ATA/213/1997•Retroactive insurance premium and frivolous appeal fee
ATA/213/1997Tribunal de Justiça / Câmara Administrativa8 de abr. de 1997Dismissed
Extraído pela Omnilex
The court upheld the demand for an exceptional retroactive premium from insured persons, referring to its judgment of 2 August 1996. It also imposed a CHF 300 fee on the appellant for maintaining a frivolous appeal after the ATFA decision had been received.
LAMA art. 12; exceptional retroactive premium for insured persons; frivolous appeal. An exceptional premium retroactively charged to insured persons may be upheld where supported by the applicable statutory framework and prior case law. A party who maintains an appeal despite having received the pertinent appellate decision may be sanctioned with a modest fee for temerity; persistence in such circumstances justifies a cost sanction.
Descripteurs
ASSURANCE SOCIALE; AM; PRIME D'ASSURANCE; PROCEDE TEMERAIRE; ASSU
Normes
LAMA.12
Résumé
Selon l'ATFA du 2.08.96, une prime exceptionnelle et rétroactive pouvait être exigée des assurés. Emolument de Frs 300.- pour recours téméraire infligé au recourant qui a refusé de retirer son recours alors que l'ATFA lui était parvenu.
Extraído pela Omnilex
Whether an exceptional retroactive insurance premium could be charged to the insured persons under LAMA art. 12.
Yes. The court followed its prior case law of 2 August 1996 and held that such a premium could be required.
The court relied on the cited precedent and accepted the legality of the exceptional retroactive premium under the applicable statute.
Whether the appellant should bear a CHF 300 fee for a frivolous appeal after refusing to withdraw it despite receipt of the ATFA decision.
Yes. A CHF 300 fee for a frivolous appeal was imposed.
The appellant persisted with the appeal even after the ATFA decision had been communicated, justifying a temerary-appeal fee.
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.