Questão jurídica principal
Whether the appellate court lawfully refused a conditional sentence because future alcohol abstinence could not be monitored with absolute certainty.
Decisão extraída
No. The refusal was insufficiently reasoned and overstated the monitoring requirements; the case had to be reconsidered under the framework previously set by the Federal Court.
Fundamentação extraída
The Federal Court held that its earlier decision did not require a flawless or fully standardized monitoring system. The appellate court failed to explain why the required practical safeguards—such as independent medical checks and unannounced controls—could not be arranged in the конкретe case.