114 C 458/16•Right to legal protection in a number-porting claim
114 C 458/16Tribunal de Primeira Instância14 de fev. de 2017Direito civilOutro
Extraído pela Omnilex
In this first-instance civil matter, the Bonn Local Court addressed costs and the amount in dispute. It stated that a claim seeking to achieve an objectively impossible result lacks a need for legal protection and is inadmissible. That was the case where the defendant had named a telephone-number porting date coinciding with receipt of the court-cost advance. The court ordered the plaintiff to bear the costs under ZPO § 91a and fixed the amount in dispute at EUR 1,200.
ZPO §§ 91a, 269(3), fourth sentence; need for legal protection in an action seeking number porting. If it is evident that an action cannot, under any circumstances, secure the outcome sought by the claimant, the claimant lacks a need for legal protection and the action is inadmissible. This applies where the defendant has specified a date for porting the telephone number that coincides with receipt of the court-cost advance: the requested objective cannot be achieved through the proceedings. In allocating costs under § 91a ZPO, the court may take this evident lack of legal protection into account.
Entscheidungsdatum: 2017-02-14
Aktenzeichen: 114 C 458/16
ECLI: ECLI:DE:AGBN:2017:0214.114C458.16.00
Dokumenttyp: Beschluss
Spruchkörper: 114. Zivilabteilung
Normen: ZPO §§ 91 a, 269 Abs. 3 Satz 4
1.) Ist offenkundig, dass die Klage dem Kläger das begehrte Ziel unter keinen Umständen verschaffen kann, fehlt das Rechtsschutzbedürfnis und die Klage ist unzulässig.
2.) Dies ist jedenfalls dann der Fall, wenn die Beklagte für die mit der Klage begehrte Portierung einer Rufnummer einen Termin genannt hat, der mit dem Eingang des Gerichtskostenvorschusses zusammenfällt.
werden die Kosten des Rechtsstreits dem Kläger auferlegt (§ 91 a ZPO).
Der Streitwert wird auf 1.200,00 EUR festgesetzt.
Allocation of the litigation costs following the resolution of the dispute.
The plaintiff must bear the costs.
The action could not achieve the requested result because the defendant had set the porting date to coincide with receipt of the court-cost advance; the plaintiff therefore lacked a need for legal protection.
Assessment of the amount in dispute.
The amount in dispute is EUR 1,200.
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.