74D?;&gt;038=6&gt;50D38&gt;6A0&lt;B



3DA8=6C74A024'4A8>3?A>E83436>>38=B867C8=C>C74742C82=0CDA4>5C748AF>A:
3DA8=6 C7>B4 C4= 30HB  *0H;>A 0AA8B>= F7> D?;>0343 C74 6A40C4BC =D<14A >5
0D38>6A0<B03E8B43<4C70C74AA>;40CC7458A<F0B>=4>52;84=C2><<D=820C8>=
)74F0BC0B:43C>?8C278=0=374;?C74>C74ABF8C7D?;>038=6C740D38>6A0<B3DA8=6
C74A024'4A8>3B8=24<>BC>5C74A4E84FC40<C70C703144=3>8=6C74D?;>038=6
703<>E43>= $B 0AA8B>=F7>BC0AC43F8C78=!D=4>5 	0=3F>A:430B
C74A>=C4B:2>>A38=0C>AF0B=4E4A>=>=4>5C74A4E84FC40<BC70C4G0<8=43
0D38>6A0<B>52;84=CB -78;4BD1BC8CDC8=68=5>AC78BC40<$B 0AA8B>=NBF>A:
F0B0BC403H?A>3D2C8>=D=;8:4$B A440=3$B (>B0;4BF7>B4D?;>038=6=D<14AB
<0A:43;H A>B4 >=  30H >5 C74 A024 '4A8>3 *0H;>A 0AA8B>=NB F>A: 3DA8=6 C74
A024'4A8>3F0BB8<?;HC>2><?0A4C742;84=CB=0<4C>C74=0<4>=C740D38>6A0<
A4?>ACC><0:4BDA4C74H<0C27430=3C74=C>;>>:5>AC740D38>6A0<6A830B8=38280
Case 3:19-md-02885-MCR-HTC Document 4190 Filed 12/05/25 Page 8 of 37

 	
C70CC74A42>A3B74F0B;>>:8=60CF0B0=0D38>6A0<0=3C>D?;>038C0=3C>A4?40C
C70C?A>24BB0B@D82:;H0BB742>D;3 
70=;H= A44 BC0AC43 0C  8= )4?C4<14A 	 F0B 0BB86=43 C> *0H;>A
0AC;4CC0=31460=F>A:8=6>=$8<<4380C4;H  =8C80;;HB74F>A:432;84=C
2>=C02C 2><<D=820C8>= F8C7 ?7>=4 0=3 4<08;  $B  A44 F0B CA08=43 8= 8;4E8=4
NB B>5CF0A4 ?A>3D2C 34B86=43 C> 5028;8C0C4 2;84=C 20B4 <0=064<4=C C> <0:4
022DA0C4=>C4B&DC;>>:C74?7>=4BHBC4<0=3C4GC8=65D=2C8>=B>=>==42C )74
F0BC74=CA08=43C>;>>:D?3>2D<4=CBC><0:4BDA4C74H703144=58;431DCB74383
=>C58;42;08<B *A08=8=60C5>AC74$$#F0BCH?820;;H8=6A>D?B4CC8=6B
F8C7*0H;>A 0AC;4CC DBD0;;H ;4038=6 F8C7 !40=84 );4033 ;4038=6 >= >220B8>=  >A
+ ) 2;84=CB$B A44?0AC828?0C438=38B2DBB8>=B>5F70CC>;>>:5>A8=0D38>6A0<B 
>A+ ) 2;84=CBB74F0BC0D67CC>;>>:5>A24AC08=B785CB>=0D38>6A0<BC>34C4A<8=4
F782720C46>AHC742;84=C14;>=6438= )74F0B0;B>C0D67CC>;>>:5>ABC0ACDB064
30C40=34=3DB06430C40=3C74=C>20;2D;0C4C743DA0C8>=>5C74DB064 338C8>=0;;H
$B A44F0BC0D67CC><0:4BDA40=0<4>=0=0D38>6A0<<0C2743C74?0AC82D;0A
2;84=C>=F7>B420B4B74F0BF>A:8=6 >C7$B A440=3$B 0AA8B>=A4<0A:43
C70C0BC0<?4324AC85820C8>=;8:4<0A:0CC741>CC><>5+60=30=0D38>6A0<BF4A4
=>CB8<8;0A;H?A4B4=C>=+ ) 0D38>6A0<B 
B 383 C74 >C74A BC055 $B  A44 2>=58A<43 C70C C74 +60=30= 2;84=CB F4A4
CA40C43C74B0<40B0=H>C74A2;84=C >AC74BD??;4<4=C0C8>=!D;H 	3403;8=4C>
D?;>03A42>A3BC748A8;4E8=4BHBC4<F0BF74A4C74A42>A3BF4A4;>20C43CH?820;;H
70E8=6144=A4248E435A><>;;H=40A40=3B4=CC>0343820C43$40A?;D64<08;
033A4BB &220B8>=0;;H02;84=CF>D;3B4=30A42>A338A42C;HC>C74343820C434<08;
033A4BB  70=;H= A44 0=3*0H;>A 0AA8B>= F7> 1460= C74 A024 '4A8>3 ?D;;8=6
A42>A3B5A><C7458A<NB8;4E8=4BC0C43C70CF8C79DBCCF>>AC7A4430HBC>6>C74H
F4A4 ?A>E8343 F8C7 0 &=4A8E4 0=3 C>;3 C> ?D;; A42>A3B 5A>< C74A4  #8:4 $B 
0AA8B>=$B A440CC74C8<4C74A024'4A8>31460=F0B?D;;435A><>C74A58A<
F>A:C>D?;>030D38>6A0<B0=3F0BC>;3C>9DBC<0C27C742;84=CNB=0<4F8C7C74
=0<4>=C740D38>6A0<;>>:5>A0=0D38>6A0<270AC0=3C>D?;>030B@D82:;H0B
?>BB81;4 *7458A<NB&=4A8E42>=C08=437D=3A43B>50D38>6A0<B *74H14;84E43
1DCF8C7>DC38A42C:=>F;4364C70CC74A42>A3B20<45A><>;;H=40A4 
;4G (>B0;4B F7> BC0AC43 0C C74 58A< 0B 0= 8=C4A= 8= 	 F78;4 0 2>;;464
BCD34=C383@D8C40;>C>5F>A:>=C74$;8C860C8>=1DC703?A8<0A8;H<>E43
Case 3:19-md-02885-MCR-HTC Document 4190 Filed 12/05/25 Page 9 of 37
 	
>E4AC>>C74A20B4B1HC74C8<4C74A024'4A8>3F>A:F0BA4@D8A43 )74F0B38A42C43
C>0BB8BC8=C70C455>AC0=303E8B43C70C0C58ABC3DA8=6C74A024'4A8>3C74HF4A4>=;H
F>A:8=6F8C7A42>A3B8=C748A8;4E8=4BHBC4<C74A4F0B;4BB?A4BBDA40=3C74H703
C8<4C>;>>:0CC740D38>6A0<B -74=0CC74C08;4=3>50E4A10;BC0CDBA4?>AC$B 
(>B0;4B F0B 68E8=6 *0H;>A 0AC;4CC 40A;H 8= C74 A024 '4A8>3 B74 B083 F8C7 0
7D<>A>DB C>=4 KF4 BDA4 B44 0 ;>C >5 A  >1 L $B  0AA8B>= 0=3 $B  A44
A4<4<14AB448=6C70C=0<40;>C0BF4;; $A 0AC;4CCNBA4B?>=B4F0BK 383=NC740A
C70C 3>=NC:=>FF70CH>DNA4B0H8=6 L4383=>C8=@D8A45DAC74A $B (>B0;4BB083
C74BC055383B?>CB><48BBD4BF8C730C4B0=3=>C8243C70CC74+60=30=0D38>6A0<B
F4A4 38554A4=C 8= 0??40A0=24 5A>< C74 + )  0D38>6A0<B  *74 >=;H 38A42C8>= B74
A420;;BF8C7C74+60=30=0D38>6A0<BC7>D67F0BC><0:4BDA4C74=0<4F0BA867C
0=3C743>2D<4=CF0B0=0D38>6A0< )743>4B=>CA420;;0=H38A42C8E4C>14>=C74
;>>:>DC5>A0=HC78=6CA>D1;4B><48=C74A42>A3B $B (>B0;4B3>4BA420;;C70C3DA8=6
C7458ABC?0AC>5C74A024'4A8>3F74=;>>:8=6<>A42;>B4;H0CC740D38>6A0<BC74H
>220B8>=0;;HF>D;358=3>=4C70CF0B>DC>5C8<4A460A38=6F74=C740D38>6A0<F0B
C0:4= -74=8C1420<4ADB743C74H>=;H703C8<4C><0C27=0<4B=>C4C74?A4B4=24
>50=0D38>6A0<6A0?71DC2>D;3=NC;>>:0CC740D38>6A0<5>A0=HC78=64;B4 )74
544;BC70CC74ADB71460=$>=30H>5C74;0BCF44:424<14A>A24AC08=;H1H
*D4B30H 
-438B2DBB43C740??40A0=24>5C74+60=30=0D38>6A0<BCAH8=6C>;40A=85
C74BC055=>C82430=HC78=601>DCC740D38>6A0<BC70CF0B>DC>5C74>A38=0AH *74
+60=30=>=4BF4A4BCA0=64B74B0831420DB4C74HF4A45>A486=1DC0C58ABCC74+ ) 
0D38>6A0<BB44<43BCA0=641420DB4C74HF4A4=>CC74CH?4>5<43820;A42>A3BC74H
F4A4DB43C>B448=6 )74?>8=C43>DCC74HF4A4DB43C>KF>A:8=6F8C7F>A3B=>C
6A0?7B L$B (>B0;4B0;B>A4;0H43C70C3DA8=6C7458ABC?0AC>5C74A024'4A8>3C74
0D38>6A0<BF4A40;;2><8=65A><C748A8;4E8=4BHBC4< *74=0A>D=3$>=30H>A
*D4B30HC74HA4248E430&=4A8E4=>CBDA4F74A48C20<45A><0=3F4A4C>;3C>
A4CA84E40D38>6A0<B5>AD?;>038=65A><C74A4F8C7?A4BBDA4C>D?;>030B50BC0BC74H
2>D;3 
B=>C4301>E4 +60=30=0D38>6A0<BF4A4D?;>0343145>A4C74D=8E4AB4
>50E08;01;4A4?>ACBF0B4G?0=3438=C744H4B>5*0H;>A0AC;4CC &5C7>B4 A4?>ACB
0D38>6A0<BF4A4D?;>03431H*0H;>A0AA8B>=F7>03E8B43C70CB74F0B>=;H
8=BCAD2C43 C> 2><?0A4 C74 =0<4 >= C74 A4?>AC F8C7 C74 2;08< 0=3 2>=58A< 0=
0D38>6A0<6A83F0B?A4B4=C $B 0AA8B>=F0B=4E4A>=0A4E84FC40<0=3F0B=NC
Case 3:19-md-02885-MCR-HTC Document 4190 Filed 12/05/25 Page 10 of 37
 	
CA08=438=0=H0B?42C>5F70CC>;>>:5>A8=0=0D38>6A0<  C8B2;40A5A><38B2DBB8>=B
F8C7C74C7A44BC055?4AB>=B01>E4C74A4F0B=4E4A038A42C8>=>ACA08=8=6C>;>>:5>A
4=CA84B >= 0D38>6A0<B =>A C74 0D38>6A0<B 64=4A0;;H 5>A >DC>5C74 >A38=0AH
BC0C4<4=CB >A FA8C8=6B B8<?;H 38BB8<8;0A C> F70C F0B B44= 8= 0 CH?820; + ) 
0D38>6A0< *74A4F0B=NC0=H38A42C8>=5A><0AC;4CC>AA>BBC>;>>:5>A?>BB81;4
8=3820C8>=B>55A0D3=>A0=HCA08=8=6>=7>FC>B?>CBDB?828>DB=0AA0C8E4B>A6A0?7B 

*74D=34AB86=438=C4AE84F43C745&gt;DA?0AC=4AB&gt;5C70CF4A48=E&gt;;E438=



C74 $  $#  #4F 0AA8B>= 5>D=38=6 ?0AC=4A 0C 4=8=64A 0AA8B>= 0E8B
F0B8=E>;E438=14;;F4C74A02C8E8C84B8=C74$$# 0H;>A0AC;4CC!40=84
);4033 0=3 -8;;80< A>BB F4A4 C74 30HC>30H <0=064AB >5 C74 ;8C860C8>= 8=
60C74A8=6 8=5>A<0C8>= A4;4E0=C C> C74 58A<NB 2;84=CB 6>8=6 5>AF0A3 8= C74 4E4=C >5
CA80;B >A B4CC;4<4=C  -74= 0 B4CC;4<4=C F0B A402743 8C F0B 0AC;4CC );4033 0=3
A>BB C70C <0=0643 C74 2;84=C 0224?C0=24 0=3 2;08<B ?A02C824 C> A4?A4B4=C C748A
2;84=CBN>1942C8E4B>5148=62><?4=B0C435>A8=9DA84B 0AA8B>=:=4FC74BD1<8BB8>=
>52;08<B5>A2;84=CB8=E>;E4306A40C340;>5C427=820;:=>F7>F0=3B:8;;F7827
74383=>C?>BB4BB -78;474<08=C08=4307867;4E4;?>;82H0=3BD?4AE8B8>=?>B8C8>=
>E4A0H;>A!40=840=38;;74F0B=>C8=E>;E438=BD?4AE8B8=6BC0558=3>8=6C748A
9>1B8=BD??>AC>5C7>B4>C74AC7A44?0AC=4AB B8345A><0=0F0A4=4BBC70CC7458A<
A4?A4B4=C430=D<14A>5+60=30=2;84=CBF7>F>A:430B2>=CA02C>ABC>BD??>ACC74


    

  • ) 8= A0@0=35670=8BC0=3DA8=6C7>B4F0AB0=3C70CC7458A<F0BF>A:8=6F8C7
0;0FH4A8=+60=30C70C7034G?4A84=248=74;?8=6+60=30=BF8C72;08<B5>A8=9DA84B
D=A4;0C43C>C7440A?;D6B0AA8B>=383=>C142><40F0A4>50=HB?428582BA4;0C8E4C>
+60=30=2;08<BD=C8;C74A>F=A44AD38C(4?>AC20<4>DC
-8;;80<A>BB8BC74?0AC=4AF7>7403BD?C748=C0:434?0AC<4=C *74
+60=30= =0C8>=0;BN A4?A4B4=C0C8>= BC0AC43 F8C7 0 70=35D; J 0??A>G8<0C4;H  J
A454AA435A><;010<0;0FH4A0A>=0AC;0= %>C;>=605C4AC70C$A A>BBA4248E43
0=4<08;5A><>;;H=40A4F8C70=>C74A?4AB>=A0507$DB>:40B:8=601>DCC74
40A?;D6;8C860C8>= *74H4<08;438=8C80;;H0=3C74=7030/>><<44C8=6 48=3820C43
C74A4F4A4B4E4A0;8=38E83D0;B74F0BF>A:8=6F8C7C7A>D67>;;H=40A4C70C703
50<8;80A8CH F8C7 C74 40A?;D6 20B4  $DB>:4 703 >C74A 4G?4A84=24 74;?8=6 +60=30=
=0C8>=0;B F8C7 454=B4 0B4 2C  20B4B  4 0;B> 703 144= 02C8E4 F8C7
+60=30=B ?A4 0=3 ?>BC 34?;>H<4=C C> F0A I>=4B 5>A <4A820= 2>=CA02C>AB
Case 3:19-md-02885-MCR-HTC Document 4190 Filed 12/05/25 Page 11 of 37
 	
BB4=C80;;H C74H F>A:43 >DC 0= 0AA0=64<4=C F74A4 $DB>:4 F>D;3 5028;8C0C4
+60=30==0C8>=0;BB44:8=6A4?A4B4=C0C8>=5>A740A8=6;>BB8=C74$40A?;D6$# 
A4@D8A430B86=43A4C08=4A06A44<4=C0=8=C0:45>A<?A>E838=634<>6A0?782B
4G?>BDA48=5>A<0C8>=<43820;A42>A3B ?0BB?>AC2>?H>54<?;>H<4=C2>=CA02C
>AB><43>2D<4=C0C8>=>54<?;>H<4=C8=0F0AI>=45>AC74+) &=4C78=6 =>C43
8=<0=H>5C74A4C08=4A06A44<4=CBF4A4C74F>A3B>;;H=40A4?A8=C4314;>FC74
B86=0CDA4;8=45>AC742;84=C *7>B4F>A3BF4A4BD??;8431H$A $DB>:40=3F4A4
<40=C1H78<C>B46A460C4C74?4AB>=BF>A:8=638A42C;HF8C7>AC7A>D6778< *74
A4C08=4A06A44<4=CBF8C7C74>;;H=40A4=0<4=D<14A43 383=>C70E4
0 2>=E4AB0C8>= F8C7 $DB>:4 01>DC 0 A454AA0; 544 0AA0=64<4=C  >F4E4A 
2>=B834A4378<10B43>=$DB>:4NBA4?A4B4=C0C8>=0;824=B43;0FH4A8=+60=30=
0=3 A454AA8=6 2>D=B4;    F0B 0F0A4 C70C >;;H=4 0A4 F0B 0= %& C70C
2>=CA02C43F8C7C746>E4A=<4=CC>0BB8BCA4CDA=8=6+60=30=B5A><F0AI>=4B ;>C
>52><<D=820C8>=F8C7+60=30=2;84=CBF4=CC7A>D67>;;H=40A4>A$DB>:4B8=24
<0=H>5C74<383=>C70E40224BBC>4<08;?4AB>=0;;H  C8B2;40A5A><38B2DBB8>=B 
703 F8C7 A0507 $DB>:4 0=3  ?0AC=4AB C70C A>BB F0B $DB>:4NB ?A8<0AH
2>=C02C C7A>D67>DC  $A  A>BB ?A>E8343 2>?84B >5 $A  $DB>:4NB ?0BB?>AC 0=3
=0C8>=0; 834=C85820C8>= 20A3  4 0;B> ?A>E8343 0 ?7>C>2>?H >5 0 BC0<? F7827 F0B
A4?A4B4=C43C>78<1H$DB>:40B2>=58A<0C8>=>578BBC0CDB0B0;824=B43;0FH4A 
A>BB 06A443 C70C F8C7>DC <>A4 8C A40;;H 383 =>C 2>=58A< $DB>:4NB BC0CDB 0B 0
;824=B43;0FH4A *7>B4C7A448C4<B>5834=C85820C8>=<4=C8>=43F4A4>1C08=431H$A 
A>BB3DA8=6<H8=E4BC860C8>=>5C74<0CC4AB0C70=30=30C<HA4@D4BC *74H383=>C
E4C$DB>:41DC383A4B40A27>;;H=40A4  CB44<432A4381;4C> %>>=40C
E4CC430=H>5C74<43820;?A>E834ABD=C8;05C4AC74A>F=A44AD38CF74=
C74H2>=C02C43C74$8=8BCAH>540;C70=3;40A=43C70C*74>>3>2C>AB2;8=82NB
;824=B4F0B05>A64AH ;8:4F8B4383=>C2742:8=C>C74A4?4C8C8E4B86=>551H
>=43>2C>A>=0D38>6A0<B 
<>=6 C74 834=C8584AB BD1<8CC43 1H C74 +60=30= 2;08<0=CB <40=C C>
34<>=BCA0C4 ?A>>5 >5 DB4 >5 C74 $  40A?;D6B F4A4 ;4CC4AB >5 0??A4280C8>=
24AC85820C4 >5 B4AE824 ;>20C8>= ?7>C>B 0=3 >C74A 834=C8584AB C70C C74 +60=30=
8=38E83D0;2>=CA02C>AF0B4<?;>H431H02><?0=H?A>E838=6B42DA8CH8=C74C740C4A
>5 F0A  %>=4 >5 C7>B4 3>2D<4=CB ?A>E8343 0=HC78=6 <>A4 C70= 28A2D<BC0=C80;
4E834=24>54<?;>H<4=C A>BB06A443F8C7<4C70CC7424AC85820C4B>54<?;>H<4=C
5>A02>=CA02C>AC>F>A:0C38554A4=C10B4B383=>C033A4BBF70C850=H4G?>BDA4C74
Case 3:19-md-02885-MCR-HTC Document 4190 Filed 12/05/25 Page 12 of 37
 	
+60=30=B703C>4G?;>B8>=B>A6D=58A4 %>A383C74H834=C85HC74$40A?;D6B
0BC74740A8=6?A>C42C8E434E824F>A=1HC74+60=30=B *7438A42C4<?;>H4A>54027
>5C74+60=30=2>=CA02C>ABCDA=43$#?;08=C8552>D;370E4BD??;843C74<F8C7C74
$40A?;D6C><0C27C7>B4148=6DB431H02C8E4<8;8C0AH8=C740A40>A2>D;3
70E4144=40A?;D6B>1C08=43B?4285820;;H1HC744<?;>H4A 
=C0:4BC055F0BCA08=43>=C7458A<NB20B4<0=064<4=CBHBC4<0=3D?;>038=6
3>2D<4=CB0BC74H20<48=C>C70CBHBC4< A>BB?4AB>=0;;H;8:4B70A32>?84B0=3B>
74703C74BC055<08=C08=0?0A0;;4;B4C>558;4B5>AC7>B4 -74=0B:4301>DC2742:8=6
3DA8=6 8=C0:4 01>DC 270A02C4A8BC82B >5 3>2D<4=CB C70C 20DB43 >=4 C> @D4BC8>= C74
;468C8<02H>502;08<>A2;84=C7403E8B43C70C<>BC>5F70CC74HF>D;3A4248E4F4A4
B>A?0BB?>ACB0=374B0F=>A40B>=C>@D4BC8>=C748A;468C8<02H *742>=B8BC4=C
8BBD4B703C>3>F8C7C74>A34A>5=0<4B58ABCE4ABDB;0BC0=330C4B ??A>G8<0C4;H
J 	>5C74+60=30=2;84=CB383=>C70E47030= >A?0BB?>AC1DCF4A4BC8;;
?A>24BB43 
'0AC=4A !40=84 );4033 703 0 E4AH 5D;; 0=3 02C8E4 A>;4 8= C74 14;;F4C74A 0=3
F0E4?A>24BB &=24C74B4CC;4<4=CF0BA402743B7438370E40A>;48=CA08=8=6BC055
8=F70CC>;>>:5>AA460A38=6B4AE8242>==42C43DB064>5C7440A?;D65>A0;;
2;84=CB )740CC4=343<>BCC>F=70;;<44C8=6BA460A38=6C74B4CC;4<4=C?A>6A0< 4A
=0<4 3>4B 0??40A 8= C74 A>F=A44A C01;4 A45;42C8=6 F7> 5A><  D?;>0343
0D38>6A0<B3DA8=6C74A024'4A8>3 $B );4033F0B=>CCH?820;;H8=E>;E438=C74
D?;>038=6>53>2D<4=CB8=C>C74)4CC;4<4=C'A>6A0<03<8=8BC4A431HA>F=A44A 
>F4E4A3DA8=6C74A024'4A8>32AD=27B74383?4A5>A<C70CA>;4C>B><44GC4=C 
E4= C74= 74A A>;4 F0B ;8<8C43 1420DB4 B74 F0B CA0E4;8=6 3DA8=6 C70C F44: 
22>A38=6 C> *01;4  8= C74 A>F=A44AD38C (4?>AC $B  );4033 D?;>0343 	
0D38>6A0<B8=C7458ABC30HB>5C74A024'4A8>30=38=C74;0BC30HB 4A
8=BCAD2C8>=B5>AC74B4D?;>03BF4A4C74B0<40BC70C68E4=C>BC055J<0C27=0<4B0=3
<0:4 BDA4 C74 3>2D<4=C F0B 0= 0D38>6A0<  &E4A0;; 74A F>A: F8C7 C74 +60=30=
20B4BF0B@D8C4;8<8C43 
*74$$#F0B1H?0AC=4A*0H;>A0AC;4CCNB34B2A8?C8>=K78B
?A>942C L0AC;4CC0B>5C78BFA8C8=68B=>;>=64A0BB>280C43F8C70=3>22D?84B0
?>B8C8>= 8= C74 >F;8=4 #0F 58A<  *70C 74 8B => ;>=64A 4<?;>H43 1H  8B
8AA4;4E0=CB8=24C742>=3D2C148=68=E4BC860C43>22DAA433DA8=6C70C4<?;>H<4=C0=3
3DA8=678BA4?A4B4=C0C8>=>52;84=CB8=;8C860C8>=?A4B8343>E4A1HC74>=>A01;4
Case 3:19-md-02885-MCR-HTC Document 4190 Filed 12/05/25 Page 13 of 37
 	
$ 0B4H(>364AB0=3BD1942CC>74A>A34AB0=3C7420==>=B>5?A>54BB8>=0;2>=3D2C
6>E4A=8=6C70CA4?A4B4=C0C8>= *74D=34AB86=438B0F0A4>538B06A44<4=CB14CF44=
0=30AC;4CC0=3>F;8=4A460A38=6F78272>D=B4;A4?A4B4=CC742;84=CB
05C4AC74B4?0A0C8>=>50AC;4CC5A>< *74>DAC70B>A34A43C7>B48=E>;E43C>
58;4 055830E8CB 8= 20<4A0 F7827 0A4 3D4 145>A4 C78B (( F8;; 14 58;43  *74
D=34AB86=43 3>4B =>C ?>BB4BB :=>F;4364 C70C C74 38B?DC4 F8;; 14 A4;4E0=C C> C78B
8=@D8AH0=3A4?>AC8=6 
#4F0AA8B>=F0B24AC08=;HC74B4=8>A;0FH4A0C1DC=>C8=E>;E438=C74
30HC>30H<0=064<4=C>5C78B;8C860C8>= 4F0B;4035A><07867;4E4;4 6 8=78B
F>A3B KC78B 8B F74A4 F4 0A4 6>8=6 C74B4 0A4 C74 20B4B F4 0A4 C0:8=6 C78B 8B C74
2A8C4A80 C78B 8B 7>F <0=H 20B4B  F0=C C> 58;4  3>=NC F0=C C> 58;4 C74B4 20B4B L
0AA8B>=022>A38=6C>0AC;4CC703>E4A0A278=6?>;82H2>=CA>;<44C8=6A46D;0A;H
F8C7C74$C40<0B:8=65>AD?30C4B<0:8=63428B8>=B01>DCCA0E4;0=334?>B8C8>=B
0=3B?4=38=6<>=4H 
0AC;4CC;8:48;;A>BBB083C7458ABC+60=30=2;84=CB20<4C7A>D670A454AA0;
5A><0A>= 0AC;0= -74= +60=30= A454AA0;B 5A>< 78< 3A>??43 >55 C74H 703 =>
+60=30=A454AA0;BD=C8;A0507$DB>:4A402743>DC *74A405C4A<>BC>5C74+60=30=
2;84=CBF4A4$DB>:4A454AA0;BF8C7?4A70?B 	 	2><8=638A42C;HC>C7A>D67
F>A3>5<>DC75A><>C74A2;84=CB *748=C0:4?A>24BB02CD0;;HF0B270=6435>AC74
+60=30=B1DC>=;HC>C744GC4=CA4@D8A43C74<C>BD1<8C0=8=C0:45>A<24=BDB
5>A< 0=3?A>>5>5DB440A;84AC70=+ ) 2;84=CBC>64C0A>D=3B><42><<D=820C8>=
8BBD4B 
)8=24B><0=H20B4B20<4C7A>D67A0507$DB>:4 0B:430AC;4CC01>DCC748A
E4CC8=6?A>24BB>578<  =0338C8>=C>?7>=420;;BI>><20;;B0=34<08;BC74HE4CC43
A0507 F8C7 8=C4A=4C A4B40A27 ?A8<0A8;H  *74H 5>D=3 E0A8>DB A454A4=24B 5A><
8=C4A=0C8>=0;083>A60=8I0C8>=B8=F7827C74H;8BC43>;;H=40A40B0K;468C8<0C4L
%& 8= F7827 C74H F4A4 ?A>E838=6 A4B>DA24B C> *74H 0B:43 5>A 78B A468BCA0C8>=
3>2D<4=CB5>A>;;H=40A4F782774?A>E83438=K 	>AB> L?0AC=4AB383
=>CA4?A4B4=CC><4C70CC74HE4CC43>;;H=40A48=C70CC8<45A0<41H2>=C02C8=6
C74 $8=8BCAH >5 40;C7 0B C74H 383 3DA8=6 C78B 8=E4BC860C8>=  *74A45>A4 C74 58A<
20==>C34<>=BCA0C4C70CC74 	24AC85820C4F0B64=D8=4>AB8<?;H0=>C74A5>A64AH
0BC74H;0C4A;40A=4301>DCC742DAA4=C24AC85820C4 F0B2>?8438=4AA>AC74H
14;84E4>=0=4<08;14CF44=A05070=30+);0F58A<C70C703>1C08=430E4A382C
Case 3:19-md-02885-MCR-HTC Document 4190 Filed 12/05/25 Page 14 of 37
 	
>A B4CC;4<4=C 8= 0 454=B4 0B4 2C 20B4 0=3 C74 + )  58A< F0B A4@D4BC8=6
8=5>A<0C8>=01>DC7>FC>F8A4C742;84=C78B<>=4H *74K4AA>=4>DB8=2;DB8>=L>=
0=4<08;F0B0CC74C8<4C74HF4A44E0;D0C8=6A0507 *74H54;CC78B60E42A434=24
C>78B2;08<C70C74703;468C8<0C42;84=CBF7>F4A48=9DA43 0AC;4CCF0B=>C0F0A4
0C C74 C8<4 >5 <H 8=C4AE84F >5 0=H =4FB 022>D=CB >5A0507 148=6 022DB43 >5
345A0D38=6<0=H+60=30=B *74H383=>CE4C0=H>5C74<43820;?A>E834ABD=C8;C74
A>F=A44AD38C(4?>AC20<4>DC $A 0AC;4CCB08374F0B=>C>5C748<?A4BB8>=
C70C+60=30F0B:=>F=5>A5A0D32><<8CC431H8CB28C8I4=B 0B43>=<8BB8>=0AH
4G?4A84=24B >5 B><4 ?4>?;4 8= 78B 50<8;H 74 14;84E43 +60=30 70B 0 KB?4280;
A4;0C8>=B78?LF8C7C74+=8C43)C0C4B *74+=8C43)C0C4B4?0AC<4=C>5)C0C4F41B8C4
<0:4B @D8C4 2;40A C70C >DA 6>E4A=<4=C 58=3B +60=30 C> 14 0 2>D=CAH F74A4
<4A820=BCA0E4;8=6>A3>8=61DB8=4BB<DBCD=34ABC0=3C70C5A0D38B?A4E0;4=C0=3
20DC8>=<DBC144G4A28B43F74=CA0E4;8=6>A3>8=61DB8=4BBC74A4 
A0507F0B=>C?0830=HC78=61H0=370B=>4G?42C0C8>=>564CC8=6?083
0B50A0B0AC;4CC:=>FB 
 	-74=0B:43C74B?428582@D4BC8>=0AC;4CCB083383=>CCAHC>64CC74?A4
4<?;>H<4=C <43820; 4G0<8=0C8>= A42>A3B 5A>< 0=H >5 C74 2>=CA02C>AB 78A8=6 C74
+60=30=B  =502C74383=>CD=34ABC0=3C70CC742>=CA02C>AB383?A44<?;>H<4=C
<43820; 4G0<8=0C8>=B D=C8;  0B:43 C70C @D4BC8>=  =C4A4BC8=6;H 74 383 A420;; C70C
>;;H=40A4?4A5>A<43?A44<?;>H<4=C<43820;4G0<8=0C8>=B0=314;84E4BB><4
>5C740D38>6A0<BC74H70E4>=+60=30=2;84=CBF4A4A454A4=240D38>6A0<B?A8>AC>
C74 +60=30=B ;40E8=6 5>A F>A: 8= C74 F0A I>=4B  -74= 0B:43 85 C74 A454A4=24
0D38>6A0<B F4 38B2DBB43 5A>< >;;H=4 0A4 F>D;3 70E4 144= D?;>0343 C>
A>F=A44A74B083=>C=424BB0A8;H 0AC;4CC4G?;08=431H38B2DBB8=6C74A468BCA0C8>=
?A>24BB 5>A B4CC;4<4=C F74A4 H>D 2>D;3 27>>B4 4G?438C43 ?0H >A 3454AA43 ?0H 
454AA43 ?0H 2;84=CB C74<B4;E4B 2>D;3 D?;>03 3>2D<4=CB 0=3 B><4 383 1>C7
+60=30=B0=3<4A820=B DCF>D;3=>C=424BB0A8;H:=>FD=;4BBC74H;>>:43
0C 4E4AH 58;4 >5 C748A 2;84=CB 0C A>F=A44A  4 34B2A814B F70C 74 20;;43 0 K;D;;L
14CF44=!0=D0AH0=3!D;HC74''BD??;4<4=C0C8>=?4A8>3 >A4E4AH''2;84=C
C74H703+60=30=0=3+ ) F4=CC7A>D67C748ABHBC4<C>58=34E4AH<43820;
A42>A3C74H7035>AC748A''2;84=CB )C0AC8=68=!0=D0AH>5 	C74H34E4;>?430
?A>24BBF74A4C74H7030B?A403B744C0=3C748AC40<>5?4>?;4;>>:430C  	>A
 	''2;84=CB+60=30=0=3+ ) 58;4BC>58=3A454A4=240=38=9DAH0D38>6A0<B 
*74H DB43 C74 A>F=A44A '' 20;2D;0C>A 8=?DCC8=6 C74 0D38>6A0<B 0=3 C74
Case 3:19-md-02885-MCR-HTC Document 4190 Filed 12/05/25 Page 15 of 37
 	 
20;2D;0C>A F>D;3 KB?8CL >DC ?>8=CB  *74B4 20;2D;0C8>=B C74H DB43 8=7>DB4 =>C
D?;>038=6 C> A>F=A44A B> F74= C74H 6>C ?>8=CB 102: 5A>< A>F=A44A C74H
2>D;32><?0A4F8C7C748A8=7>DB4=D<14AB  510B43>=C748A0=0;HB8B02;84=CC70C
27>B4''0=3F0B=>C4=C8C;43C>?>8=CB5A><0;;C74<43820;A42>A3BC7458A<703
C74H383=>C8=C4=3C>D?;>030=0D38>6A0<0=35>AB><4>5C748A2;84=CBC74A4F0B
>=;H>=4 KCC70C?>8=C8=C8<4>DAD=34ABC0=38=6F0B8502;84=C27>B4''0=3
4E4=85C74H383=NCD?;>030B8=6;40D38>6A0<C74HF>D;3144=C8C;43C>0  	
A468BCA0C8>=?0H<4=CL022>A38=6C>0AC;4CC >A<0=H>5C74+60=30=B3DA8=6C74
!0=D0AHC>!D;H 	''BD??;4<4=C0C8>=?4A8>3C74H383=>CD?;>030D38>6A0<B 
 	-74= 0B:4301>DCBC055CA08=8=60AC;4CCBC0C43C70C8=C0:4BC055?A8<0A8;H
A4?>AC43C>8;;A>BB 0AC;4CC0=3A>BBKF>D;3<44CF8C7C74<0=34G?;08=F70C
C> 3> F8C7 C74 E0A8>DB ?7HB820; 3>2D<4=CB F4 703 F74A4 C74H 6> 8= C74 20B4
<0=064<4=CBHBC4<7>FC>A4?>AC8=C>C74J7>FC>CH?48=C>C7420B4<0=064<4=C
BHBC4< 38554A4=C 8=5>A<0C8>= F74C74A 8C 14 5A>< C74 8=C0:4 5>A< 2><<D=820C8>=
F8C7C74A454AA8=6B>DA2424=BDB5>A<8=5>A<0C8>=2742:1>G4BC70CF4F>D;3F0=C
B> C70C F4 2>D;3 34C4A<8=4 F74C74A C78B F0B 0 2>=CA02C>A >A 0 E4C4A0= H40AB >5
B4AE824F74A4C>?;024 	B 
 	K-4703C><44CF8C7C74<F74=C74+60=30=BCD55JF74=+60=30=2;84=CB
JF74=F4BC0AC4364CC8=6<>A4+60=30=2;84=CB *74E>;D<4?82:43D?  BC0AC43
=>C828=638B2A4?0=284B8=C74F0HC70CC74HFA>C4C74=0<4B0=330C4B>518AC78=>DA
BHBC4< L0AC;4CCCA0=B2A8?C?064B  	
 	38B2DBB43F8C7$A 0AC;4CCC74?A>24BB4<?;>H431H5>A0CC08=8=60=3
4G0<8=8=6<43820;A42>A3B &=24B4CC;4<4=CF0B0==>D=2430=3C78=6B703C>64C
3>=4@D82:;HC74H703C>64C<43820;A42>A3B5>A0;;C7440A?;D62;84=CB *74H
<>E43 4GCA0 ?4>?;4 >E4A 5A>< 8=C0:4 0=3 >=4>55 20B4B  *74H 78A43 C4<?>A0AH
?4>?;4383B785CF>A:78A43=DAB4BC>2><48=05C4AF>A:8=6030HB785C0C78;3A4=NB
>B?8C0; F7> F>D;3 A4E84F A42>A3B D?;>03 0=3 BD1<8C D=C8; <83=867C *74H 383
BD1BC0=C8E4A4E84F>5<43820;A42>A3B&()30C04C2 &=24C74A42>A3BF4A4
A4CA84E43C74H703C>CA08=BC0550BC>F70CC>;>>:5>A8=<43820;A42>A3B0=3703
0;<>BC308;H<44C8=6B8=02>=54A4=24A>><C74HC>>:>E4A5>AC70C?DA?>B4 *0H;>A
!40=84 8;; $0AH B7C>= *0H;>ANB ?0A0;460; 2>=3D2C43 @D4BC8>= 0=3 0=BF4A
B4BB8>=B0;<>BC308;H $A 0AC;4CCF>D;33>B?>C2742:BC><0:4BDA4BC0558=?DCC8=6
BCD552>AA42C;H 434C4A<8=430C>=4?>8=CC70CCF>BC055?4AB>=BF4A4=>C8=?DCC8=6
Case 3:19-md-02885-MCR-HTC Document 4190 Filed 12/05/25 Page 16 of 37
 	 
8=5>A<0C8>= 2>AA42C;H 0=3 C74H F4A4 C4A<8=0C43 05C4A F7827 0AC;4CC 0BB4ACB 74
2742:434E4AHC78=6C74H383?A8>AC>C4A<8=0C8>= 
383=>C>1C08=<43820;A42>A3B38A42C;H5A><?A>E834AB5>AC74+60=30=
2;84=CB  $>BC >5 C74 A42>A3B 5>A 2;84=CB A4?A4B4=C43 1H >;;H=4 0A4 20<4 5A><
A0507 )><4A42>A3B20<45A><C742;84=CB 
-74=0B:4301>DCC74A>F=A44AD38C(4?>ACC70CBD664BC43C74A4F4A4
+60=30= 0D38>6A0<B C70C F4A4 50:4 0=3 F74C74A C74A4 F0B 0 38554A4=C E4CC8=6
?A>24BB5>A0D38>6A0<BB4CD?5>AC74+60=30=B0AC;4CCB083C74HF4A4=>CE4CC43
0=H38554A4=C;HC70=+ ) ?A8E0C4?A>E834A0D38>6A0<B -74=0B:4385C74+60=30=
64=4A0C43 0D38>6A0<B ;>>:43 38554A4=C;H >A ;8:4 C74 + )  64=4A0C43 0D38>6A0<B
0AC;4CCB083C74H;>>:43C74B0<4 >A4G0<?;4B0<4:8=3>5G0=3><0A:8=6B5>A
F7827 40A 0=3 B7>>C4AB =>C274B ?A4B4=C >= 0 ;>C >5 0D38>6A0<B  ,0;D4B F4A4 8=
A0=64B;8:4C70C>5+ ) B4AE824<4<14AB 
 	 	 	B:43 01>DC C74 4G0<?;4B A>F=A44A 8=2;D343 8= C74 0D38C
A4?>AC F8C7 ;0=6D064 K0DB43 1H C74 DB4 >5 C74 $ 40A?;D6L 8= 0D38>6A0<B
?DA?>AC43;H?4A5>A<438= 	 $A  0AC;4CCB083>=?064>5C74CA0=B2A8?CK 
C78=:C70C8B05A0D3D;4=C0D38>6A0< -4383=NC20C278C -4383=NCB448C145>A40=3
H>D:=>F0B C78=:102:01>DC>DA?A>24BB4BC74A40B>=F4383=NC20C278C8BC70C
1 1 , (7., 0$ 1$("(,,.$0 -4<?70B8B03343 .>D:=>FC743>2D<4=CBC70C
F47035>A2;84=CBC70CF4A4A4;4E0=CC>BD1<8BB8>=F4A40D38>6A0<B0=3C74E0;D4B
>5C7>B40D38>6A0<B 
 	K=3C744G7818CBC70CF4A4>=C740D38CA4?>AC0D38>6A0<BF4A4>=38554A4=C
?064B 5A>< C74 =0AA0C8E4B  ) )/, -.!! '   ($  () )(  1- &))%$(" .
(,,.$0 - !,)' 4 . .#$- *)$(. $( .$'  . 1-(7.  $. 1-(7. , & 0(. .) )/,
$(+/$,34<?70B8B03343 L0AC;4CC70BB4E4A0;BDB?828>=B0BC>7>FC748AA4E84F>5
A42>A3BC>>:C74<B?4285820;;HC>C740D38>6A0<0=3=>CC74=0AA0C8E4;0=6D0641DC
8C8B2;40A5A><<H38B2DBB8>=F8C778<C70CC748A5>2DB0=3?4A248E43A4;4E0=24F0B
B8<?;HC740D38>6A0<0=3C74C7A4B7>;3BA42>A343C74A48=F8C7>DC2>=B834A0C8>=>5
C742>=24?C>55A0D3 B5>AC74>=40D38>6A0<0AC;4CC2>=24343F0B5A0D3D;4=C
C78B)?4280;$0BC4A8B=>C0F0A4>50=H3>2D<4=C0C8>=C70C34<>=BCA0C4B0AC;4CC>A
C>>:0=H02C8>=C>F8C73A0FC740D38>6A0<5A><2>=B834A0C8>= 
Case 3:19-md-02885-MCR-HTC Document 4190 Filed 12/05/25 Page 17 of 37
 	 
 	-8C7C742><<4=C;4G(>B0;4B<034C><4C70CB743A4F0CC4=C8>=8=0;867C
740AC43F0HC>0KA>1LF7>B4=0<4:4?CB7>F8=6D?>=0D38>6A0<B?DA?>AC43;H
?4A5>A<438=+60=30 0B:4385C74A4F0B0=H38B2DBB8>=8=C7458A<48C74A0<>=6
C74 ?0AC=4AB >A BC055 01>DC F7> F0B B86=8=6 >55 >= C74 +60=30= 0D38>6A0<B
?A>E838=60=4G0<?;4>5>=40D38>;>68BC>A3>2C>AF7>B86=43>55>=0F7>;41D=27
>538554A4=C0D38>6A0<B0AC;4CCBC0C43C70C74?A>101;H;>>:430C 	 	>A  	
0D38>6A0<B64=4A0;;H0=3;8:4F8B47037D=3A43B>52>=E4AB0C8>=BF8C7BC055?4>?;4
01>DC 0D38>6A0<B 1DC 74 3>4B=NC A4<4<14A 4E4A ?4AB>=0;;H 148=6 0;4AC43 C> 0
2>=24A= 01>DC 0=H B86=0CDA4B >A =0<4B >5 ?A>E834AB  4 0608= BC0C43 C74H F4A4
;>>:8=60C0D38>6A0<B0=330C4BF74=C74HF4A4?4A5>A<43 
-74= 0B:4385C74A4F0B0=HC78=601>DCC74+60=30=A42>A3BC70C4E4AA08B43
0A435;06>A20DB43C74<C>@D4BC8>=F7HB><4C78=6F0B8=0A42>A3>A?A><?C0
=443C>;>>:8=<>A434?C70AC;4CCB083=>C?A8>AC>C74A>F=A44AD38C(4?>AC 
4 54;C F70C C74H F4A4 3>8=6 2>=58A<43 8= 78B <8=3 C70C C74 0D38>6A0<B F4A4
;468C8<0C4 *74HF4A4AD==8=6A4?>ACBF44:;HC>;>>:0C?A>6A4BBC>F0A3<44C8=6
C748A3403;8=4 *74H34C4A<8=43?>8=CE0;D4B8502;84=CF0B6>8=6'' *74H703
0E4A064 ?>8=C E0;D4B 5>AA<H <4<14AB %0EH <4<14AB 0=3 2>=CA02C>AB  *74H
5>D=3C70C01>DC>5C748A+)B4AE824<4<14ABF4A44;8681;45>A?>8=CBD=34A'' 
&5C74+60=30=B>AF4A44;8681;4 *740E4A064?>8=CB5>A+)28C8I4=BF4A4
    +60=30=BF4A4>A KDC=>C78=69D<?43>DCLC>0AC;4CC 8E4=C74
B?428582B>5$A 0AC;4CCNB0BB4AC8>=74A4C>BD664BCC70C=>C78=6F0B0B:4FF8C7C74
+60=30=2;08<B A>F=A44ANBA4B?>=B4C>0AC;4CCNB0BB4AC8>=
K-40A4=>CBDA4F7H<0:4BC78B2;08<>AF74A48C2><4B5A>< &5C74
 + ) 28C8I4=B8=C74''C7458A<A4?A4B4=CBA4248E43'>8=CB *70C8B 
F7>@D0;85H5>A'>8=CB=>CF7>383@D0;85H A4?A4B4=CB0=>C74A  	
''2;08<0=CBF8C7#4E4;  0=3#4E4;34C4A<8=0C8>=B8=C74''
F7827<40=BC74B42;08<0=CB0;B>F>D;370E4@D0;858435>AB><4'''>8=CB703
C74H4;42C43C74''8=BC403 )>  >5C7458A<NB 	''+ ) 28C8I4=B2>D;3
70E46>CC4='''>8=CB *>B0HC70CC748A508;8=6+60=30=2;08<0=CBA08B43=>
A435;06B1420DB4C748A+ )2;84=CBF4A4508;8=60CC74B0<4A0C48B@D8C418I0AA4 L
)42C8>=?064A>F=A44ANBA4?;HC>NBA4B?>=B4  	
0B:43$A 0A;4CCC>34B2A814F70CC74?A>24BBF0B5>A3DA8=6C74A024
'4A8>3  0AC;4CC C>;3 <4 C74 8=BCAD2C8>=B C> C748A C40< F0B F4NA4 =>C ;>>:8=6 5>A
Case 3:19-md-02885-MCR-HTC Document 4190 Filed 12/05/25 Page 18 of 37
 	 
?>8=CB 1420DB4 F4 70E4 0;A403H 3>=4 C70C 0=0;HB8B F4 0A4 CAH8=6 C> ?A>E834
A>F=A44A C74 0D38>6A0< C70C B7>FB B><4 B>AC >5 740A8=6 ;>BB B> C70C KC74B4
2;84=CBF8;;64CC748AA468BCA0C8>=?0H<4=C?4A8>3 L*745DAC74A8=BCAD2C8>=C>C748A
C40<F0B8C<DBC148=C7458A<NB?>BB4BB8>=145>A4!D;HC74  0AC;4CCB083C><4
K*70CNBF70CH>DB44>=?>5C740D38CA4?>AC424<14AC7A>D67424<14A
0=3 C78=:<H<0C7F0B01>DC 0D38>6A0<BF4A4D?;>03433DA8=6C70C?4A8>3 L
*74H =>C85843 0;; C748A 2;84=CB 1H 4<08; C70C C74 58A< 703 0= >1;860C8>= C> 64C C>
A>F=A44A0=H0D38>6A0<8=C74BHBC4<1H!D;H  &AA0=A>F=7>F4E4A
A4248E4305>AF0A3434<08;5A><>=4>5C742;84=CB0=3&AA0=B4=C0AC;4CC0=
4<08;0A>D=3C74>A >5424<14ABC0C8=6KH>D:=>F858C8B8=H>DA2;84=CNB
?>BB4BB8>=0B>5!D;H  	>AH>DA?>BB4BB8>=H>D<0HD?;>03C70CA42>A3 L
*70C270=643NBD=34ABC0=38=6K5D=30<4=C0;;HL0BC>F70CC74HB7>D;3D?;>03 
*74&=4A8E4<4=C8>=431H$B (>B0;4B$B A440=3$B 0AA8B>=F0BB4C
D?1HC>7>;30=H+60=30=<43820;A42>A3BA4248E4305C4A!D;H  	 )><4
2;84=CBB4=C8=A42>A3B>=C748A>F=0=3$A $DB>:4B4=C8=A42>A3B $A $DB>:48=
502CC>;3<48=05>;;>FD?8=C4AE84FC70C8=424<14A 	$A A>BBB083
F0=C430;;0D38>6A0<B6>8=6102:58E4H40AB0=3C74H>=;H703CF>F44:BC>B4=3
C74< $DB>:434B2A814BC742;84=CB0;;>5F7><703144=B4=C4<08;B022>A38=6C>
$A 0AC;4CC7DAA843;HCA843C>64CC74A42>A3B $DB>:4C>;3<4-)' )!.# , ),-
() &)(" , 2$-.  /. ' $& *,)0$ ,- 5%( 16 .#  &$ (.- (, ' ' , 
. -.$(".# '(-), , . .# /$)",'-)' /$)",'-1 , , . 
( 1/.%. *74HF4A4BC8;;60C74A8=6A42>A3BF74=A>BBC>;378<C8<4
F0B D? 0=3 =>C C> B4=3 0=H 0338C8>=0; A42>A3B  $A  0AC;4CC BC0C43 C70C 0=H
0D38>6A0<B>A>C74A<43820;A42>A3BA4248E431H05C4A!D;H F4A4?;0243
8=C74&=4A8E40=3C70C8CF0BK@D0A0=C8=43LB>C70C>=;H$A 0AC;4CC$B );4033
0=3$A A>BB7030224BBC>8C -74=C74HB4CD?C74&=4A8E4F0B>?4A0C8=6
D=34AC748<?A4BB8>=C70C0D38>6A0<B703C>148=C74?>BB4BB8>=>5F8C78=C74
!D;H 3403;8=40=3C74H383=>CF0=C0BC055?4AB>=C>8=03E4AC4=C;HD?;>030=
0D38>6A0<A4248E4305C4AC70C30C4 
5C4A C74 4<08; 5A>< &AA0= A>F= A460A38=6 C74 8=?>BB4BB8>=>5 8BBD4
*0H;>A 0AC;4CC 270=643 C74 58A<NB ?>B8C8>= C70C >=;H C74 C7A44 ?0AC=4AB 34B2A8143
74A4C>5>A47030224BBC>C74@D0A0=C8=43&=4A8E45>;34A>=+60=30 4;>>:438=
C70C 5>;34A 0=3 14;84E43 C74A4 F4A4  	 >A B> 3>2D<4=CB  0AC;4CC B083 K)> F4
34E8B430?;0=C>6>64CC74B4A42>A3BC70C0A4B8CC8=68=0B?4280;5>;34AC70C703144=
Case 3:19-md-02885-MCR-HTC Document 4190 Filed 12/05/25 Page 19 of 37
 	
@D0A0=C8=435A><C74A4BC>5C74BC055B>C70CC74A4F0B=NC0=022834=C0;D?;>03>5
B><4C78=6 -4F0=C43C><0:4BDA4F45>;;>F43JF40??A4280C43C70CC74A4F0B
C78B6A024?4A8>3 *74>DAC383=NC70E4C>3>8C 0AA4CB>=383=NC70E4C>3>8C -4
A40;8I438CF0B02>=24BB8>=0=3C70CF40??A4280C4B>F4F0=C43C><0:4BDA4F4
5>;;>F43C74;4CC4A L0AC;4CC*A0=B2A8?C?064B $A 0AC;4CC5DAC74A4G?;08=43
C70CC743>2D<4=CB8=C745>;34AF4A448C74AA4248E435A><$DB>:4>A2;84=CB0=3
703144=;8C4A0;;H3A066438=C>C745>;34A %0<4BF4A4=>C8=0=HCH?4>5>A34A0=3
>=4703C>>?4=058;4;>>:5>AC74=0<4B40A275>AC70C=0<48=C74BHBC4<
>AA>F=A44ABHBC4< *74HC74=703C><0C27C70C=0<4F8C70=0D38>6A0<0=3
D?;>03F8C7>DC2>=B834A0C8>=>5F74C74A8CF0B03D?;820C4>50=>C74AC74H0;A403H
?>BB4BB43 *74A4F0B=>CC8<4C>3>0=H:8=3>50=0;HB8B 0AC;4CCF4=C>=C>B0H
K=3B>C74?A>24BBF0B586DA4>DCC74=0<4?DC8C8=>DABHBC4<F74A48CB7>D;3
14F74A44E4AH>=420=0224BB8CC0:48C>DC>5@D0A0=C8=4D?;>038CC>A>F=A44A
8=3820C4>=>DAB?A403B744CJ 7030=>C74A>=4>5C74B4;8E4B?A403B744CBC70CB083
F7>D?;>034340273>2D<4=C0=3F7>A4E84F438C =3C74=2742:JFA8C4MH4BN8=
C78B2>;D<=C70CH>D70E4D?;>0343C78B3>2D<4=C =3C70CNBF70CF4383>=C74
0=3  L0AC;4CCCA0=B2A8?C?064B 	 	
*7458ABC8=3820C8>=703C70C5A0D3F0BBDB?42C438=C74+60=30=2;08<B
F0BF74=C74HA4248E43C74A>F=A44AD38C(4?>AC>=$0H 	 -8C7>DC
B?4285828CH8=C74A4?>AC0BC>F7>B40D38>6A0<>AA42>A3F0B0=4G0<?;4>5?>C4=C80;
5A0D3383=>C0CC4<?CC>3868=C>C740D38>6A0<B8=4027>5C742;08<B *74H
>=;HF4=C8=C>C7458;4B5>AC742;08<0=CBC70CA4248E43?>8=CBD=34A'' *74H383
=>C B44 0=HC78=6 8= C7>B4 A4E84FB C70C KBC>>3 >DC L  383 =>C 022>A38=6 C>
0AC;4CC3>0=8=34?C7B40A275>ABDB?828>DB>A?>C4=C80;;H5A0D3D;4=C0D38>6A0<B
>A>C74AA42>A3B *74H383;>>:0CC74>=4BC70CF4A40CC027430B0=4G7818CC>C74
A>F=A44AD38C(4?>ACB40A278=6C7420B4<0=064<4=CBHBC4<C74@D0A0=C8=4
5>;34AF7>D?;>0343F70CF74C74AC74A4F0BB42>=3A4E84F2><<D=820C8>=BF8C7
C742;84=C145>A40=305C4AC74A024'4A8>3 *74>=;H0D38>6A0<5>A0+60=30=2;84=C
C70CC74HA45DB43C>D?;>03F0B5>A02;84=CF7>3DA8=6C74A024'4A8>3B08374
F4=CC>78B0D38>;>68BCF7>C>;3C70C2;84=CC70CC74A4F0B0=4AA>A8=78B?A4E8>DB;H
FA8CC4= 0D38>6A0< 0=3 C70C 2;84=C F0=C43 C> 70E4  D?;>03 C74 2>AA42C43
0D38>6A0<1DC$A 0AC;4CCA45DB43 

Case 3:19-md-02885-MCR-HTC Document 4190 Filed 12/05/25 Page 20 of 37

 	
&1E8>DB;H0:4H?4AB>=8=C78B8=@D8AH0=3C74BC>AH>5+60=30=2;08<B58;43
1H  8B A0507 "08C0;4 $DB>:4  *7A>D67>DC C74 E0A8>DB 3>2D<4=CB 0=3
A454A4=24B C> C78B ?4AB>= 78B =0<4 8B B?4;;43 0 E0A84CH >5 F0HB *74 D=34AB86=43
27>>B4BC7458ABC<833;40=3;0BC=0<4BDB430=3B?4;;438=C78BA4?>AC1420DB48C8B
C74 =0<4 C70C 0??40AB >= $A  $DB>:4NB ?0BB?>AC 0=3 =0C8>=0; 834=C85820C8>= 20A3 
>?84B>5C7>B4F4A4BD??;843C><41H-8;;80<A>BB0C<HA4@D4BC -4A4C78BA4?>AC
FA8CC4= 5>A 0 +60=30= CA81D=0; 8C F>D;3 14 2DBC><0AH C> A454A C> C74 ?4AB>= 0B
$DB>:4A0507"08C0;04 +60=30==0<8=62>=E4=C8>=2A40C438BBD4B5>A0=3
C748ABC0555>A0B7>AC?4A8>3>5C8<4 
$A  $DB>:4 34B2A814B 78<B4;5 0B 0 64=4A0; ?A02C8C8>=4A 8= ;0F ;824=B43 C>
?A02C8248= 	05C4A6A03D0C8=65A><;0FB27>>;0CC74'4=C02>BC0;+=8E4AB8CH8=
"0<?0;0 +60=30 ;C7>D67 C74 D=34AB86=43 F0B 01;4 2>=58A< BD27 0 D=8E4AB8CH
4G8BCB8="0<?0;00=370B0=02C8E4;0FB27>>; 2>D;3=>C2>=58A<C70C$DB>:48B
0;824=B43;0FH4A =0CC4<?CC>2>=58A<78B;824=BDA4508;43F74=<H4<08;C>C74
$8=8BCAH>5!DBC8248=+60=30F4=CD=0=BF4A43 5>;;>FD?455>AC;8:4F8B4508;43 
*74D=34AB86=4358=3BC70C$DB>:4F0B=>C?4A5>A<8=6C74A>;4>50;0FH4A8=C78B
;8C860C8>=  =<H38B2DBB8>=BF8C70A0507$DB>:474?A4B4=CB78<B4;50B02C8=6>=
1470;5>5>;;H=40A45>AC7414=458C>5A4CDA=8=6+60=30=2>=CA02C>AB 47>;3B
78<B4;5>DCC>14C74&>5>;;H=40A48="0<?0;0 4A4?A4B4=CBC70C>;;H=4
0A48B0=>=6>E4A=<4=C0;>A60=8I0C8>=C70C8B5D=3431HC74+60=30=6>E4A=<4=C
C>5028;8C0C40=30BB8BC+60=30=28C8I4=B?A4?0A8=65>A0=3A4CDA=8=65A><34?;>H<4=C
8= 48C74A A0@ >A5670=8BC0= ?4A5>A<8=6 28E8;80= F>A: ?A8<0A8;H B42DA8CH 5>A C74
+ )  <8;8C0AH 0C 10B4B 0=3 4<10BB84B B BD27 C74 D=34AB86=43 0BB4ACB 8C 8B =>C
A4;4E0=C85748B0;824=B43;0FH4AB8=2478B8=C46A8CH0=37>=4BCH<DBC1434C4A<8=43
8=34?4=34=C;H>578BBC0CDB0B0;824=B43;0FH4A 4F0B02C8=68=78BA>;40BC74&
>5>;;H=40A4 (4;4E0=CC>C78B8=E4BC860C8>=8B78BF>A:F8C7A4CDA=8=6+60=30=B
<0=H >5 F7>< 0BB4AC43 8= B><4 F0H C74H F4A4 8=9DA43 BD554A8=6 740A8=6 ;>BB
0=3 >AC8==8CDB  CF0B0;;46431HC74+60=30=?;08=C855BC70CC74HF4A48BBD43C74
$E 	 5CAD4C74H24AC08=;H2>D;3144;8681;45>A2><?4=B0C8>=0B=>C78=68=
C78B;8C860C8>=>AB4CC;4<4=C?A>6A0<70B;8<8C434;86818;8CHC>+ ) 28C8I4=B 'A8>AC>
 8C B44<B C70C $DB>:4NB F>A: 0C >;;H=4 0A4 F0B 5>A A4CDA=8=6 2>=CA02C>AB
8=9DA438=B><4F0H8=C748AF>A:5>AC74+ ) 6>E4A=<4=C8= A0@0=35670=8BC0=
F7> 703 454=B4 0B42C  2;08<B *70C 02C ?A>E834B 0= 4GC4=B8>= C> C74
5434A0;F>A:4ABN2><?4=B0C8>=?A>6A0<  =C70C?A>6A0<$DB>:4340;CF8C7<0=H
Case 3:19-md-02885-MCR-HTC Document 4190 Filed 12/05/25 Page 21 of 37
 	
38554A4=C8=9DA84B  C8B8AA4;4E0=CC>C78B8=E4BC860C8>=F74C74AC74740A8=68=9DA84B
2>D;3>AB7>D;370E4144=?DABD43C7A>D67C740BF4;; >F4E4A8= 	0C0
2>=54A4=24 5>A  ?A02C8C8>=4AB $DB>:4 703 0 2>=E4AB0C8>= F8C7 0 ;0FH4A F7>
<4=C8>=43C74$;8C860C8>=0=3B08374F>D;33>B><42742:8=6F74=74A4CDA=43
C> C74 )C0C4B 5>A C74 ;0FH4AB 3>8=6 C70C F>A:  C 8B C7A>D67 C70C =4CF>A:8=6 C70C
$DB>:45>D=3-8;;80<A>BB0=3 A05072>=C02C438= 	  C8B:=>F=
5A>< *0H;>A 0AC;4CC 0=3 -8;;80< A>BB C70C C74H C7>D67C C74 58ABC 2>=C02C F8C7
$DB>:4F0B5>A78<B4;50=3C70C74F0B0?>C4=C80;2;84=CB>C74HB4=C78<0=8=C0:4
?02:064 &=248CF0B4BC01;8B743C70C$A $DB>:4D=34AC740DB?824B>5>;;H=4
0A4F0B8=C741DB8=4BB>5A454AA8=62;84=CBC>;0FH4ABC70C2>D;374;?C74<74
1460=A454AA8=62;84=CBC>C7A>D67-8;;80<A>BB  =<H<44C8=6F8C7$DB>:4
74A4E40;43C70C747030B<0=H0B  	?>C4=C80;2;84=CB742>D;370E4A454AA43
1DCC70C$A A>BBA4@D8A4324AC08=<43820;A42>A3B14B4=CC>C7458A<0=3<>BC>5
C74?>C4=C80;+60=30=2;84=CB383=>C70E44<08;>A4E4=:=>F7>FC>DB48C>A0
F0H C> 64C C74 A42>A3B B> 2>=B834A01;H 54F4A +60=30=B 1420<4 2;84=CB  -74= 
0B:43*0H;>A0AC;4CC0=3-8;;80<A>BB01>DCC74;0A64A=D<14A>5?>C4=C80;2;84=CB
=48C74A2>D;3A420;;4E4A740A8=6BD270=D<14A 
22>A38=6C>$DB>:440A;H>=F74=703C74+60=30=2;84=CB58;;>DC0
@D4BC8>==08A4B44:8=68=5>A<0C8>=01>DC40A?;D6DB40=3?;024>5DB41DCF4A4=>C
0B:43C>B4=3A42>A3B )><42;84=CB>1C08=43C748AA42>A3B0=3DB43C7>B4C>58;;>DC
C745>A<B05C4AF7827B><4BD275>A<BF>D;370E4144=BC>A438=C742;84=CNB58;4
F8C7>;;H=40A4 0B43>=$DB>:4NB34B2A8?C8>=B><4>5C740D38>6A0<BF>D;3
70E4 144= A454A4=24 0D38>6A0<B ?4A5>A<43 ?A44<?;>H<4=C 0=3 B><4 8=9DAH
0D38>6A0<B?4A5>A<4305C4AA4CDA=5A><34?;>H<4=C 4A420;;BC4;;8=6C74
+60=30=2;84=CBC74H383=>C=443C>B4=3C740D38>6A0<B0;C7>D67B><42;84=CB383
0=HF0H $DB>:42><?;08=B01>DCNB70=3;8=6>5C742;08<B1420DB4022>A38=6
C>78<<0=H+60=30=2;84=CB<8BB43>DC>=C748A2;08<1420DB4>5=>C70E8=60=
0D38>6A0< F8C7 C74 2;08<  #0C4A 20<4 0 34<0=3 5>A A42>A3B C> 14 2>;;42C43 8= 0
F44:NBC8<4F74=C74A40;8CH8=+60=30F0BC70CB><42;84=CBF4A450A0F0H5A><
28C84B 0=3 2><<D=820C8>= F0B ;8<8C43 F8C7 B><4 70E8=6 => 8=C4A=4C   2;84=C
0CC4<?C8=6 C> ?A>E834 3>2D<4=C0C8>= <867C 70E4 C> 3A8E4 5>A 30HB C> 34;8E4A 8C 
$DB>:40BB4ACBC70CC74F44:C74HF4A468E4=F0B8<?>BB81;4C><44C0=38=502C8=
78B>?8=8>=C74A4@D4BC5>A8=5>A<0C8>=2>D;3C0:4B8G<>=C7BC>022><?;8B7 
Case 3:19-md-02885-MCR-HTC Document 4190 Filed 12/05/25 Page 22 of 37
 	
0A;H424<14A>5 	F0BF74=$DB>:458ABC;40A=43C70CF0=C43
<43820;A42>A3B0=3B?4285820;;H0D38>6A0<B6>8=6102:58E4H40AB 4F0BC>;31H
$A A>BBC70CC74H>=;H703KCF>F44:B L4703B><4>5C74A42>A3B78<B4;58=
>;;H=40A45>AC7>B42;84=CBF8C7>DC4<08;033A4BB4B0=3C70C74F0B<0=068=6
1DC <0=H 2;84=CB 703 C> 6> 102: C> C74 <43820; ?A>E834AB C> CAH C> >1C08= C7>B4
A42>A3B  $DB>:4 0=3 C74 2;84=CB 1460= B4=38=6 0D38>6A0<B 0B 50BC 0B C74H 2>D;3
C74HF>A:4330H0=3=867CF8C7>DCB;44?8=6CAH8=6C>B4=30B<0=HA42>A3B0BC74H
2>D;3D=C8;A>BBB083BC>?=><>A4A42>A3B2>D;314B4=C $DB>:474;?43B><4>5
C742;84=CBF7>383=>C70E40=4<08;B4AE824B4=30D38>6A0<BB><4>5C742;84=CB
F7>7034<08;8=620?018;8CHF>D;33>8CC74<B4;E4B B05>A4<4=C8>=435>A<0=H
2;84=CB C74 A42>A3B => ;>=64A 4G8BC43 1DC B8=24 C74 <43820; ?A>E834AB K:=4FL C74
2;84=CKA4<4<14A43LC742;84=CKA4<4<14A43LC4BC8=6C742;84=CC74HA42A40C43C74
0D38>6A0<  )><4 270=643 8=5>A<0C8>= >= 0 A42>A3 C70C 383 4G8BC 022>A38=6 C>
$DB>:4 
$A $DB>:42><?;08=BC70C<0=H+60=30=BA4248E43=>C824C70CC74H703=>
?>8=CB0=3B>383=>C@D0;85H5>A2><?4=B0C8>= )8=24A>BBB0838CF0B3D4C>=>C
70E8=60D38>6A0<BC74+60=30=B544;C74H=4E4AA40;;HA4248E430=4G?;0=0C8>=5>A
C7434=80; 
-78;48=C4AE84F8=6$A $DB>:40B42>=3C8<4C>5>;;>FD?>=B4E4A0;8BBD4B
C74D=34AB86=430B:43855A0D3F0B0=8BBD48=+60=3064=4A0;;H 4BC0C438CF0B0
?A>1;4<C7A>D67>DCC742>D=CAH 4A4;0H43C70C+60=308B0E4AH?>>A=0C8>=0=3
<0=H?4>?;4;02:C74A4B>DA24B=44343C>;8E4034@D0C4;H  =C7440A;H30HBF74=
A0507$DB>:41460=F>A:8=6F8C774F0A=43-8;;80<A>BBC70C74B7>D;3
=>C0224?C<43820;A42>A3B38A42C;H5A><2;84=CB 4C>;3A>BB=>CC>CADBC0=HC78=6
748BB4=C 460E4C74B0<403E824C>C742>A?>A0C8>=BC70CF4A478A8=6+60=30=BC>
F>A:8=F0AI>=4B  =C7>B428A2D<BC0=24BF74C74A?A44<?;>H<4=C<43820;4G0<B
F>A:8=9DAHCA40C<4=CA42>A3B>A?>BC4<?;>H<4=C<43820;4E0;D0C8>=B7403E8B43
C74 2>A?>A0C8>=B C> 70E4 B><4>=4 ?82: D? A42>A3B 38A42C;H 5A>< C74 <43820;
?A>E834AB *74A40B>=5>AC7403E824C>-8;;80<A>BB0=3C742>=CA02C>ABF0BC70C8C
F0BCH?820;5>A+60=30=BC>0;C4ABD27A42>A3BC>BD8CC748A=443B 40;B>0BB4ACB
C70C85$A A>BBBDB?42C43C70C0A42>A3F0BK5D3643L8=B><4F0HA>BBB7>D;3
B4=3C74A42>A3C>$DB>:41420DB47470B0;8BC>54E4AH%*8=+60=300=374
2>D;32742:C74022DA02H>5C74A42>A3 
Case 3:19-md-02885-MCR-HTC Document 4190 Filed 12/05/25 Page 23 of 37
 	
-74= 0B:43 01>DC 0AC82;4B BD664BC8=6 0;;460C8>=B >5 5A0D3 0608=BC 78< 0=3
F74C74A7470B4E4A144=270A643>A2>=E82C43>55A0D37434=8431>C7 4F4=C>=
C>4G?;08=C7>D67=>C2A4381;HC70C<4A820=BCA0E4;C>+60=30C>A4?A4B4=C8=9DA43
?4AB>=B 1DC 3>=NC 3> 0;; C74 C78=6B >=4 8B A4@D8A43 C> A4?A4B4=C C7>B4 2;84=CB  =
340;8=6F8C76>E4A=<4=C0;064=284BC74HB0H0=33>C78=6BC><0:4C748A+60=30
2>=C02C;>>:103B>C70CC746>E4A=<4=C064=2HF8;;=>CCADBCC70C2>=C02C *747>?4
>5C74<4A820=B8BC70C>=24C70CCADBC8B;>BCC74<4A820=BF8;;CAHC>64CC74<C>
BD1BC8CDC45>AC74>A868=0;2>=C02CB><4>=4KF7>F8;;<0:4<8BC0:4BL022>A38=6C>
$DB>:4 
*74 >0BC0; '028582 =E4BC860C8>=B A4?>AC 2><<8BB8>=43 1H #403 >D=B4;
F78275>2DB4B?A8<0A8;H>=$DB>:4?A>E834B0;8C0=H>50;;460C8>=B0608=BC$DB>:4 
*74 >=;H <43820; ?A>E834A F7827 34<>=BCA0C43 ;468C8<02H F0B "0<?0;0 0<8;H
;8=82  C 3>4B =>C >5 2>DAB4 033A4BB C74 8BBD4 >5 0= 0D38>6A0< >A >C74A A42>A3
BC0AC8=6>DC;468C8<0C41DC05C4A148=6?A>E8343C>C748=38E83D0;0;C4A0C8>=B148=6
<0341HC70C8=38E83D0;C>4=70=24C7474;?5D;=4BB>5C743>2D<4=C 0B0;;D343C>1H
$DB>:4  C8BBC0C43C70CC748=5>A<0C8>=34E4;>?431HC748=E4BC860C>AB20<45A><
>?4=B>DA24<0C4A80;>=C748=C4A=4C &1E8>DB;HC74B0<48=5>A<0C8>=F>D;370E4
2><4 C> ;867C <D27 B>>=4A 703  2>=3D2C43 BD27 0 B40A27  	= 0338C8>=
A>F=A44A 5>D=3 0 20B4 5A>< C74 + )  4?0AC<4=C >5 #01>A 4=458CB (4E84F
>0A3BCH;43"0BD;4E *A8?;40=>?H0=3>=C8=4=C0;0BD0;CH><?0=H (%> 
 	 3428B8>=8BBD43D6DBC 	 	*744=458CB>0A3D;C8<0C4;H383=>C
0;C4A C74 0F0A3 >5 2><?4=B0C>AH 30<064B C> "0BD;4 F7> F0B ?A> B4  >F4E4A
A4;4E0=CC>C78BA4?>ACC74>0A3A4<0=343C7420B45>A5DAC74A8=E4BC860C8>=1HC74
8BCA82C 8A42C>A A460A38=6 0 2><<D=820C8>= C70C BC0C43 0= >A60=8I0C8>= C70C
A4?A4B4=C43"0BD;45>A038B2A4C4?0AC>5C7420B4F0B?083C7A>D67>;;H=40A40=3
"0BD;4F0B2><?;08=8=601>DCC74<>=4H?083C>>;;H=40A4  F0B0;B>01;4C>
;>20C4 C78B 20B4 B8<?;H 1H DB8=6 >;;H=4 0A4 0B B40A27 C4A<B  *74 ?>8=C 8B =>C
F74C74A>;;H=40A4383B><4C78=68;;468C8<0C48=C70C20B4F43>=NC:=>FC74
A40;8CH>5C70C5A><C74?D1;8B743>A34A1DCC70C8CB7>D;3A08B4B><4BDB?828>=01>DC
>;;H=40A40B?0AC>503D438;864=24>5$DB>:4 

*74A>F=A44AD38C(4?>AC8B30C43$0H 	 8;;A>BB8=@D8A43>5
C74D=34AB86=435>A0??A>E0;C>A4B?>=3C>C740D38CA4?>AC0=3F8C7@D82:06A44<4=C
Case 3:19-md-02885-MCR-HTC Document 4190 Filed 12/05/25 Page 24 of 37

 	
5A><<4?A4?0A430A4B?>=B4F78278B30C43D6DBC  	 *74A405C4A 
0B:43A>F=A44AC>?A4?0A40A4B?>=B4C>C743>2D<4=C0=3C70CA4B?>=B4
F0B30C43D6DBC  	 BC74>DAC8B5D;;H50<8;80AF8C70=38=?>BB4BB8>=>5
4027>5C74B43>2D<4=CBC78B((F8;;=>CA470B70=33D?;820C4C7>B4455>ACB0=3
8=BC403F8;;7867;867C24AC08=58=38=6B0=30CC4<?CC>?D;;C>64C74A24AC08=502CBC>
5028;8C0C4C78BA4?>ACNB455>ACBC>?A>E83402><?;4C4?82CDA4 
*74D38C(4?>AC<0:4B8C2;40AC70C3D4C>0BD1BC0=C80;=D<14A>58=3820C>AB
D=2>E4A43 F78;4 ?A>24BB8=6 C74 2;08<B >5 NB +60=30= 2;84=C4;4 A>F=A44A
14;84E4BC70CK=40A;H0;;C74''BD1<8BB8>=B5A><+60=30=2;08<0=CB0A4501A820C43
0=3=>C2A4381;4 L*748=3820C>AB>55A0D38=C7>B4BD1<8BB8>=B8=2;D34C4A<8=>;>6H
C70C 8B 8<?>BB81;4 A4?>ACB C70C 70E4 144= 0;C4A43 BDB?828>DB ?A>E834A B>DA24B 0
BD1BC0=C80;=D<14A>5834=C820;A4?>ACB70=3FA8C8=68AA46D;0A8C84B0=38=>=420B4
02;08<5>A02;84=CF7>F0B0;A403H?083C7A>D6702;08<<0341H0=>C74A;0F58A< 
*74D38C (4?>AC 8B 0= 4G24;;4=C 022>D=C >5 C74 ?A>24BB ?A>243DA4B 0=3
C8<4;8=4BFA8CC4=F8C77>=4BCH0=38=C46A8CH8=<H>?8=8>= *742>=2;DB8>=BA4;0H43
8=C74A4?>AC0A4C74A4BD;C>54G24;;4=CA0C8>=0;40=3A40B>= *74502CB60C74A433DA8=6
C78B8=E4BC860C8>=8=<H>?8=8>=2>=58A<0=31>;BC4AC74A>F=A44A2>=2;DB8>=B 
&=4>5C74A>F=A44A2>=2;DB8>=B340;CF8C7058=38=61HC74<C70CC74A4F4A4
<0=H4G0<?;4B>53D?;820C40D38>6A0<BF7827C74HD;C8<0C4;H2>=2;D343F4A4<>A4
C70= 2>8=2834=24 0=3 A4?A4B4=C43 5A0D3  *74 D=34AB86=43 2>=BD;C43 F8C7 A 
)?0=:>E8270=30B:4378<C>4E0;D0C4C7>B40D38>6A0<B 8B2>=2;DB8>=F0BC70C
0;;BD270D38>6A0<BF4A45A0D3D;4=C 
*74(4B?>=B4C>C74A>F=A44AD38C(4?>AC5>2DB4B740E8;H>=0=
0E>830=24>50=H0??40A0=24C70C8=C4=C8>=0;;H2><<8CC435A0D3 0BC74H
?>8=C43>DC8=C74A4B?>=B470=3;43C74+60=30=2;08<B9DBC0BC74H383C74+ ) 
2;08<B4G24?CC74HA4@D8A4324AC08=3>2D<4=C0C8>=40A;84A3D4C>;>68BC82385582D;C84B
=>C<4=C8>=8=60<>A4?A4BB8=6=443C>E4CF70CF0BA4248E435>A8=C46A8CH *74H0A4
A867C8=C78B4@D0;CA40C<4=C *74?A>1;4<8BC74H383=NC70E40?A>24BB>A?A>243DA4
C>E4C0=H2;08<5>A5A0D3 A4;84B>=0C74>AHC70CC74BC0C8BC820;30C014CF44=
+ )  2;08<B 0=3 +60=30= 2;08<B F4A4 =40A;H C74 B0<4  *74H 0A4 FA>=6 0=3 C74
A>F=A44A=0;HB8B34<>=BCA0C438C 
F>D;370E4;8:43C78B)?4280;$0BC4AC>2>=2;D34C70C1420DB4B><4>5
C748A+60=30=2;84=CBD?;>03430D38>6A0<BC74<B4;E4BF7827F>D;370E4?A4E4=C43
Case 3:19-md-02885-MCR-HTC Document 4190 Filed 12/05/25 Page 25 of 37
 	 
C74< 5A>< :=>F8=6 F70C C74 2>=C4=CB >5 C7>B4 0D38>6A0<B F4A4  DA8=6 C78B
8=E4BC860C8>= 0224BB437D=3A43B>52;84=CBN58;4BC>;>>:0C0D38>6A0<B0=3
>C74A3>2D<4=C0C8>= B$A 0AC;4CC2><<4=C43C><40C?064>578BCA0=B2A8?C
C70CC>:=>FF70CB><4>=4D?;>0343C74HF>D;370E4C>6>C7A>D674E4AH58;48=
A>F=A44A  5C74H383=NC20A4C>C0:4C74C8<4C>58=3>DCF70CC748A+ ) 2;84=CB
D?;>0343 C74 +60=30= =D<14AB F4A4 <D27 ;4BB  *> C70C ?>8=C 0224BB8=6 C74
+60=30=B 58;4B 0B  383 B8<?;H A4@D8A4B B40A278=6 C74 2;84=CNB   0=3 C74=
0224BB8=6C7458;4 *743>2D<4=CB8=402758;40A4;8BC438=2><<>=;0=6D064 
*74(4B?>=B48BE4AH;867C>=?A>24BB0=3?A>243DA48=5>AC74
60C74A8=6>58=5>A<0C8>=C><0:42;08<B5>AC74+60=30=B  C8B2;40AC70CC74A40;
8BBD48=*0H;>A0AC4CCNB70=3;8=6>5C74+60=30=2;08<BF0BC70C74A40;;H14;84E43
74 F0B 148=6 2;4E4A 1H 38B2>E4A8=6 78B A468BCA0C8>= ?0H<4=C K;>>?7>;4L F7827
2>=E4=84=C;HA4@D8A43=>F>A:8=C74<0==4A>5BD??;H8=6?A>>5>5740A8=6;>BB8=0
34542C8E440A?;D620B4 
A>F=A44ANB=0;HB8B>5C74(4B?>=B4F0B034E0BC0C8=6?DB7102:C>
C70C A4B?>=B4  A>F=A44A ?4A5>A<43 0 ?>8=C 1H ?>8=C C0:4 3>F= >5 C74 
0BB4AC8>=B  !DBC 0B C74 2>=2;DB8>= 74A4C>5>A4 ?A>E8343 A460A38=6 C74 >A868=0;
A>F=A44AD38C(4?>ACC74A>F=A44A0=0;HB8B8B2>=58A<430=31>;BC4A431H
C748=E4BC860C8>=0=3502C60C74A8=61HC74D=34AB86=43 
B 74A4C>5>A4 <4=C8>=43 A>F=A44A 0;B> A4B?>=343 C> B4E4A0; 8=@D8A84B
5A>< C74 D=34AB86=43  )><4 >5 C74 8=@D8A84B 8=E>;E43 4G?0=38=6 >= B><4 >5 C74
58=38=6B 8= C74 D38C (4?>AC  G0<?;4B >5 C7>B4 8=@D8A84B 8=2;D34 0338C8>=0;
2;08<0=CBF8C7A4?>AC8=6C70CF0B8=C74FA>=6C8<45A0<48<?>BB81;4;0=6D0640B
F4;; 0B 0;C4A43 A4?>ACB 0=3   2;08<0=CB F8C7  A42>A3B F8C7 B86=85820=C
70=3FA8C8=68AA46D;0A8C84B 

<D;C838BCA82C;8C860C8>=$#F8C78=C749DA8B382C8>=>5C74!D38280;'0=4;
>=$D;C88BCA82C#8C860C8>=0BC78B>DAC:=>FB0=3C7434B2A8?C8>=<0:4B2;40A8B
02>=B>;830C8>=>520B4B5A><>C74A5434A0;38BCA82C2>DACB>5C4=6A40C8==D<14AC70C
1A8=6C>C78B>DAC0CC>A=4HB;824=B43C>?A02C8248=0=4@D0;;H6A40C=D<14A>5BC0C4B
%  ;0 #>2 (  	?A>E834B5>ABD27;0FH4ABC>A4?A4B4=CC748A2;84=CB8=C78B
Case 3:19-md-02885-MCR-HTC Document 4190 Filed 12/05/25 Page 26 of 37

 	 
$#D?>=?0H8=605440=3?A>E838=6?A>>5C70CC740CC>A=4H8B0<4<14A8=6>>3
BC0=38=6>5C7410A8=C749DA8B382C8>=F74A4C740CC>A=4HA4B834B>AA46D;0A;H?A02C824B
;0F  =C70CB0<4AD;40C C74A48BC74<0=30C4C70C0=0CC>A=4H<DBC2><?;H
F8C7C74(D;4B(46D;0C8=6*74;>A8300AD=;4BB5434A0;;0F?A>E834B>C74AF8B4 

(D;4 	A4@D8A4BC70C0;0FH4A?A>E8342><?4C4=CA4?A4B4=C0C8>=C>02;84=C
0=3C70CA4@D8A4B;460;:=>F;4364B:8;;C7>A>D67=4BB0=3?A4?0A0C8>=A40B>=01;H
=424BB0AH5>ABD27A4?A4B4=C0C8>=
(D;4  	 A4@D8A4B 0 ;0FH4A C> F8C73A0F 5A>< A4?A4B4=C0C8>=   85 C74
A4?A4B4=C0C8>=F8;;A4BD;C8=E8>;0C8>=>5C74(D;4B>5'A>54BB8>=0;>=3D2C>A;0F
C742;84=C?4AB8BCB8=02>DAB4>502C8>=8=E>;E8=6C74;0FH4ANBB4AE824BC70CC74
;0FH4A A40B>=01;H 14;84E4B 8B 2A8<8=0; >A 5A0D3D;4=C D=;4BB C74 2;84=C 06A44B C>
38B2;>B40=3A42C85HC742A8<4>A5A0D3>AC742;84=C70BDB43C74;0FH4ANBB4AE824B
C>?4A?4CD0C402A8<4>A5A0D3D=;4BBC742;84=C06A44BC>38B2;>B40=3A42C85HC74
2A8<4>A5A0D3
(D;4 2>E4ABC74BD1942C>520=3>AC>C74>DAC  =BD1?0A06A0?708C
?A>7818CB0;0FH4A5A>< <0:8=6050;B4BC0C4<4=C>5;0F>A502CC>C74>DAC>A
508;8=6C>2>AA42C0?A4E8>DB50;B4BC0C4<4=C>5;0F>A502C1HC74;0FH4A 508;8=6
C>38B2;>B40<0C4A80;502CC>0>DACF74=38B2;>BDA48BA4@D8A43C>0E>830BB8BC8=60
5A0D3D;4=C02C1H02;84=C>554A8=64E834=24C74;0FH4A:=>FBC>1450;B4>A85
C74;0FH4A2><4BC>:=>FC70C?A4E8>DB;H>554A434E834=24F0B50;B4C74;0FH4A
B70;;C0:4A40B>=01;4A4<4380;<40BDA4B8=2;D38=685=424BB0AH38B2;>B8=68CC>C74
>DAC
(D;4  	0 A4@D8A4B <0=064A80; ;0FH4AB 64=4A0;;H C> <0:4 A40B>=01;4
455>ACBC>4=BDA4C7458A<70B8=45542C<40BDA4B68E8=6A40B>=01;40BBDA0=24C70C0;;
;0FH4AB 8= C74 58A< 2>=5>A< C> C74 (D;4B >5 'A>54BB8>=0; >=3D2C 0=3 1
B?4285820;;H ?;024B C70C A4@D8A4<4=C >= 0 ;0FH4A F8C7 BD?4AE8B>AH 0DC7>A8CH >E4A
0=>C74A;0FH4A )D1?0A06A0?72 344<B0E8>;0C8>=>5C742>=3D2CAD;4B85C74
BD?4AE8B>AH ;0FH4A 142><4B 0F0A4 >5 <8B2>=3D2C 1H 0 BD1>A38=0C4 ;0FH4A 0=3
A0C8584B8C>A508;BC>C0:4A4<4380;02C8>=
(D;4 0A4@D8A4B=>=;0FH4A0BB8BC0=CBBD270B?0A0;460;;460;0BB8BC0=C
>A >C74A B8<8;0A;H C8C;43 4<?;>H44B F>A: D=34A C74 38A42C8>= >A BD?4AE8B8>= >5 0
Case 3:19-md-02885-MCR-HTC Document 4190 Filed 12/05/25 Page 27 of 37

 	 
;0FH4A >A ;0F 58A<  )D1?0A06A0?7 2 <0:4B 2;40A C70C BD27 =>=;0FH4A BC055 <0H
F>A:F8C7>DCC74?A4B4=24>A02C8E48=E>;E4<4=C>5C74;0FH4A1DCC74;0FH4A<DBC
A4E84F0=314A4B?>=B81;45>AC74F>A:?A>3D2C>5C74?0A0;460;B>A;460;0BB8BC0=CB 

74;010<0(D;4B>5'A>54BB8>=0;>=3D2C0B8B2DBC><0AHF8C7C7403E4=C
>5C74$>34;(D;4B8B@D8C4B8<8;0AC>C70C>574;>A8300A
(D;4 	A4@D8A4BC70C0;0FH4A?A>E8342><?4C4=CA4?A4B4=C0C8>=C>02;84=C
0=3C70CA4@D8A4B;460;:=>F;4364B:8;;C7>A>D67=4BB0=3?A4?0A0C8>=A40B>=01;H
=424BB0AH5>ABD27A4?A4B4=C0C8>=
(D;4 	 A4@D8A4B 0 ;0FH4A C> F8C73A0F 5A>< A4?A4B4=C0C8>=   85 C74
A4?A4B4=C0C8>=F8;;A4BD;C8=E8>;0C8>=>5C74(D;4B>5'A>54BB8>=0;>=3D2C>A;0F
C742;84=C?4AB8BCB8=02>DAB4>502C8>=8=E>;E8=6C74;0FH4ANBB4AE824BC70CC74
;0FH4A A40B>=01;H 14;84E4B 8B 2A8<8=0; >A 5A0D3D;4=C D=;4BB C74 2;84=C 06A44B C>
38B2;>B40=3A42C85HC742A8<4>A5A0D3>AC742;84=C70BDB43C74;0FH4ANBB4AE824B
C>?4A?4CD0C402A8<4>A5A0D3D=;4BBC742;84=C06A44BC>38B2;>B40=3A42C85HC74
2A8<4>A5A0D3
(D;4   2>E4AB C74 BD1942C >5 20=3>A C> C74 >DAC  = BD1?0A06A0?7 0 8C
?A>7818CB0;0FH4A5A>< <0:8=6050;B4BC0C4<4=C>5;0F>A502CC>C74>DAC>A
508;8=6C>2>AA42C0?A4E8>DB50;B4BC0C4<4=C>5;0F>A502C1HC74;0FH4A 508;8=6
C>38B2;>B40<0C4A80;502CC>0>DACF74=38B2;>BDA48BA4@D8A43C>0E>830BB8BC8=60
5A0D3D;4=C02C1H02;84=C>554A8=64E834=24C74;0FH4A:=>FBC>1450;B4>A85
C74;0FH4A2><4BC>:=>FC70C?A4E8>DB;H>554A434E834=24F0B50;B4C74;0FH4A
B70;;C0:4A40B>=01;4A4<4380;<40BDA4B
(D;4  	0 A4@D8A4B 0 ?0AC=4A 8= 0 ;0F 58A< C> <0:4 A40B>=01;4 455>ACB C>
4=BDA4C7458A<70B8=45542C<40BDA4B68E8=6A40B>=01;40BBDA0=24C70C0;;;0FH4AB
8=C7458A<2>=5>A<C>C74(D;4B>5'A>54BB8>=0;>=3D2CF78;41A4@D8A4B0;0FH4A
70E8=638A42CBD?4AE8B8>=>E4A0=>C74A;0FH4AC><0:4A40B>=01;4455>ACBC>4=BDA4
C74 >C74A BD1>A38=0C4 ;0FH4A 2>=5>A<B C> C74 (D;4B >5 'A>54BB8>=0; >=3D2C
)D1?0A06A0?72344<B0E8>;0C8>=>5C742>=3D2CAD;4B85C74BD?4AE8B>AH;0FH4A
142><4B0F0A4>5<8B2>=3D2C1H0BD1>A38=0C4;0FH4A0=3A0C8584B8C>A508;BC>C0:4
A4<4380;02C8>=
Case 3:19-md-02885-MCR-HTC Document 4190 Filed 12/05/25 Page 28 of 37

 	 
(D;4   2>E4A8=6 =>=;0FH4A 0BB8BC0=CB <0:4B 2;40A 8= BD1?0A06A0?7 2 0
;0FH4A8BA4B?>=B81;45>AC742>=3D2C>5C74=>=;0FH4AC70CF>D;3140E8>;0C8>=>5
C74(D;4B>5'A>54BB8>=0;>=3D2C854=606438=1HC74A4B?>=B81;4;0FH4A85C70C
;0FH4A>A34AB>AA0C8584BC742>=3D2C8=E>;E43>A0B0?0AC=4A8=C7458A<8=F7827
C74=>=;0FH4A8B4<?;>H43>A70B38A42CBD?4AE8B>AH0DC7>A8CH>E4ABD27=>=;0FH4A
0=3:=>FB>5C742>=3D2C0CC8<4F74=8CB2>=B4@D4=24B20=140E>8343>A<8C860C43
1DC508;BC>C0:4A40B>=01;4A4<4380;02C8>= 

*74  $>34; (D;4 	3 A4BCA82CB 0 ;0FH4ANB 2>=3D2C F74= 0 ;0FH4A
:=>FB02;84=CNB02C8>=8B2A8<8=0;>A5A0D3D;4=C *748BBD430>A<0;&?8=8>=
>= ?A8; 	 	 A460A38=6 C78B ?A>E8B8>= 8= $>34; (D;4 	3 F74A48= C74
)C0=38=6 ><<8CC44 >= C782B 0=3 'A>54BB8>=0; (4B?>=B818;8CH BC0C43 8= ?0AC
K$>34;(D;4 	3?A>7818CB0;0FH4A5A><03E8B8=6>A0BB8BC8=602;84=C8=2>=3D2C
C74;0FH4AM:=>FBN8B2A8<8=0;>A5A0D3D;4=C *70C:=>F;4364<0H148=54AA435A><
C7428A2D<BC0=24B8=2;D38=60;0FH4ANBF8;;5D;1;8=3=4BBC>>A2>=B28>DB0E>830=24
>5502CB 22>A38=6;HF74A4502CB:=>F=C>C74;0FH4A4BC01;8B707867?A>1018;8CH
C70C02;84=CB44:BC>DB4C74;0FH4ANBB4AE824B5>A2A8<8=0;>A5A0D3D;4=C02C8E8CHC74
;0FH4A70B03DCHC>8=@D8A45DAC74AC>0E>8303E8B8=6>A0BB8BC8=6BD2702C8E8CH E4=
858=5>A<0C8>=;40A=433DA8=60?A4;8<8=0AH8=C4AE84F>A3DA8=60A4?A4B4=C0C8>=8B
8=BD558284=CC>4BC01;8B7K:=>F;4364LD=34A(D;4 	3>C74AAD;4B<0HA4@D8A4C74
;0FH4AC>8=@D8A45DAC74A8=>A34AC>74;?C742;84=C0E>832A8<4>A5A0D3C>0E>83
?A>54BB8>=0; <8B2>=3D2C 0=3 C> 03E0=24 C74 2;84=CNB ;468C8<0C4 8=C4A4BCB  *74B4
8=2;D34 C74 3DC84B >5 2><?4C4=24 38;864=24 2><<D=820C8>= 0=3 7>=4BCH D=34A
(D;4B 	 	 	 	 	0=3  L


B 0= >E4AE84F 8C 8B 2;40A 5A>< 0;; C74 4E834=24 D=2>E4A43 8= C78B
8=E4BC860C8>= 8=2;D38=6 C74 58=38=6B >5 A>F=A44A 0=3 >0BC0; '028582
=E4BC860C8>=BC70C5A0D3F0B2><<8CC438=+60=308=C74BD1<8BB8>=>55A0D3D;4=C
<43820;A42>A3B2;40A;HC>B7>F740A8=6;>BB1HC74+60=30=2>=CA02C>A2;84=CB>5
-74C74A A0507 $DB>:4 F0B 02C8=6 >=;H 8= C74 14BC 8=C4A4BCB >5 C74
14=458280A84B>50+60=30=6>E4A=<4=C?>;82HC>0BB8BCA4CDA=8=628C8I4=2>=CA02C>AB
5A>< F0A I>=4 34?;>H<4=CB 1H 5D=38=6 0= %& 740343 1H $A  $DB>:4 >A F0B
345A0D38=6C7>B4E4AH14=458280A84B5>A78B?4AB>=0;608=F8;;=>C14058=38=6>5C78B
Case 3:19-md-02885-MCR-HTC Document 4190 Filed 12/05/25 Page 29 of 37

 	
A4?>AC -8C7>DC0=4GC4=B8E438B2>E4AH?A>24BB;8:4;H8=+60=308C8B8<?>BB81;4C>
:=>FF7>0=37>F<0=H?4A?4CA0C43C78B5A0D3 '4A70?B4E4=C70CF>D;3=>CA4E40;
C7402CD0;5A0D3BC4AB >=B4@D4=C;HF74C74AC742;84=CB>58=38E83D0;;H>A0B0
6A>D?F4A46D8;CH>55A0D3F8;;=>C14058=38=6>5C78BA4?>AC *74A>;4>5C78B)?4280;
$0BC4A 8B C> 8=E4BC860C4 85 C74A4 F0B 5A0D3 0=3 F70C A>;4 85 0=H  ?;0H43 8=
?4A?4CA0C8=6BD275A0D3>AF4A4F8;;5D;;H>AA42:;4BB;H8=38554A4=CC>C70C5A0D30=3
C> <0:4 A42><<4=30C8>=B C> C74 >DAC A460A38=6 F70C 85 0=H A4<43H B7>D;3 14
>A34A431H74A 
BC74$B4CC;4<4=C?A>6A0<6>CD=34AF0H7030<?;4C8<4C>
;40A= 0=3 D=34ABC0=3 C74 B4CC;4<4=C 06A44<4=CB C74 B4CC;4<4=C <4C7>3>;>6H
?0AC828?0C48=C>F=70;;<44C8=6F74A4C74B4CC;4<4=C<4C7>3>;>6HF0B4G?;08=43
0=32>;;42C<43820;A42>A3B?0AC82D;0A;H0D38>6A0<B *74508;DA4C>3>B>C7>A>D67;H
20DB43C74<8=?0ACC>508;C>D=34ABC0=3C74=4435>AC74BD1<8BB8>=>5?A>>5>5
740A8=6;>BB >=B4@D4=C;HC70CB4CD?5>AC74A024'4A8>32ADB7F74=C74H
383=>C70E4C74C8<4C><0:4BDA4C748A?A>24BBF0B2><?;4C435>A0;;0D38>6A0<B
B4=C>AC70CC74+60=30=BF0=C43C>B4=3 *74A4F4A4B><0=H0AC;4CC2DC>55C74
?A>24BB145>A42><?;4C4 E4=F>AB43D48=;0A64?0ACC>C70C2ADB7>5D?;>038=6
0D38>6A0<B383=>C4G0<8=4C740D38>6A0<B5>A4AA>AB>A8=38280>55A0D3383
=>C34C4A<8=48=F7>B4?>BB4BB8>=C7>B40D38>6A0<BF4A474;3508;43C>34C4A<8=4
C74?A>24BBD=34AC0:4=1H$DB>:40=3B8<?;HD?;>03430D38>6A0<B0B50BC0BC74H
2>D;3  C 8B =>=B4=B820; C7>D67 C4;;8=6 C70C *0H;>A 0AC;4CC 0=3 -8;;80< A>BB
34;867C430C70E8=6144=C74>=;H58A<C>K38B2>E4AL0;>>?7>;4F74A41H02;08<0=C
F8C7>DC0=0D38>6A0<2>D;34;42C''0=3A4248E4 	F78;4C74A4BD;C>5=>C
BD1<8CC8=60=0D38>6A0<8=''60A=4A430  	A468BCA0C8>=?0H<4=C -8C7>DC
C74508;DA4C>D=34ABC0=3C74?A>6A0<F>D;370E47030<?;4C8<4C>60C74A
0D38>6A0<B0=3>C74A<43820;A42>A3B0BF4;;0BB4CC8=6D?0=0=C85A0D3E4CC8=6
?A>24BB *01;4 8=C74A>F=A44A=0;HB8B>5C744=8=64A0AA8B>=0E8B 	 	
D38C (4?>AC (4B?>=B4 8B =>C 9DBC C4;;8=6 >= C78B ?>8=C 1DC B7>2:8=6  *70C C01;4
34<>=BCA0C4B C70C  +60=30= 2;08<0=CB D?;>0343 3>2D<4=CB 3DA8=6 C74
BD??;4<4=C0C8>= ?4A8>3 0=3 =>=4 C74A405C4A 8=2;D38=6 3DA8=6 C74 A024 '4A8>3 
*0H;>A0AC;4CCD?;>0343 3>2D<4=CB3DA8=6C74'')D??;4<4=C0C8>=0=3!40=84
);4033 	3DA8=6C70CC8<4 *74A4F4A4 	 3>F=;>03B3DA8=6C74A024'4A8>3 
DAC74A<>A4 F74=  0B:43 $A  0AC;4CC 01>DC 60C74A8=6 <43820; A42>A3B >5 C74
+60=30=BCAH8=6C>;40A=7>F<D27F0B3>=4?A8>AC>C74A024'4A8>3F74=C78=6B
Case 3:19-md-02885-MCR-HTC Document 4190 Filed 12/05/25 Page 30 of 37
 	
F4A4=>CB>742C8274BD664BC43C74H2>D;3=NC70E41420DB4D=C8;C74B4CC;4<4=C703
144=0==>D=2431420DB4?A8>AC>C70CC74!D364703?A4E4=C43C74<5A><>1C08=8=6
<43820;A42>A3B 8ABCC70C?A>7818C8>=703C>3>F8C7C74,B8=240B06>E4A=<4=C0;
064=2HC74*>D7H?A>24BB703C>148=E>:431DCC70C383=>C8=2;D34C74+60=30=NB
F7>B4 A42>A3B F4A4 =>C F8C7 C74,  %> >A34A 4E4A ?A>7818C43 2>;;42C8=6 ?A8E0C4
<43820;?A>E834AA42>A3B0B50A0B 20=A4<4<14A=>AF0B>=4A4E40;43C7A>D670
B40A27  )42>=3 C74H 703 =>C78=6 BC0=38=6 8= C748A F0H >=24 C74H D=34AC>>: C74
A4?A4B4=C0C8>=>5C74+60=30=2;84=C4;4C>B44:A42>A3B38A42C;H5A><C74<43820;
?A>E834AB F7> 4G0<8=43 C74 740A8=6 >5 C74 +60=30=B 48C74A 01>DC C> 34?;>H >A
A424=C;H A4CDA=43 5A>< 34?;>H<4=C  *74A4 F0B =>C78=6 C> ?A4E4=C  5A><
2>;;42C8=6A42>A3B5A><C744<?;>H4AB>5C74+60=30=?;08=C855B *74?A>24BB
383=>C4=C08;B4=38=6F70C4E4A0DC7>A8I0C8>==44343C>70E4BD27A42>A3BA4;40B43
C> C7>B4 2;08<0=CBN 2>D=B4; 9DBC ;8:4 C74 ;0FH4A 5>A 0 + )  2;84=C B4=38=6 0=
0DC7>A8I0C8>=C>0?A8E0C4<43820;?A>E834A0=3>1C08=8=60=0D38>6A0<8574>AB74
703 144= C> BD27 0 ?A>E834A  5  703 <034 38A42C A4@D4BCB C> C74 +60=30=
<43820;?A>E834AB0BBD664BC431H$DB>:4C74HF>D;370E4144=01;4C>0BB4BB
40A;HC7402CD0;4G8BC4=24>5C74E0;838CH>50=38=C46A8CH>5C74?A>E834AB0=3C74
0D38>6A0<B?DA?>AC43;HC>70E4>A868=0C43F8C7C7>B4?A>E834AB 
-8;;80<A>BB0=3*0H;>A0AC;4CC508;43C>4BC01;8B70?A>243DA40=3CA08=8=6
C>8=BDA40608=BC5A0D3D;4=C3>2D<4=CBBD1<8CC431HC748A2;84=CB>A>;;H=40A4
0=3A0507$DB>:4C7A>D67BC055A4E84F4AB>AC74<B4;E4B *74HB8<?;H383=>C0C
0=HC8<4?4A5>A<05A0D30=0;HB8B>5C743>2D<4=CBC74H8=C4=343C>A4;H>=8=C748A
2;08<0=CBNA4@D4BC5>A2><?4=B0C8>=  C8BCAD4C70CC74HD;C8<0C4;H383=>C70E4C74
C8<4C>E4CC740D38>6A0<BD?;>03431DCC70CF0B1420DB4C74H383=>C?;0=5>AC70C
C8<4 )D270508;DA48B>=?0AC82D;0A;H*0H;>A0AC;4CC0=3-8;;80<A>BB0=3
8B =>C 4G2DB01;4 2>=3D2C 5>A C74 >DAC C> 0;;>F C> ?0BB F8C7>DC 148=6 74;3
022>D=C01;4 *74H508;43C>?4A5>A<03D438;864=24>=$A $DB>:40=3508;43C>
?4A5>A<03D438;864=240BC7458A<F0B1468==8=6C>?DABD42;08<B5>A+60=30=B
A454AA431H78<C7A>D67>;;H=40A4 *74H14;84E43$A $DB>:4C>142A4381;40=3
0KB<>>C7>?4A0C>AL1DC508;43C>744378BF0A=8=601>DC=>CCADBC8=6+60=30=BF8C7
<43820; A42>A3B 2>=B8BC4=C F8C7 C74 =0C8>=F834 ?A02C824 >5 5A0D3   B8<?;4
4G0<8=0C8>=>5C74+ ) )C0C44?0AC<4=CNBF0A=8=601>DC5A0D38=+60=30<867C
70E40;C4A43$A 0AC;4CCNBE84FC70C+60=307030KB?4280;A4;0C8>=B78?LF8C7C74
+=8C43)C0C4B0=38C3>4B=>C70E40A4?DC0C8>=5>AF834B?A4035A0D3 )8<8;0A;HC74H
Case 3:19-md-02885-MCR-HTC Document 4190 Filed 12/05/25 Page 31 of 37
 	
508;43 C> E4C C74 ;468C8<02H >5 C74 3>2C>AB 0D38>;>68BCB 0=3 2;8=82B C70C F4A4 C74
B>DA24>50D38>6A0<B 
*74 58=38=6 >5 C78B )?4280; $0CC4A 8B C70C 0;; 4G24?C 5>DA >5 C74 +60=30=
2;08<B BD1<8CC43 1H 4=8=64A 0AA8B>= 0E83 F4A4 5A0D3D;4=C  &=;H C7>B4 5>DA
2;08<B>DC>570E4B><48=38280>5A4;8018;8CH8=C70CC742;8=82B20=14E4A85843
0=3F78;4C740D38>6A0<B3>=>C70E430C0?>8=CBC70C2;40A;H14;84E01;4C74H3>=>C
70E4 >1E8>DB 8=3820C8>=B >5 <0=8?D;0C8>=  +=01;4 C> 3A0F 0 2>=2;DB8>= >5 C74
8<?02C7>F4E4A>=4>5C745>DAF0B0=0A>=0AC;0=A454AA0;>=4F>A:43F8C7
>;;H=40A40=3C74>C74ACF>70E8=6=>0??0A4=C2>==42C8>=F8C748C74A -8C7
C7>B4 54F 4G24?C8>=B 0=3 C74A4 8B =>C 01B>;DC4 24AC08=CH 01>DC C7>B4 5>DA 0
A40B>=01;4?4AB>=F>D;32>=2;D34C70CC746A>D?>5+60=30=2;08<B0B0F7>;4
F4A4=>C;468C8<0C4 *745>DA4G24?C4320B4B20AAHC742;08<834=C85820C8>==D<14AB
>5   	 0=3 	
DAC74A8C8BC7458=38=6>5C78B)?4280;$0BC4AC70CC74502CBD=2>E4A4374A48=
0A4BD558284=CC>0BB4ACC70CC74A40A4E8>;0C8>=B>5C7420=>=B>54C782B>5C74%>AC74A=
8BCA82C>5;>A830C74(D;4B(46D;0C8=6C74;>A8300A0=3C74;010<0(D;4B>5
'A>54BB8>=0;>=3D2C *78B)?4280;$0BC4A5DAC74AB0BB4ACBC70CC742>=3D2CC70C;403B
C>C78B2>=2;DB8>=8BBD558284=CC>B4AE40B0=0338C8>=0;10B8B5>AC78B>DACC>8<?>B4
B0=2C8>=B>=64=4A0;;H0=3#4F8B0AA8B>=*0H;>A0AC;4CC0=3-8;;80<A>BB
5>AC748A8=38E83D0;02CB>5<8B2>=3D2C 
CC02743 C> C78B (4?>AC 0=3 (42><<4=30C8>= 8B 0= ??4=38G 2>=C08=8=6
<0=H>5C743>2D<4=CBA454AA43C>74A48= 

C 8B C74 A42&gt;&lt;&lt;4=30C8&gt;= &gt;5 C78B )?4280; $0BC4A C70C C74 &gt;DAC 58=3 C70C



4=8=64A0AA8B>=0E8B0=3B?4285820;;H?0AC=4AB*0H;>A0AC;4CC0=3-8;;80<
A>BB B?4285820;;H 0=3 )4=8>A '0AC=4A -  #4F8B 0AA8B>= 64=4A0;;H 0;;
;0FH4AB>F8=60583D280AH>1;860C8>=C>C742;84=CB>5B08358A<C>2><?4C4=C;H
0=3C7>A>D67;HA4?A4B4=CC74<8=C74<0CC4A>5C78B;8C860C8>=508;43C>3>B>
*74 508;DA4 8= C74 58ABC 8=BC0=24 20<4 5A>< =>C 02@D8A8=6 0 C7>A>D67
D=34ABC0=38=6 >5 C74 B4CC;4<4=C 06A44<4=C 0=3 C74 <4C7>3>;>6H >5 C74
B4CC;4<4=C?A>6A0<  C8B5DAC74AA42><<4=343C70CC74>DAC58=3C70C?0AC=4AB
0AA8B>=0AC;4CC0=3A>BB508;43C>034@D0C4;HBD?4AE8B40=34=BDA4C70CC74
Case 3:19-md-02885-MCR-HTC Document 4190 Filed 12/05/25 Page 32 of 37

 	
=>=;0FH4ABC055?4AB>=B>5C744=8=64A0AA8B>=0E8B58A<F4A4?A4?0A43
C>2><?;HF8C7AD;4B>5?A>54BB8>=0;2>=3D2C
 	C8BC74A42><<4=30C8>=>5C78B)?4280;$0BC4AC70CC74>DAC58=35>AC74
?DA?>B4>5BD??>AC8=64E834=245>AC74B0=2C8>=BC>148<?>B431HC78B>DAC
C70C 4=8=64A 0AA8B>= 0E8B 0=3 B?4285820;;H )4=8>A '0AC=4A -  #4F8B
0AA8B>=0=3?0AC=4AB*0H;>A0AC;4CC0=3-8;;80<A>BBE8>;0C43C74E0A8>DB
AD;4BF8C78=C74(D;4B>5'A>54BB8>=0;>=3D2C8=;>A8300=3;010<028C43
8= C78B (4?>AC  *78B )?4280; $0BC4A ?0AC82D;0A;H =>C4B C70C 0C => C8<4 70B
4=8=64A 0AA8B>= 0E8B >A 0=H >5 C74 ?0AC=4AB F7>B4 2>=3D2C 70B 144=
B2ADC8=8I431HC78B(4?>ACC0:4=0=HA4<4380;02C8>=A460A38=6C745A0D3D;4=C
0D38>6A0<BBD1<8CC43C>C74)4CC;4<4=C'A>6A0<  =BC403C7458A<C7A>D67
8CBA4B?>=B4C>C74A>F=A44AD38C(4?>AC70BB8<?;H0BB4AC43C7458A<0=3
8CB?0AC=4AB383=>C78=6FA>=6  C8B5DAC74AA42><<4=343C70CC74>DAC58=3
C70C ?0AC=4AB A>BB 0=3 0AC;4CC 508;43 8= 4E4AH A4B?42C C> 34C4A<8=4 8=
03E0=24>52>=58A<8=6A4?A4B4=C0C8>=>5+60=30=28C8I4=BC74A8B:B8=74A4=C
8=3>8=61DB8=4BB8=+60=300=38=508;8=6C>4BC01;8B70?A>24BBC>0BB4BBC74
E0;838CH>58=5>A<0C8>=BD??;843C>C7458A< *78B8=2;D34B508;8=6C>?4A5>A<
3D4 38;864=24 8=@D8A84B >5 C74 <43820; 2;8=82B A4;843 D?>= 1H C74 +60=30=
2;84=CB C> 0BBDA4 C7>B4 2;8=82B F4A4 ;468C8<0C4 *78B 0;B> 8=2;D34B 508;8=6 C>
C0:4 270A64 >5 A4@D4BC8=6 <43820; A42>A3B 8=2;D38=6 0D38>6A0<B 38A42C;H
5A><C744=C8C84BC70C0;;4643;H?4A5>A<43740A8=6C4BCB0=3C74FA8CC4=A42>A3B
0CC4=30=CC74A4C>  C8B5DAC74AA42><<4=343C70CC74>DAC58=3C70C?0AC=4AB
A>BB0=30AC;4CC508;43C>?4A5>A<3D438;864=248=@D8A84B>5A0507$DB>:4
0=3508;8=6C>70E402;40A0=3FA8CC4=D=34ABC0=38=6>5C74A>;474F>D;3?;0H
8=C74;8C860C8>= >A4G0<?;4F0B$A $DB>:4C>14;0FH4AA454AA8=62;84=CB
C>4=8=64A0AA8B>=0E8B0BBD<8=6C74;0F58A<F0B01;4C>34C4A<8=478B
4G02C ;460; BC0CDB 0B 0 ;0FH4A-74C74A 74 F0B C> 14 0 A454AA8=6 ;0FH4A >A
?4A5>A<8=63DC84B0BC74&>5>;;H=40A4A>BB0=30AC;4CC508;43C>
4BC01;8B7C74?A428B43DC84B$DB>:4F0BC>D=34AC0:4850=H 420DB4B><4
+60=30=2;84=CB>54=8=64A0AA8B>=0E8BF4A4=>CF>A:8=638A42C;HF8C7
$DB>:4 0=3 C74A4 F0B 0 1;DAA8=6 >5 ;8=4B A460A38=6 $DB>:4NB A4;0C8>=B78?
F8C7 	4027 	2;84=C 	0AC;4CC 	0=3 	A>BB 	508;43 	C> 	4BC01;8B7 	BD558284=C
2><<D=820C8>=BF8C7C7>B42;84=CBC>?A>?4A;HA4?A4B4=C0;;+60=30=2;84=CB 
><<D=820C8=6F8C72;84=CB?A8=28?0;;H1H4<08;>AC4GC>AC7A>D67$DB>:4
Case 3:19-md-02885-MCR-HTC Document 4190 Filed 12/05/25 Page 33 of 37
 	
8= 78B D=3458=43 A>;4 F0B B8<?;H 8=034@D0C4  *4;4?7>=4 2>=C02C >A 4E4=
14CC4A8=?4AB>=C>F=70;;<44C8=6B8=+60=30;8:4;HF0BC74;40BCC70CF0B
A4@D8A43C>2><?4C4=C;H0=3C7>A>D67;HA4?A4B4=CC78B6A>D?>52;84=CB 
  	=C7458ABC?0A06A0?7>5)42C8>= 	02CB>=?064C78BA4?>ACB4CB>DCC74
7D64 BD<B >5 <>=4H 8=E>;E43 8= C74 +60=30= 20B4B  *70C 5A0D3D;4=C
BD??>AC8=63>2D<4=CBF4A4BD1<8CC43C>02@D8A4C70C<>=4H5>A2;84=CB0=3
C748A;0FH4AB34<0=3BB86=85820=C022>D=C018;8CH0B8345A><B8<?;HA42>D?8=6
C74<>=4H *74>DAC8B24AC08=;H9DBC858438=>A34A8=6B0=2C8>=B0608=BCC74
4=8=64A 0AA8B>= 0E8B 58A< 0=3 -  #4F8B 0AA8B>= *0H;>A 0AC;4CC 0=3
-8;;80<A>BB  C8BC74A42><<4=30C8>=>5C78B)?4280;$0BC4AC70C- #4F8B
0AA8B>=14B0=2C8>=435>A78BA>;48=C78BD=?A>54BB8>=0;2>=3D2C8=0=0<>D=C
=>C ;4BB C70= C4= C7>DB0=3 3>;;0AB  	 	 C70C *0H;>A 0AC;4CC 0=3
-8;;80<A>BB14B0=2C8>=435>AC748AA>;4B8=0=0<>D=C=>C;4BBC70=CF4=CH
C7>DB0=33>;;0AB 	 	4027 027BD27B0=2C8>=B7>D;38=C74>?8=8>=
>5C74)?4280;$0BC4A140??;843C>C748=38E83D0;0=3=>CC74;0F58A< B5>A
C7458A<4=8=64A0AA8B>=0E8B8CB7>D;314B0=2C8>=43=>C;4BBC70=585CH
C7>DB0=33>;;0AB  	 
 	C8BC74A42><<4=30C8>=>5C78B)?4280;$0BC4AC70CC74''A468BCA0C8>=B0=3
0??;820C8>=B>5C744=8=64A0AA8B>=0E8B+60=30=2;84=CB14344<43E>83
0=38=E0;834G24?C5>A2;08<B   	 0=3 	DAC74A
0;; <>=4HB 0;A403H ?083 1H A>F=A44A 5>A 4027 >5 C74 E>8343 +60=30=
2;08<B <DBC 14 A4CDA=43 C> C74 B4CC;4<4=C ?A>6A0< 1H 4=8=64A 0AA8B>=
0E8B5>AC74A4?;4=8B7<4=C>5C745D=30=3C742><<>=14=458C7>;3102:
5D=3BB7>D;314F8C73A0F=5A><C74><<>=4=458CD=30=3A4CDA=43C>
C74B4CC;4<4=C?A>6A0<022>D=C E4AH20C46>AH>5C74B45D=3B8B38B2DBB438=
C78B((8=C7458ABC?0A06A0?7>5)42C8>= 	02CB>=?064 >F4E4AC>
2>=58A<022DA02H>5C740<>D=CBC74D=34AB86=43A42><<4=3BC70CC74>DAC
38A42C A>F=A44A C> 34C4A<8=4 4G02C;H F70C 5D=3B <DBC 14 A4CDA=43
2>=B8BC4=CF8C7C74D;C8<0C458=38=6B>5C74>DAC0=3?A>E834C74>DAC0=
8C4<8I0C8>= >A 022>D=C8=6  %0CDA0;;H 0B ?0AC >5 C78B A42><<4=30C8>= 0;;
+60=30= 20;2D;0C43 ?0H<4=CB C70C F4A4 74;3 D? 1H A>F=A44A ?4=38=6 0
A4B>;DC8>=>5C78B<0CC4AB7>D;3A4<08=F8C7C74B4CC;4<4=C?A>6A0< B5>A
C74  4G4<?C43 2;08<B 4027 F0B 0F0A3430   	 6A>BB ?0H<4=C ;4BB
 	5>AC74><<>=4=458CD=3;4BB 	5>A0CC>A=4H544B=4CC8=6
Case 3:19-md-02885-MCR-HTC Document 4190 Filed 12/05/25 Page 34 of 37
 	
4027  	 E4= C7>D67 C748A 2;08<B F>D;3 =>C 14 E>8343 85 C74 >DAC
03>?CBC74A42><<4=30C8>=>5C78B((C748<?02C>55A0D3D;4=C2;08<B
8B7D640=3C744=8=64A0AA8B>=0E8B58A<B7>D;314A4@D8A43C>38B6>A64
0=3A4CDA=C>C74)4CC;4<4=C'A>6A0<8CB0CC>A=4H544B8=4027>5C744G4<?C
20B4B )8=245>AC7>B42;08<BC74B4CC;4<4=CF0B2>=BD<<0C43C745D=3B
F8C774;3 5>A C74 ><<>= 14=458C 5D=3 B7>D;3 A4<08= F8C7 C74 2><<>=
14=458C5D=30=3C74 	=4CC>4027>5C742;08<0=CBB7>D;314A4C08=43
1HC742;08<0=CB  CB7>D;314=>C43C70C0;;5D=3BC70C0A4A4@D8A43C>14?083
102: C> C74 B4CC;4<4=C ?A>6A0< 5>A C74 4=8=64A 0AA8B>= 0E8B E>8343
+60=30=2;08<B<DBC14?0831HC70C58A<38A42C;HF8C78= 30HB>5C744=CAH
>5C74>DACNB58=0;>A34A8=C78B<0CC4A *74B4CC;4<4=C?A>6A0<F8;;=>C14
A4@D8A43C>F08C5>A0=HA42>D?<4=C1HC7458A<5A><C744=8=64A0AA8B>=
0E8B2;84=CB 
  *78B )?4280; $0BC4A 0BB4ACB C70C 8C 8B F8C7>DC 2>=CA>E4ABH C70C => >=4 F7>
34E>C43C8<40=3CA40BDA4B7>D;314D=2><?4=B0C43=>A140A4G?4=B4>DC>5
?>2:4C3DA8=6C744=C8A48=E4BC860C8>=>5C74+60=30=2;08<B34B86=435A><
C741468==8=6C>?A>E834C74>DACF8C7C748BBD4B0=3502CB4<143343F8C78=
C78B6A>D?>52;08<B8=C74B4CC;4<4=C?A>6A0<5>AF7827B748BC74D;C8<0C4
<0=064A *748=E4BC860C8>=B0=38=@D8A84B<034F4A4A4@D4BC43>AB0=2C8>=43
1HC74>DAC0=32;40A;HF8C78=C748=74A4=C0DC7>A8CH>5C74>DACC><0=064
C78B;8C860C8>=0=38CBB4CC;4<4=C?A>6A0< *74B4CC;4<4=C5D=3C742><<>=
14=458C5D=38=2;D38=6>C74A2>D=B4;0=32;08<0=CBB7>D;3=>C14<034C>
?0HC74C8<40=34G?4=B4>5C78B8=E4BC860C8>= B05DAC74AB0=2C8>=0608=BC
C74 4=8=64A 0AA8B>= 0E8B ;0F 58A< 5>A 8CB A>;4 8= C74 4GCA0>A38=0AH
28A2D<BC0=24>5BD1<8CC8=650;B4<43820;A42>A3BB7>D;314A4@D8A43C>?0H
C74 2><?4=B0C8>= 0=3 4G?4=B4B 0??A>E43 1H C74 >DAC C> 14 ?083 0C C74
38A42C8>=>5C74>DACC>C7>B4?4AB>=BC74>DAC0DC7>A8I43C>8=E4BC860C48=
B><4F0HC74<0CC4A>5C74+60=30=2;08<B B?0AC>5C7438A42C8>=1HC74
>DAC C78B )?4280; $0BC4A A42><<4=3B C74 >DAC >A34A 4=8=64A 0AA8B>=
0E8B?0HBD27C8<40=34G?4=B4B8=0C8<4;8=434283431HC74>DACC>C74
?4AB>=B>A4=C8C84B34283431HC74>DAC0=38=C740<>D=CB34283431HC74
>DAC *74>DACB7>D;3>A34AB0832><?4=B0C8>=0=3A48<1DAB4<4=C14?083
38A42C;HC>C74?0H44B8=38E83D0;;H>AC>C74B4CC;4<4=C?A>6A0<C>14?0BB43
C7A>D67C>C7>B4?0H44B0BC74>DAC344<B0??A>?A80C4 
Case 3:19-md-02885-MCR-HTC Document 4190 Filed 12/05/25 Page 35 of 37
 	 
  *78B)?4280;$0BC4A8B0F0A4C70C#403>D=B4;H;BC>2:0=3)4464A(0=3H
)0=B>< 0=3 A>F= A44A 8CB4;5 0;B> F>A:43 >= C78B 8=E4BC860C8>= >5 C74
+60=30=2;08<B *74A4>52>DAB4<0H14>C74AB>5F7><C78B)?4280;$0BC4A
8B =>C 0F0A4 0=3 B7>D;3 14 2><?4=B0C43  C 8B C74 A42><<4=30C8>= >5 C78B
((C70C0;;BD27?4AB>=B>A4=C8C84B0=30=H>C74ABF7><C74>DAC38A42C43
C>?4A5>A<F>A:>=C78B8=E4BC860C8>=03E8B4C74>DACC7A>D67$A )0=B><
>50;;C8<40=34G?4=B4B8=C74?DABD8C>5C74502CB5A><C74C8<4A>F=A44A
58ABC1460=C>8=@D8A48=C>C78B<0CC4AD=C8;8C8BA4B>;E43  C8BA42><<4=343
C70C4027=0<434=C8CH>A?4AB>=142><?4=B0C432>=B8BC4=CF8C7C748ADBD0;
A0C4>5?0H  5#403>D=B4;3>=>C70E40BC0=30A37>DA;HA0C44BC01;8B7438=
C78B;8C860C8>=8C8BA42><<4=343C70C68E4=C748AH40AB>5?A02C824C70CC74
A0C414B4C1HC74>DAC0C  	?4A7>DA 
  *74 ;0BC A42><<4=30C8>= >5 C78B )?4280; $0BC4A 8B C70C C78B (4?>AC 0=3
(42><<4=30C8>=C>64C74AF8C7C740CC027<4=CBC>8C0=30=H>A34ABC74>DAC
344<B ?4AC8=4=C 14 B4=C C> C74 ;>A830 0=3 ;010<0 0ABN 38B28?;8=0AH
2><<8CC44B5>A2>=B834A0C8>=>50=H02C8>=8CF>D;32>=B834A0??A>?A80C4 
>D=B4; 8B 74A41H =>C85843 C70C >1942C8>=B C> C74B4 ?A>?>B43 58=38=6B 0=3
A42><<4=30C8>=B<DBC1458;43F8C78=CF4=CH>=4 	30HB>5C7430C4>5C74(4?>AC
0=3 (42><<4=30C8>= =H 38554A4=C 3403;8=4 C70C <0H 0??40A >= C74 4;42CA>=82
3>2:4C 8B 5>A C74 >DACNB 8=C4A=0; DB4 >=;H 0=3 3>4B =>C 2>=CA>;  *74 >DAC F8;;
2>=3D2C0A4E84F>5C78B(4?>AC0=3(42><<4=30C8>=0=30=H>1942C8>=B
58;43C74A4C> 

0C43C78BC730H>5424<14A


 	 	 	 	 	 	(4B?42C5D;;HBD1&lt;8CC43 	 	
 	 	



B DavidRHerndon
)?4280;$0BC4A


Case 3:19-md-02885-MCR-HTC Document 4190 Filed 12/05/25 Page 36 of 37

 	 

&%%)
A>F=A44AD38C(4?>AC
4=8=64A0AA8B>=0E8B(4B?>=B4C>C74A>F=A44AD38C(4?>AC
G7818CBC>(4B?>=B4
A>F=A44A=0;HB8B>54=8=64A0AA8B>=0E8B(4B?>=B4
>0BC0;'028582 =E4BC860C8>=(4?>AC>5A0507$DB>:4
G7818CBC>>0BC0;'028582(4?>AC
A0=B2A8?C>50H;>A0AC;4CC =C4AE84F
*A0=B2A8?C>5-8;;80<A>BB =C4AE84F
A0=B2A8?C>5!40=84);4033 =C4AE84F
+60=30=40;C7$8=8BCAH#4CC4AA474>>3>2C>AB;8=82#824=B4


Case 3:19-md-02885-MCR-HTC Document 4190 Filed 12/05/25 Page 37 of 37

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.