Questão jurídica principal
Whether the novel allowed the respondent to be identified and thus constituted a personality infringement
Decisão extraída
The respondent was sufficiently identifiable within his close personal environment, so the personality right claim could proceed.
Fundamentação extraída
The court upheld subjective recognizability and held that, given the many real-life correspondences in the book, persons in the respondent's close circle could identify him from the fictional character.