Questão jurídica principal
Whether the appellants could rely on Art. 8 and 13 ECHR for family reunification with their daughters.
Decisão extraída
They could not, because the relevant age is the age when the Federal Tribunal decides, and the daughters were already adults.
Fundamentação extraída
For Art. 8 and 13 ECHR, the decisive date is the moment of the Federal Tribunal's ruling, not the date of the application. As the daughters were then of age, no protected family-reunification right existed.