Housing allowance reimbursement only from proven income increase date

ATA/773/1998Tribunal de Justiça / Câmara Administrativa1 de dez. de 1998Partially Granted

Extraído pela Omnilex

Resumo Omnilex

The court examined whether recipients of a housing allowance had to reimburse the benefit because of increased income. It found that the alleged rise in earnings was not proven before 1 September 1997: the wife's wage had not been shown to exceed unemployment benefits earlier, and the husband's business profit increase was likewise not established before that date. Repayment could therefore only be considered from 1 September 1997 onward. The appeal was partially allowed.

Sumário Omnilex

RLGL.29; reimbursement of housing allowance after a change in income may be ordered only from the moment when the decisive increase in income is sufficiently proven. If the authority cannot establish an earlier effective improvement in the beneficiaries’ financial situation, retroactive recovery for the preceding period is excluded. The relevant date is the point from which the factual change affecting entitlement is demonstrated; mere assumptions or later evidence do not justify an earlier restitution claim.

Texto completo

Descripteurs

LOGEMENT; ALLOCATION DE LOGEMENT; LOGEMENT SOCIAL; OBLIGATION D'ANNONCER; RESTITUTION DE LA PRESTATION; CALCUL; MODIFICATION(EN GENERAL); REVENU; TPE

Normes

RLGL.29

Résumé

L'augmentation effective des revenus des recourants (salaire plus élevé que ses indemnités de chômage pour Madame et augmentation du bénéfice de l'entreprise pour Monsieur) n'ayant pas été démontrée avant le 1er septembre 1997, ce n'est qu'à compter de cette date qu'un remboursement de l'allocation de logement accordée pouvait être envisagé. Le recours a ainsi été partiellement admis.

Palavras-chave

housing allowancesocial housingreimbursementincome changeproofsocial benefits

Extraído pela Omnilex

Questões jurídicas principais extraídas pela Omnilex

Questão jurídica principal

From which date could repayment of the housing allowance be required after a change in income?

Decisão extraída

Repayment could be considered only from 1997-09-01, because the effective increase in income had not been proven before that date.

Fundamentação extraída

The court held that the decisive income increase was not demonstrated for any earlier period. The reimbursement assessment therefore had to start only when the change was established.

Housing allowance reimbursement only from proven income increase dateGerado por IA