ATA/23/1998•Standing of neighborhood association and traffic-calming plan
ATA/23/1998Tribunal de Justiça / Câmara Administrativa27 de jan. de 1998Dismissed
Extraído pela Omnilex
A neighborhood residents association challenged a communal road-traffic moderation project. The court held that the association had standing because its statutes included safeguarding the area's architectural and urban-planning character. On the merits, the court emphasized that it could not review expediency, only legality. Since the plan had been prepared after consulting residents and other nearby inhabitants and appeared to balance competing interests best among the alternatives, no abuse of discretion was found.
LR.7; standing of a neighborhood association and review of a road-traffic moderation plan; an association is entitled to appeal against a communal road-aménagement measure when its statutes pursue the preservation of architectural and urbanistic interests of the locality. In such matters, the administrative court reviews legality only and may not substitute its assessment of expediency for that of the authority. A moderation plan does not amount to an excess or abuse of discretion where it was adopted after consultation of affected residents and other nearby inhabitants and, among the solutions considered, best reconciles the competing interests (consid. 1-3).
Descripteurs
DOMAINE PUBLIC(PROPRIETE DE TOUS); CIRCULATION ROUTIERE; PRINCIPE JURIDIQUE; NORME; EXCES ET ABUS DU POUVOIR D'APPRECIATION; TPE
Normes
LR.7
Résumé
Consultés dans l'élaboration d'un projet de modération du trafic, les habitants riverains n'ont pas démontré que l'autorité intimée avait abusé de son pouvoir d'appréciation. A qualité pour recourir contre une mesure d'aménagement d'une route communale, une association d'habitants de quartier dont les statuts visent la sauvegarde des aspects architecturaux et urbanistiques des lieux. Le Tribunal administratif n'est pas compétent pour apprécier l'opportunité d'une décision et ne peut donc qu'examiner les aspects juridiques d'une mesure d'aménagement routier. Un plan de modération du trafic ne témoigne pas d'un excès du pouvoir d'appréciation de l'autorité, dès lors qu'il a été adopté après consultation des habitants et des autres riverains et que, parmi tous les autres projets envisagés, il concilie au mieux les différents intérêts en présence.
Extraído pela Omnilex
Whether the neighborhood association had standing to challenge the road-aménagement measure.
The association had standing because its statutes aimed at preserving the architectural and urban-planning aspects of the area.
An association of neighborhood residents may appeal against a communal road-aménagement measure when its statutory purpose covers the protection of the place's architectural and urbanistic character.
Whether the authority abused its discretion in adopting the traffic-calming plan.
No abuse of discretion was shown.
The administrative court could review only legality, not expediency. The plan was adopted after consultation of residents and other nearby inhabitants and, among the alternatives considered, best reconciled the competing interests.
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.