cp-1994-0008•Recusal request became moot after self-disqualification and waiver
cp-1994-0008Tribunal Cantonal16 de nov. de 1994Other
Extraído pela Omnilex
In a recusal matter in case AC 94/029, the Vaud Administrative Court noted that Judge Eric Brandt had already self-recused and that counsel for Janine and Pierre Schmit waived the recusal of assessors Paul Blondel and Pierre Richard. The plenary court therefore removed the matter from the docket. It also ordered that the decision be rendered without court costs and granted the applicants CHF 500 in party compensation payable by the court treasury.
Recusal proceedings; spontaneous disqualification and waiver by the requesting party render the recusal request moot, so that the court may strike the matter from the roll. Where the parties obtain only partial success in such incidental proceedings, the court may deny court costs and award a limited party indemnity (consid. implied by the dispositif).
CANTON DE VAUD
TRIBUNAL ADMINISTRATIF
Arrêt
du 16 novembre 1994
sur la demande de récusation du juge Eric Brandt et des assesseurs Paul Blondel et Pierre Richard formulée par Janine et Pierre Schmit dans le dossier AC 94/029 (maintien d'un portail sur la digue du port privé du Château de Promenthoux)
Composition de la Cour plénière: M. Pierre Journot, président; M. Jean-Claude de Haller M. Etienne Poltier et M. Alain Zumsteg, juges; M. Pierre-André Berthoud, juge suppléant.
La Cour plénière,
vu la récusation spontanée du juge Eric Brandt en date du 27 octobre 1994,
vu le courrier du conseil des requérants qui, interpellé, déclare qu'il renonce à la récusation des assesseurs Paul Blondel et Pierre Richard,
considérant que les requérants obtiennent partiellement gain de cause en étant assistés d'un avocat,
I. raye la cause du rôle;
II. dit que la présente décision est rendue sans frais;
III. alloue aux requérants la somme de 500 francs (cinq cents francs) à titre de dépens à la charge de la caisse du Tribunal administratif.
mp/Lausanne, le 16 novembre 1994
Le président:
Pierre Journot
Le présent arrêt est notifié conformément à l'avis d'envoi ci-joint.
Extraído pela Omnilex
Whether the recusal request against Judge Eric Brandt and assessors Paul Blondel and Pierre Richard should still be adjudicated.
The court removed the case from the docket because the judge had already self-recused and the applicants renounced recusal of the two assessors.
The spontaneous recusal of Eric Brandt and the waiver by counsel as to Paul Blondel and Pierre Richard left no remaining dispute to decide.
Allocation of costs and party compensation in the recusal proceedings.
The decision was rendered without court costs and the applicants were awarded CHF 500 in party compensation payable by the Tribunal administratif treasury.
As the applicants obtained partial success, they were entitled to compensation, while no fees were charged for the decision.
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.